Skip to content

stop the press!

Featured Replies

not sure if this is the right place but here it goes, I've changed my mind and not selling or crapping my Schnooks :D my question is tho, she had water in the engine,I know it's one or more valves that need replacing, so what to do? do I replace the engine block or just the valves and headgasket? I've got a friend who's a mechanic to help me with either job,I'm just looking at the costs, as I'm having to take the engine out or apart I thought it's a wise idea to also replace the cambelt whilst I'm in there,what would you guys recommend?

I changed my mind as I just love that bloody car too much and have put too much blood sweat n tears in her,not to mention money lol

thanks :-D

  • Replies 23
  • Views 1.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Strip the head down and assess the damage first make sure there's no bits you haven't seen that are fucked also make sure the pistons haven't hit the valaves and damaged them.

My opinion would be to rebuild it as if you source another head it may already have problems and tap etc. will be costly though!

Definitely replace the cambelt and personally for piece of mind I would also put a water pump on it.

Price wise I recon between £200-300, I brought a head set for mine (all seals required, head bolts etc) cambelt kit, water pump, oil + coolant etc for £170. But depend what you need really, just giving you an idea :thumbsup:

Edited by matt01

  • Author

cool! thanks for that, am trollying ebay for parts at the mo,didn't think of the waterpump, and yes you're right about replacing it with engine block and potential problems :)

Go to dale (lupoboz) in traders section I've just rebuilt mine and new valves and his prices are good and genuine vw

  • Author

cheers!! that would help, am still scratching funds together but will deffo pay him a visit ;)

Your welcome, if the engine has a load of bent valves just source a new engine as it will be cheaper

Really?

What actually happened to your engine? Maybe I missed it but it appears lots of people are giving out advice without knowing the problem that needs fixing.

  • Author

I drove through a flood that was a little deeper then I expected,she sucked in some water, I managed to get most of it out and drove her for another week,but then there was lots of white smoke and loss of power,she will still start but hardly drive,my friend the mechanic had a look and said the valves would be the problem,I haven't opened her up yet as I didn't dare to take the cam belt off and only got as far as taking the head off

should have scrapped it its only a 6n plenty more to choose from :lol:

Oh dear, I'm sorry to hear that.

If there's been water in your cylinders, its unlikely that there's bent valves. You'll have a higher chance of bent conrods I'm afraid, as water ingress causes 'hydrolock' i.e the cylinder's compression goes way up if theres liquid in there too. This will only happen if the valve is shut, and if it's shut it can't bend.

Post up a few pictures of the bottom of the head and we will have a look.

When cranking the engine by hand (using the bolt on the end of the crankshaft) do all pistons rise to the same height?

Did you do a compression test before removing the head? Did you shut the engine off the moment the engine died or did you try to restart it?

  • Author
should have scrapped it its only a 6n plenty more to choose from :lol:

thanks for that, I have nothing left n live in a static caravan in the middle of nowhere,my kids have been taken away by that f-ing bully of an ex who still has the house n savings and all that, I can't even get to a solicitor to fight him,I need a car to be able to get myself out of this mess and rebuild my life,but without one I can't get anywhere,not even back to my own country and forget how I've been treated in this one! scrapping my baby is not gonna help me get there,some proper advise would,or maybe you can get me another one?! :x

rant over

Runforrestrun, I haven't been able to check the cylinders yet,had the RAC out when it happened,ofcourse all they could do was tow me to friends house,where I took off the glowplugs and that way squirt the water out, I'm hoping my mechanic will be able to sort her, like I said,I'm still hoping to scratch the funds together,but at the mo I'm totally stuck :-(

id scrap it too tbf..

  • Author
:-(
Maybe I missed it but it appears lots of people are giving out advice without knowing the problem that needs fixing.

Apart from the fact she said "I know one or more valves that need replacing" its hard to not give advice to that kind of statement even not seeing the car so before you criticise other people's advice please read the thread correctly... And I'm not starting a bitch fight, just hate when people put snidy comments (or at least that's how it reads)

Anyhoo... Schnooky there's no better feeling then bringing your dead car back to life! I completely understand when you just can't give up on a car and must see it fixed, that's probably the only reason mine is still on the road :thumbsup:

Edit: spelling

Edited by matt01

  • Author

thanks Matt ,its nice to see some peeps still believe :)

Maybe I missed it but it appears lots of people are giving out advice without knowing the problem that needs fixing.

Apart from the fact she said "I know one or more valves that need replacing" its hard to not give advice to that kind of statement even not seeing the car so before you criticise other people's advice please read the thread correctly... And I'm not starting a bitch fight, just hate when people put snidy comments (or at least that's how it reads)

Anyhoo... Schnooky there's no better feeling then bringing your dead car back to life! I completely understand when you just can't give up on a car and must see it fixed, that's probably the only reason mine is still on the road :thumbsup:

Edit: spelling

Fair comment mate, but if nothing else, I was wondering how she had come to the conclusion that one of more valves need replacing, as I've previously said, there's no way a valve could bend from water ingress that I know of. Everyone has jumped on the bandwagon without establishing the route cause or confirming the symptoms.

