Skip to content

English vs Germans

Featured Replies

When i was browsing through one of the other threads i noticed someone posted about a german polo forum so i had a quick browse through and i just couldnt believe the quality of cars they produce. Does anybody else think that we are so far behind with our cars over here? I like the scene over here but the most we ever seen to do to an 86c is either G40 it or an AFH lump and then stick some wheels on, while over there they seem to be doing all sorts of crazy engine swaps and really going for it with every aspect of a polo.

How come we are so for behind?

This was the forum i was looking through the build threads on

http://forum.polomagazin.de/index.php

  • Replies 63
  • Views 3.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Our limitation is that our servo's and master cylinders are on the wrong side for most of the engine swaps. :lol:

You can fit a VR6 into a LHD polo, but it wont fit in a RHD one.

  • Author

surely that cant be the only thing limiting us to creating great cars. it just saddens me a little that we cant even seem to come close to what they are churning out. I've always been proud of my cars like most of everyone else on here but looking through some of their threads makes me feel ashamed. It seems like only golfs in this country get the love whereas they leave nothing untouched.

That's a bullshit excuse tbh, if you can fit a vr6 in a mk3 then working around a servo should be no problem

Infact, problem solved

universal%20pedal%20box.jpg

No servo and utilize the vr6's hydro clutch. People bitching about how it would handle shit and would be pointless but the Germans don't seem to think so. Tbh people with the sort of money to do that shit over here would rather spend all that money on wheels and air ride. We are so far behind them in term of engine swaps its unreal, you just have to look at some of the German cars one here to see that

Agreed, it's not always about the engine. Although I don't know where half the poeple who do the crazy stuff they do over there get the time/money for it.

It's just a different scene.

The turbo'd vr6 6n on here is a sign that some people are doing different things tho, just a shame it wasn't in a 86c and running 4x4 :lol:

Edited by Mclovin

It might be the fact that the british economy is a pile of crap compared to germany.

Seems to be more people are worried about fuel ecomony and running diesels than stupidly over powered twin engine conversions (like the twin vr6 lupo from Poland or Lithuania or somewhere!!!!)

That's no excuse either, the British economy was booming up until the crash

That's a bullshit excuse tbh, if you can fit a vr6 in a mk3 then working around a servo should be no problem

Infact, problem solved

http://espimages.biz/2386/I/149/09/univers...pedal%20box.jpg

No servo and utilize the vr6's hydro clutch. People bitching about how it would handle shit and would be pointless but the Germans don't seem to think so. Tbh people with the sort of money to do that shit over here would rather spend all that money on wheels and air ride. We are so far behind them in term of engine swaps its unreal, you just have to look at some of the German cars one here to see that

Dude, Your not supposed to give away secrets of how to get around problems :lol::lol::lol:

It cant be hard to put the servo on the other side anyway, most small cars have them there from Corsas to 206's, i'd have put one on the passenger side with a relay bar if my master cylinder was a problem, but it isn't.

No, the main problem with VW tuning is the VW scene and it's bias to poncified modding. It's all about image and looks half the time, you rarely see this shit on Classic Ford or mini forums - other marques seem more often treated to ballsy mods with no tardyness to chopping the shell up and making shit fit. VW's? Slam it to the floor with some Scania wheels and put some US spec headlamps in, replace the roof lining with a sheepskin rug and bob's your auntie.

People look at mine and say, "You into your volkswagens then?" I'm like nah mate, just all the XR2's rotted away.

Don't get me wrong, there are some hardcore motors with VW badges on, Polos even, but they're one hell of a minority amongst the tat because so much of the skill pool is elsewhere - probably put off by the cult/rat/euro/US/etc/etc VW scene.

Don't forget that these guys have to get through a TUV too, that makes our MOT look like a walk in the park. But it does mean that most mods have a premium price and the halfords specials you see over here would never get on the road. That said insurance is done differently there so the costs balance

There are good cars about, you just need to get around the fact that people do what they want. Let them get on with it

the german cars are that quality because there having a TUV test and that,s not cat-pis as they say in the nederlands!!

almost everything that they build ore change will be on the papers...

The polomagazin forum is very very interesting but www.polotreff.de is definitely as good but on the polomagazin forum is only Polo1 2 and 3 :)

anybody of you have heart of the www.golf1.info forum? there is some sick shit on with golfs scirocco,s and other kind of Volkswagens...

I myself look more often on the german forum then on the nederland forum :D more too see..

on the www.berg-cup.de are also very nice products to buy for polo ore golf..

Gr Richard

Edited by richard16vg40

Netherlands is by no means dry though, check out Walter's 1303 beetle on germanlook.com. amazing

how do you mean Dry through? i dont get it :oops: lots of water in Holland.. hehehe

But i The nederlands are a Couple of good projects and driving show cars too..

example the polo6n bi/turbo from Jarno,s friend Jeroen is very very Nice build...

also there is driving a polo 1.3i turbo with 280bhp!! genesis from Ron, also very sweet car..

and off course other Vw,s Like golf1 and corrado, but polo not soo much..

the best thing in the nederlands are the Coffieshops and tulips :p

By dry I mean a lack of quality cars there, but I certainly wouldn't say that at all. Perhaps in the Polo world but there are some amazing creations coming out from Beetles to hotrods/volksrods

And Richard you have the most expensive water on the world. It is packed in red and it is called "Holland Tomaten" here in germany. :lol: :lol: :lol:

And you are right with what you said.

