Skip to content

Advice or knowledge on a Polo SDI if you will.......

Featured Replies

Hey all, I'm currently looking to buy the new Mrs a car for around £1K.

I've found a W plate polo sdi for £1100 locally which seems ok. Its got 106K on the clock and full mot.

Anyway, I'm just asking if anyone knows of any common faults with these? Or any known troublesome issues?

I started it up just now and it seemed quite noisy but I've never owned a diesel before and I gather they are alot more noisy than a petrol engine anyway?!! It seemed to calm down once it had run up to temperature anyway.

theres also a Fiat seicento abarth sporting which, for some reason, I really like!! :finger:

Any ideas, tips or advice greatly appreciated. :thumbsup::smiley:

IMAG1602.jpg

IMAG1603.jpg

IMAG1604.jpg

IMAG1608.jpg

IMAG1609.jpg

IMAG1611.jpg

Edited by snifferdog

  • Replies 10
  • Views 1.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

The SDi is slow and noisy, the recent success of diesels has proven they really needed a turbo, you want the 1.4TDi version.

Or your wife does, depending on who's choice it is.

I had a Fiat Seicento Sporting ten years ago, three years old with 22k miles on the clock.

It was superb! Hilarious fun to drive, i drove all over the country every week just for the hell of it. Basically because it used no fuel, there was no reason why not. Giving me a taste for such small light go-karts it effectively put me in the car i have now - i knew old VW's were better built, and light weight was the way forward for me.

Which puts me onto my concern with the Fiat. How have they aged? Fiat's generally age badly.

Sure it's an Arbath? They got a horrid bodykit which causes rust, and they got pig-ugly 14in wheels. That's it.

You want the normal Sporting that seems to be (phone screen is tiny but i can see the better 13in wheels).

And don't get power steering - the steering is heavier than the manual steering version! It's such a light car that PAS was just for marketing.

Oh, and don't buy a dented grey one - these are all cheap and you want the best one you can find. So be picky.

Mine was black, one of the best colours. There was a more popular colour which worked well - but do ask the wife before getting a yellow one..

first of all, hello :D

secondly, avoid the fiat like the plague! trust me, it's cheap for a reason...

and as a proud owner of an SDi polo for the last 3 years, yes the SDi engine is very noisy and can be sooty (only when you put your foot down, you can see dust coming the the back of your car, this is more easily seen at night with a car behind you)

but the benefits do outweigh the cons

- it has similar power to that of a 1.4 petrol (of a similar ages car)

- for plodding around town, to the shops and back etc, a tank of fuel can last a month! (based on my experience of a full tank and driving about 10 miles everyday)

- the SDi engine is bullet proof, i've heard that they are good for at least 300,000 miles!

- because it is a diesel, the power delivery is very different from a petrol; the rev range is from 0-5300, but for the best response from a non-turbo diesel, the engine needs to be in-between 2000-3500 revs, as that is where the 'power bubble' is i.e. if you want to over take, acceleration etc. but for cruising around at 30mph, just stick it 4th or for 40+ in 5th

common problems?

- drive the car and see if the gear box is smooth (a little bit notchy is fine)

- ask the dealer if the pedal box has been replaced over the car's life (a factory fault, and a recall in 2004 to fix this)

- check to see if the reflectors in the headlights(the shiny silver bits) are loose (can wiggle the reflector left to right/ up and down)

- as from the pictures, the clear part of the headlights are faded

^^^ those problem above are what i have on mine: i had to replace the gear box (as it was a dog when i bought it), the pedal box was NOT replaced on mine, the reflectors in my headlights are loose and my headlights have faded

if all is well, ask to see if the dealer can replace the headlights for you at that price

if not, i bought this a few days ago, and i am waiting for it in the post, if it any good, i'll let you know

The SDi is slow and noisy...

i wouldn't say its slow, its just not particularly fast haha :D

it beats having a 1L or 1.2L petrol ( had many races at school with my mates and their corsa's, micra's etc )

its only noisy at idle and when you're ragging the nuts off it, other than that it's acceptable :)

had cordoba sdi and seicento 1.1, seicento was realy good car, but sdi is very economic, also it's not so slow, think its faster than 1.0 or 1.2 petrol polos. sold the cordoba to my mates, and she done now about 200k miles without any issues with easly 50-60mpg!!! go for diesel mate.

I own one myself and can't really fault it, its done 123,000 miles and never skips a beat. Also mine does not smoke that bad at all really ( I have just had a new particulate filter though). Very good mpg on long runs but only a little better than my petrol 1.4 8v around town.

Can hit 65mpg doing solid motorway but it's gotta be cruising for a long time!

A few problems I found comparing to my 1.4 8v 6n2:

- Vibration caused by worn 3rd engine mount - £30 fix

- Rear bushes are on their way out (possibly caused by lows) - Replaced with polybushes £50

- Brakes are pretty poor - this might be because previous owner fitted low quality ones or due to the extra weight. New discs and pads and a fluid flush should sort it.

- Gearbox is leaking oil from somewhere - i don't think this is a common problem though.

All in all I can't really fault it though, it has done 15,000 miles in the past year and never missed a beat.

I have changed the oil and filters every 5000 though as I am a bit mad.

Edited by racer-ev

...Also mine does not smoke that bad at all really ( I have just had a new particulate filter though)...

SDi's dont have particulate filters...? is it an after market one?

...Also mine does not smoke that bad at all really ( I have just had a new particulate filter though)...

SDi's dont have particulate filters...? is it an after market one?

CAT then, one or the other!!! :retard:

Nothing aftermarket, just needed a new exhaust so I asked for it to be done at the same time

  • Author

Thanks for the help guys. I'll go back and have a better look tomorrow!

Thanks for the help guys. I'll go back and have a better look tomorrow!

np :D

...Also mine does not smoke that bad at all really ( I have just had a new particulate filter though)...

SDi's dont have particulate filters...? is it an after market one?

CAT then, one or the other!!! :retard:

Nothing aftermarket, just needed a new exhaust so I asked for it to be done at the same time

:retard: <-- thats me ha

my bad?

Christ, stuff being a new wife to you lot!

If you bought me a ten year old Volkswagen diesel that was noisy, smoky and went like a 1.4i 8v then i'd buy you a divorce!

Shit the bed you can find something fun for a grand! And the Seicento might not win an oscar but it's one hell of a step in the right direction from the '200k' '60mpg' boredom you lot are depressing me with!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.