Skip to content

Opinions on engine's (General discussion, No Technicalness)

Featured Replies

I suppose this goes out to the people who have tryed and tested!

I want some more poke, I've been used to a Golf Mk2 ABF which i recently sold for reasons unknown but hey...

I've gone back into time and bought another Polo GT a few weeks ago and dont get me wrong i love it as i did that last 2. But the little 3f is getting a bit boring now and i want some more poke.

I've looked into all the conversions a few years ago and recently. I can't decide which route to go down and have tried to weigh up the pro's and con's of each conversion...

I'll stick with 3 popular conversions -

AFH 16V (6n 16v)

AEE (6n 8v) Hybrid/GT Management

G40

Here's mine

AFH 16V (6n 16v) - Seems pretty cheap, fair bit of work involved, Good power increase but to me a well tuned GT is just as fast?

AEE (6n 8v) Torque monster, same again a fair bit of work involved, same again good power gains/torque being a winning factor and heard they are pretty fast.

G40 - Costs a bomb for a decent conversion in excess of £1000, good power gains and a lot of potential. The bad, temperamental, parts expensive?

Whats your opinions?

Holla ;)

Edited by Matty-H

  • Replies 50
  • Views 2.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

one you haven't listed is the AFH hybrid 1.6 a few chaps have done on here apparently producing very good power on bike carbs, can imagine that it would produce near ABF levels of power.

Edited by leonh

Something different? AAV turbo?

You missed out as well that a G40 is an easy drop-in conversion, and with a turbo conversion the "temperamental" side isn't so much of an issue.

There are plenty of advocates for the 16V conversions, but tbh to me it just seems like a lot of effort for not a huge amount of power unless you tune the heck out of it. And if you're doing that, you're into big power with a G40 for a similar spend. Plus if you think a 1.6 8v engine will be a torque monster, a G40 will give you a real shock!

Just my 2p. I considered a valver for mine years ago but decided the cost/arseache wasn't worthwhile for the power I'd get. I've done over 40,000 miles on the G40 engine with no mechanical issues, but I made sure I had everything serviced when I put it in.

Edited by Alex

Dont forget the Audi 4.2 V8 :lol:

A big spec GT might just have enough poke to trouble a standard afh but that's irrelevant cause you should be comparing like for like other wise its a pointless comparison. I've had both in pretty much standard trim and the GT wouldn't get a look in, not even close. Like wise I'd imagine a well set up bike carb'd afh would have no issues dismissing a big spec GT which probably cost as much to build.

Afh on standard injection is a nice little set up, G40 power for a fraction of the price, only reliability issues I had was a failed hall sender (later ones don't have this issue apparently), good for day to day driving and pulls nicely when you want to stretch its legs, pretty quick for what it is and is a great all round set up

1.6 afh/avy hybrid on standard injection, as above but with much more torque, probably more power too but the torque is the most obvious improvement making it even more competent for normal driving and much more fun when booting it. I'm running the wrong flywheel atm tho so I'm not really getting the best out of it but it really is a hoot to drive... Reminds me a lot of my kr mk2 golf in the power delivery

Alex g40 conversions really ain't worth doing these day, for the price you pay you might as well just sell your car and buy a full g40, they ain't much more than the conversions, save a load of effort and at least you can test drive it before buying :lol:

No 'charged experience here, tried a few bike carb'd engines though:

Carb'd 1.6 16v AFH was very good, traction not too bad and picked up well, blipped absolutely instantly and throttle response in gear was very impressive.

Not as much torque as carb'd AEE but more tractable - Didn't sound as good as AEE either. AEE just as instant but frustrating in the wet.

Looking forward to carb'd AVY, still off the road with some floor section missing atm whilst i sort custom front suspension though, if ever i get a day off, so no report on that yet.

Carb'd ABD sounded better than 16v, very economical, same nature as 1.6 AFH but obviously not as quick. Sweetest to drive in traffic.

The thing is, you can pick up a mk4 16v polo for so cheap if theres something wrong with it, that you can sell a few of the parts and usually make your money back as i did. My 16v didnt cost much just bits and bobs mainly

If the gti engine (or AFH/AVY hybrid) from the mk5 fits in without too much hard work, does this mean the tdi would aswell, engine mount wise etc. or do they differ a lot? I know there would be all the wiring and that but that's another story!

Don't really know the mk5 layouts, just think a tdi would be quite interesting.

  • Author
You missed out as well that a G40 is an easy drop-in conversion, and with a turbo conversion the "temperamental" side isn't so much of an issue.

There are plenty of advocates for the 16V conversions, but tbh to me it just seems like a lot of effort for not a huge amount of power unless you tune the heck out of it. And if you're doing that, you're into big power with a G40 for a similar spend. Plus if you think a 1.6 8v engine will be a torque monster, a G40 will give you a real shock!

Just my 2p. I considered a valver for mine years ago but decided the cost/arseache wasn't worthwhile for the power I'd get. I've done over 40,000 miles on the G40 engine with no mechanical issues, but I made sure I had everything serviced when I put it in.

Yea I forgot to mention that, obviously a lot of checking up and servicing and it'll last. But 'If' I ever go ahead with a G40 I would put the charger in the blue bin and stick a turbo on it. But then its more money unless you pick up a decent conversion minus the charger, and that can get expensive when you start talking about management and setting it up ect?

I love torque and I like revvy engines and there's not a lot with both, that's another problem for me... I know its going back to golfs, but I miss the characteristics on the ABF as it was fairly torquey, but after that magic 4.5k it pulled hard right through. But then again I prefered the low down torque of my old 2.0l AGG/PB engine which was brilliant around town and startling civic type r's low down :)

Although I suppose taking into consideration an AFH & AFH hybrid in a mk3 polo wouldn't be bad bottom end as they weigh naff all and its less to lug around.