Here we have TÜV and everything has fit together to become streetlegal.

4 example .....hmmmm..... lets take something stupid...... spacers.... nice tiny little parts.... u on the island put them on and drive around.... haha you lucky bastards... here it has to be streetlegal. So just with wheels which are allowed listed in the spacer's permission papers or what the guy @TÜV allows to use combinated with your wheels. I use (have to use them) 5mm spacers on the front so my revolution wheels don't touch the brakesystem..... haha when i swap my wheels against others for winter, i can but it is not allowed to use the spacers, even not with my original wheels which were on the polo when it came from factory. They are listed in my papers combinated with the revolution wheels.... You see that example is just for some fuxxxng spacers.....

Let's take an engineswap 4 example....

Muhaaaarrrrrrrrrr you take an 1,8T and put it into the enginebay and that's it..... haha i am glad we have the TÜV.... for our all safety..... here we can do the same.... but we have to follow some rules.

We have to have the right dimensioned brakesystem..... (a reason that german mk4 16V always had discs on the rear!)

We have to make sure the speedometer shows the correct speed (combinated with different wheelsizes like 13", 16" and 17")

We have to make sure the emissions are the same or better than the emissions from the original engine.....

There are so many things we have to obey to.

I have seen also so many scrap polos on all the poloshows i have been to, the most of them wouldn't be streetlegal on german streets.....

When you see a german streetlegal 1.8T Polo mk4 on a show, you can be sure for 99% that the conversion is done right and safe, on a british poloshow i just start to think how some cars do still exist with a big and strong engine and brakes a 1.3Liters 55BHP Polo has got from factory back in the 80's..... i just start to think all the time.

So when you build/convert something, you have to do it right here in germany, so the TÜV-M8 can list everything in the carpapers to make it streetlegal, otherwise no registration and without a registration you cannot move the car...... if you do that anyway you drive around with no insurance.....

OKOK not the best example... but that's what also Richard means and he's absolutely right....... you have fluffy laws.. and now don't tell us about your MOT..... what i have heard in the past few years your MOT is..... bullshit.... just my opinion.

Also when i read the PVW Mag, they are all good and quality made.... but just a part of these cars would be streetlegal in germany...... (the same counts for german cars shows in german VW Mags.... for magazines people do silly things to their cars)

Dank je wel and c u @MIVW

cheers

Christian6N

  • Author

That's a point well made. It just goes to show how easy we have it over here and we still can't make anything as crazy as the Germans.

the german scene is a lot more mature than ours. they actually take their cars seriously.

I think the majority of this boils down to money though at the end of the day.

Germanys economy has been booming for years, not once have I heard of a german crash or market instability.

Over here for the past 5-10 years there has been something about a stock market instability in the news, or something saying we all have no money.

Even when our economy is booming it is nowhere near what germany is like.

Hats off to the germans for their cars and everything but bear in mind where most of the formula one teams are based. Also bear in mind the fact that the majority of the good engineers and designers, in top level motorsport, are british.

Just a pitty our economy doesnt support a nation of engineering excellence. The germans have somehow got that down.

Don't think that the average Joe public is affected too much by that though. Look at the number of cars on the road here that have had modifications done. It's just about attitude, law and differing opinion.

And we do do some engineering here, quite a bit in fact, but again its the people on the street that make up the majority of forums not those in top end jobs.

Perhaps it is the people involved and their view on what is good.

I think mikey has it right. The vw watercooled 'scene' (as much as I hate the word) is made mostly of youngsters with minimal money and limited skills. However, look across to the aircooled, and there's much more going on over there, with many of the members being more veteran. On top of this is the image of the 'scene' in the uk too. My brother for example doesn't understand why I bother with polos at all, or even any vw. For him, the iconic cars are fords, and I think this is a view shared by many who have the skills to create decent cars. Vws are for posing and lowering. There's even the common sticker that some douches plaster their windows with; 'low and slow'. Says it all

But that happens on the aircooled side too!

Of course, no car type is going to be exempt. But the folk I know, the chaps on the forums and the shows are much more laid back with as much as an interest in engineering as well as looks

I wish we had something like TUV over here...

Problem here is, people that asses cars with mods etc haven't a fucking clue about what they are assessing lol. Sounds like TUV assessors over in Germany actually know their stuff??

Our MOT's are bullshit, they all differ, one tester could pass a car that another tester would fail on a large list of things.

The thing about spacers seems a little over the top though.

People seem to blame everything on the economy these days. Cars with crazy engine conversions are still being built in other scenes, let's just face it as a scene we are very much image based, and that really is the long and short of it.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.