I just wanted to check with her as the last thing I'd want is to get the wrong advice, and as a result she shells out loads of money fixing the wrong thing.

I drove through a flood that was a little deeper then I expected,she sucked in some water, I managed to get most of it out and drove her for another week,but then there was lots of white smoke and loss of power,she will still start but hardly drive,my friend the mechanic had a look and said the valves would be the problem,I haven't opened her up yet as I didn't dare to take the cam belt off and only got as far as taking the head off

so you've got the head off?

if you upload a few pictures of the bottom of the head we can have a look for you.

should have scrapped it its only a 6n plenty more to choose from :lol:

thanks for that, I have nothing left n live in a static caravan in the middle of nowhere,my kids have been taken away by that f-ing bully of an ex who still has the house n savings and all that, I can't even get to a solicitor to fight him,I need a car to be able to get myself out of this mess and rebuild my life,but without one I can't get anywhere,not even back to my own country and forget how I've been treated in this one! scrapping my baby is not gonna help me get there,some proper advise would,or maybe you can get me another one?! :x

rant over

That obviously came across wrong.

My reasoning behind what I said is this; Surely it would be quicker, more simple and possibly cheaper (once you take into account the money you will get back from scrap) to just get rid of the one you have and simply buy another one?

And if what you just said is true then any car would be better than the one you have now, even a shitty fiesta or saxo is better than what you have now, and they can be bought for cheapo prices

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/adv...224hw?logcode=p

Where are you? If your situation is as bad as it sounds I don't mind coming over, help you strip it for a day and see what the problem is, then we can find out the problem and I can guide you from there

  • Author
should have scrapped it its only a 6n plenty more to choose from :lol:

thanks for that, I have nothing left n live in a static caravan in the middle of nowhere,my kids have been taken away by that f-ing bully of an ex who still has the house n savings and all that, I can't even get to a solicitor to fight him,I need a car to be able to get myself out of this mess and rebuild my life,but without one I can't get anywhere,not even back to my own country and forget how I've been treated in this one! scrapping my baby is not gonna help me get there,some proper advise would,or maybe you can get me another one?! :x

rant over

That obviously came across wrong.

My reasoning behind what I said is this; Surely it would be quicker, more simple and possibly cheaper (once you take into account the money you will get back from scrap) to just get rid of the one you have and simply buy another one?

And if what you just said is true then any car would be better than the one you have now, even a shitty fiesta or saxo is better than what you have now, and they can be bought for cheapo prices

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/adv...224hw?logcode=p

sorry yes, it did,I'm in a real shitty situation and my car is just the last thing I'm holding onto right now, I wasn't joking when I said I've got nothing left :( and that just hit the sore spot ,I did try to scrap her,but even on Ebay the highest I could get for her was £135, I cant get another car for that, I really am at an all time low,it's my little one's birthday in 2 weeks,then xmass with 2 kids,I just haven't got the funds ,soz I had a rant :)

I haven't had the head off yet as I haven't got right tools etc, I was told I can have the head reconditioned if it was damaged,but again, I need to make the cash for that first, I'm hoping my mechanic will pop round soon to see what exactly is the problem,so far it's just been a guess on the symptoms she is showing

I'm close to Leominster even just around from breakers yard lol,I even asked for a job there as i could walk it,hoping they'd let me work for some of the parts,but no jobs available right now

thanks so far guys, you've been of much help already, now all i need to wait for is the funds, fingers crossed! :D

Viv

Before you do anything else or pay a single penny, disconnect the fuel pump fuse, take the glow plugs out, and crank it on the starter to get any water that's in there out. The sooner you do this the better as you don't want water sitting in your bores.

DO NOT try to start it before doing this.

DO NOT dismantle the engine without having a compression test first - INSIST on this if your mechanic doesn't volunteer it, as this is a sure fire way to tell what the problem is. I'd put money on the fact that your head is fine, and if any part of the engine has failed, it will likely be a con rod.

Wish you all the best.

  • Author
Before you do anything else or pay a single penny, disconnect the fuel pump fuse, take the glow plugs out, and crank it on the starter to get any water that's in there out. The sooner you do this the better as you don't want water sitting in your bores.

DO NOT try to start it before doing this.

DO NOT dismantle the engine without having a compression test first - INSIST on this if your mechanic doesn't volunteer it, as this is a sure fire way to tell what the problem is. I'd put money on the fact that your head is fine, and if any part of the engine has failed, it will likely be a con rod.

Wish you all the best.

thats exactly what I did ,but drove her after this and made any damage most likely worse,my mechanic is a mate who does it as a hobby,he's great,also a great welder and always knows ways around expensive problems lol,not sure if he can do a compression test though,but will ask him, thanks hun :)

Compression tests are very easy he should be able to

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.