Is hard to decide, I don't want to sell mine for a g40 as there daft money, and mine is a really good shell, good colour ect. I'm Not thinking long term on money I would probably loose as I want to keep this on for years tbh. But yet again I'm contradicting myself saying that because I can't justify shelling out 1k for a G40 setup the + Turbo and all that. But I dont mind messing around doing a more difficult conversion, spending less than half the money and getting good gains that way. I have done alot of engine swaps in various cars, including my old golf with the abf and other engines it had in it lol The work does not bother me as I've got plenty of time and experience to do it.

  • Author
The thing is, you can pick up a mk4 16v polo for so cheap if theres something wrong with it, that you can sell a few of the parts and usually make your money back as i did. My 16v didnt cost much just bits and bobs mainly

That's what I would do if i were to go down that route, get what I need, sell the rest and weigh the rest in and hopefully break even or end up with a rather cheap conversion :)

Guy, how does an AFH make as much as a G, both in standard forms? Isn't the AFH 100bhp and the G 115?

I'm looking at doing a TDi engine'd mk2. Just in the collecting stage atm whilst the 'loon gets done, picking up things as they come up but I have everything bar the exhaust and boost pipes. Oh and a shell. Soon to be sorted :wink:. Thomas on here had an mk3 with the same 1W in with a turbo strapped to it. Made 130bhp and over 200 lbft (or was it Nm?) torque iirc. The problem is the availability of the 1W engines. Even if you find a block, your going to struggle to find a working pump.

Or a hybrid ABD turbo. Currently collecting parts for this too. Although the pistons need machining to lower CR, the engines are cheap to come by. Turbos are peanuts if you wait about. Add in an R5 carb and suitable exhaust and your looking at more power than a standard G for a fraction of the price (my build has cost under £400, again with only the exhaust and boost piping to sort out). This route is unproven ground currently with only Tommo (that I know of) pulling it off.

On that note, does anyone have any more info on Tommos build? Boost pressures? Intercoolers he used? Any thing really

The thing is, you can pick up a mk4 16v polo for so cheap if theres something wrong with it, that you can sell a few of the parts and usually make your money back as i did. My 16v didnt cost much just bits and bobs mainly

That's what I would do if i were to go down that route, get what I need, sell the rest and weigh the rest in and hopefully break even or end up with a rather cheap conversion :)

its what i did, bought a valver that had been crashed into a kurb (bent wishbone ect) for 350, kept the engine, and sold the reast. made almost half my money back on the gearbox alone! the engine ended up costing me nothing!

Well I say standard, more like standard fitment in an early polo, I've only seen mikey using a cat and a after market air filter has to be used on Mk1-2 due to bonnet clearance with the standard afh airbox. The afh reacts well to both these with my mk3 giving around 110bhp, g40's are 113bhp

You can't really compare the standard mk4 power because its not in a mk4 and alterations are made when fitting in the earlier polo's to make them fit better, these alterations tend to give power increases

I think tommo was running some thing like 20psi and using a sierra cosworth ic iirc

Edited by Mclovin

20psi? Fecking hell! I wondered how he was getting such ridiculous power from it. I'v just bought his old crank and pistons, so at least I know they will take a beating (for how long is another matter).

And i see what you say about transferring the AFH into the mk2. What alterations need to be made, besides the usual bike carbs (which arent essential, obviously)

grind the arb mount, put mk4 pulley on mk2 alternator, engine mount plate if your 'not a pikey' thats all i can think of

engine mount plate if your 'not a pikey'

Dont have to be a pikey to not bother - worked fine for me :lol:

The PY engine may only have a peak horsepower output of 113, but I doubt an AFH's torque curve is anything like the G40s.

I'm still waiting for someone to do a 1.4TDI, chipped up to 180Nm or so would be a lot of fun in a Mk2 ;)

If thats all the mods that eric has said, how do they increase power to G40 levels?

Yeti, with the early 1W, remapping isnt necessary as its all mechanical injection. Apparently fiddling with the pump and adding a turbo is all thats needed. Guy, you used to fiddle with the Jetta's pump didnt you? Same sort of idea?

Guy fiddles with lots of things!

1W's are a bit too thin on the ground for my liking, I've had a good read at Thomasz' 1W turbo, and I don't dislike it as an idea, but there's something about bring a 1.4 TDI to life in a mk2 really sparks my interest.

Did you not read my post si? :lol:

Tuned 1.4 tdi in an early polo would be the tits, I know some one on here that was considering it for his mk1 polo although I think that idea has long since passed which is a shame

Edited by Mclovin

Thomas is a 1.4 tdi. Or do you mean one from a 6n? I've asked about these so many times as i fancied putting one in (before I found the 1w) but could never get a straight answer. As I've never actually seen one, its hard to say if it would fit. ETKA may give an idea on fitment and mountings?

The PY engine may only have a peak horsepower output of 113, but I doubt an AFH's torque curve is anything like the G40s.

You can't have every thing max lol, but the same kinda peak power as a g40 in a mk3 for little over £100 compared to the £1k+ cost of a g40 conversion wasn't a bad accomplishment imo

If thats all the mods that eric has said, how do they increase power to G40 levels?

Yeti, with the early 1W, remapping isnt necessary as its all mechanical injection. Apparently fiddling with the pump and adding a turbo is all thats needed. Guy, you used to fiddle with the Jetta's pump didnt you? Same sort of idea?

you said bike carbs, so itd have about 10 bhp more than a g40 if tuned right. most people seem to get between 120-125 from the afh

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.