Skip to content

Removal of threads?

Featured Replies

Can a mod or admin tell me where my post has been moved to? or why its been deleted? as i cannot find it?

Thanks

Jake

  • Replies 28
  • Views 1.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I'm seeing a moved one about wheels, one that's called "Delete Please" that's been deleted, and one that's a link to ebay, general rule for those is links to ebay aren't allowed unless you're the seller.

  • Author

No Guy none of them,

Yeti -All the other are fine. Yeah its the one with the ebay link, I cannot see an issue with that one? it's rare you see a g40 thats rolled?! of interest to everyone surely and safety wise?!

+ Tanj90 has an ebay linked thread in here but that stays? ......

Thanks

Jake

Edited by quiksilver_jake

  • Author

Anyone?

No Guy none of them,

Yeti -All the other are fine. Yeah its the one with the ebay link, I cannot see an issue with that one? it's rare you see a g40 thats rolled?! of interest to everyone surely and safety wise?!

+ Tanj90 has an ebay linked thread in here but that stays? ......

Thanks

Jake

It will have been deleted in case someone on here is already bidding, obviously they wouldn't want too many people bidding against them. Tanj90's thread is still there because the car won't sell for the price that it is listed for so there is no issue of people bidding against each other.

Sorry Matt but thats possibly the worst excuse I've heard for a thread to be deleted. Why should the greed of one member looking for a bargain be put over the countless others on here that would be interested in it?

It's some thing that would be in the interest of the club, for members who might be interested in buying it and just as a general discussion topic. It's not very often that some thing like this pops up but we are not allowed to discuss it on CLUB POLO because some one wants to keep the bids down? There are countless threads on here about non polo's on eBay, yet we can't discuss an eBay auction for a crashed g40, one of the rarest, most sort after and most talked about types of polo we got over here?

How is it that a thread about a g40 on the bay is deleted yet this one isn't... http://www.clubpolo.co.uk/forum/index.php?showtopic=268878

And that's far from the only example of what's currently being discussed on here along the same kinda lines. could it be that some one with the power is interested in the G?...

Sorry Matt but thats possibly the worst excuse I've heard for a thread to be deleted. Why should the greed of one member looking for a bargain be put over the countless others on here that would be interested in it?

It's some thing that would be in the interest of the club, for members who might be interested in buying it and just as a general discussion topic. It's not very often that some thing like this pops up but we are not allowed to discuss it on CLUB POLO because some one wants to keep the bids down? There are countless threads on here about non polo's on eBay, yet we can't discuss an eBay auction for a crashed g40, one of the rarest, most sort after and most talked about types of polo we got over here?

I wasn't the one that deleted it, I'm sure whoever it was has their own reason.

general rule for those is links to ebay aren't allowed unless you're the seller.

And I didn't come up with that rule. The thread about the £6k also promotes more discussion than a thread about 'oh look, something for sale at a reasonable price'.

I don't think it does promote more discussion, you only have to look at the thread I posted about the mk2 loon, a link that you yourself joined in the discussion, there's as much discussion in that as there is the 6k one.

It's not just the price that will promote discussion, unusual content does just as well

Just one look through the sections here and you can easily find 3 or 4 eBay links to cars which clearly don't belong to club members.

So surely if the rule is "links to ebay aren't allowed unless you're the seller."

Then all the eBay links in general and polo chat should be removed not just a select few?

same old cp story tbh. Rules are made, then not enforced 100%. Either enforce the rule 100% or don't have the rule as its frankly a waste of time and only ends end pissing off forum users, who see other users getting away with it. cough, cough! for sale section, no bumping in 5 days cough!!

  • Author

This has totally pissed me off to be honest!

I thank Yeti and Mattloaf for at least trying to sort out this and point their point across but can I please have a response from who deleted it?

As Jon said above it's getting to be one rule for one and one for another! More to the point it seems to be the long standing members been the ones taking the hit over the newer members.....?!

I really would appreciate a decent response on this and I'm really fucked off!

Thanks

Jake

I've checked back and it was me for the reasons above.

same old cp story tbh. Rules are made, then not enforced 100%. Either enforce the rule 100% or don't have the rule as its frankly a waste of time and only ends end pissing off forum users, who see other users getting away with it. cough, cough! for sale section, no bumping in 5 days cough!!

You're right Jon, though if you're thinking in terms of a comparison to Polo3, that's a bit unfair, because a busy day on there is under 100 posts, so it's totally possible for the staff to read them all. The problem here is we have far, far more posts a day (click "Today's active topics" and you'll normally get about 10 pages back), so the few staff that actually do any moderating tend to moderate based on reported posts and what they come across while reading the site.

What I normally end up doing is if I spot a problem is look down the first page of threads in that section, so it does make things inconsistant (eg I might deal with 20 for sale threads one day, then 6 chat threads the next day, but miss a problem that's appeared in for sale).

Basically, if you see something wrong, click the report button and one of us is normally on it pretty quickly, but the staff that moderate don't really get the chance to read every thread.

*Gone for a look at the for sale section, and finish off sifting the genuine signups from the spammers in the 15 pages I found that needed doing last night.

I've checked back and it was me for the reasons above.

same old cp story tbh. Rules are made, then not enforced 100%. Either enforce the rule 100% or don't have the rule as its frankly a waste of time and only ends end pissing off forum users, who see other users getting away with it. cough, cough! for sale section, no bumping in 5 days cough!!

You're right Jon, though if you're thinking in terms of a comparison to Polo3, that's a bit unfair, because a busy day on there is under 100 posts, so it's totally possible for the staff to read them all. The problem here is we have far, far more posts a day (click "Today's active topics" and you'll normally get about 10 pages back), so the few staff that actually do any moderating tend to moderate based on reported posts and what they come across while reading the site.

What I normally end up doing is if I spot a problem is look down the first page of threads in that section, so it does make things inconsistant (eg I might deal with 20 for sale threads one day, then 6 chat threads the next day, but miss a problem that's appeared in for sale).

Basically, if you see something wrong, click the report button and one of us is normally on it pretty quickly, but the staff that moderate don't really get the chance to read every thread.

*Gone for a look at the for sale section, and finish off sifting the genuine signups from the spammers in the 15 pages I found that needed doing last night.

Not comparing the two forums in any way, shape or form. CP has 100 times the amount of people using it. But if you do want to get into the realms of comparing, one would have thought that seing as there are more users on CP, then you would have more Mods to deal with the extra traffic.

I've been down the route of reporting anything and everything I though was breaking the rules in the for sale section and the net result was that it annoyed certain CP mods and was told not to bother reporting them anymore.

  • Author

So if this "rule" cannot be enforced fully why enforce it all ? It's giving off the wrong impression to alot of members ...

That's fair enough Steve but from your post it seems not a lot has changed, there still seems to be mods not pulling their weight. I had a moan probably two years back about how people that are barely on here are still mods, low and behold the same mods are still mods and still barely on here. The old line 'mods have personal lives too' just doesn't really cut it because if they don't have time to do this they should just give it up and let some one else take over from them to help take the pressure off the mods that do sacrifice their time to sort the forum out.

That said is it not a bit silly to have a blanket ban on eBay adds if your not the seller? In the fs yeah totally but if some thing pops up that is rare and could provoke good discussion or help out forum members that might not otherwise spot it then surely that's not a bad thing?

Edited by Mclovin

I've checked back and it was me for the reasons above.

same old cp story tbh. Rules are made, then not enforced 100%. Either enforce the rule 100% or don't have the rule as its frankly a waste of time and only ends end pissing off forum users, who see other users getting away with it. cough, cough! for sale section, no bumping in 5 days cough!!

You're right Jon, though if you're thinking in terms of a comparison to Polo3, that's a bit unfair, because a busy day on there is under 100 posts, so it's totally possible for the staff to read them all. The problem here is we have far, far more posts a day (click "Today's active topics" and you'll normally get about 10 pages back), so the few staff that actually do any moderating tend to moderate based on reported posts and what they come across while reading the site.

What I normally end up doing is if I spot a problem is look down the first page of threads in that section, so it does make things inconsistant (eg I might deal with 20 for sale threads one day, then 6 chat threads the next day, but miss a problem that's appeared in for sale).

Basically, if you see something wrong, click the report button and one of us is normally on it pretty quickly, but the staff that moderate don't really get the chance to read every thread.

*Gone for a look at the for sale section, and finish off sifting the genuine signups from the spammers in the 15 pages I found that needed doing last night.

Not comparing the two forums in any way, shape or form. CP has 100 times the amount of people using it. But if you do want to get into the realms of comparing, one would have thought that seing as there are more users on CP, then you would have more Mods to deal with the extra traffic.

I've been down the route of reporting anything and everything I though was breaking the rules in the for sale section and the net result was that it annoyed certain CP mods and was told not to bother reporting them anymore.

I agree with that Jon...i got a warning from a Moderator about reporting threads aswell and was told to stop doing it.

Oh and it was Dknight who told me to stop...ClubPolo's very own self styled "Mod God"....

Edited by buster.g40

The thing is it's about perception. If the only person you ever notice deleting stuff is Dan, or me, then it's natural to come to the conclusion it's because they like deleting stuff. Likewise if you're the only person dealing with stuff and it feels to you like the same person's sending report after report, it can feel like they're having a pop at you.

Though to be fair, I read the post report, and while you were making a point, it did also look like you were having a pop at the staff, so Dan had one back.

To be honest though, that's not the sort of thing that I let bother me and every day's a new one for me, so I just put it that both sides of the arguement were in the past and I filed it under "forgiven, forgotten, filed under a heap of other crap", so can we set an end to it at that?

That's fair enough Steve but from your post it seems not a lot has changed, there still seems to be mods not pulling their weight. I had a moan probably two years back about how people that are barely on here are still mods, low and behold the same mods are still mods and still barely on here. The old line 'mods have personal lives too' just doesn't really cut it because if they don't have time to do this they should just give it up and let some one else take over from them to help take the pressure off the mods that do sacrifice their time to sort the forum out.

That said is it not a bit silly to have a blanket ban on eBay adds if your not the seller? In the fs yeah totally but if some thing pops up that is rare and could provoke good discussion or help out forum members that might not otherwise spot it then surely that's not a bad thing?

I'm not going to argue with that.

4 mods active in the past 30 mins. yeti: only one to reply to this thread

make of that what you will

I sometimes wonder why I don't use this forum from time to time. Then I see petty threads like this and I remember. If a bit of inconsistency on a forum for Polo's is all you lot have got to worry about then I'd love to have your lives!

Yep I live a truly amazing life, every morning I'm awaken by rays of majestic sunshine warmly caressing my face as blue birds pleasantly chirp outside my window... which is just the start of my heavenly and perfect daily existence :-D

If you don't like reading threads like this then I can't understand why you would click on a thread with a title that is only ever going to involve forum politics?

Edited by Mclovin

Like this Guy?

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.