Skip to content

Woudln't normally ask..

Featured Replies

Wouldn't normally ask people what to do regarding my own car, but I need to release a bit of money I have ied up in the multiple engines I have kicking about. Basically I have 3 engines (in parts, but practically complete) that I could build: a 1W based 1.4 diesel, 1.4 ADB based turbo or a 1W based 1.4 Turbo. If i was prepared to get wossner pistons I could go for 1.5 turbo, but I'm not really prepared to fork out another £600 on what I've already spent. Whatever I don't use will be up for sale, so there's quite a few tasty bits potentially up for grabs. Below is more detail (giving an indiacation of value and potential spec of engine). With whatever engine the turbo manifold, turbo and intercooler will be staying.

1.4 Diesel Turbo - Based around a 1W block with knackered diesel pump. However I have a pump taken from a working engine (from Kiz) along with spare pistons

1.4 ABD Turbo - ABD block with internals, although suspected ring failure. To go inside are skimmed and lighgtened internals (from Tommos engine, made 200bhp). R5T carb, mk2 GT inlet (not mk2f), mechanical head with polo GT mechanical head cam. Rings have been sourced to replace the blown ones (these are very hard to get hold of). Dizzy is sorted with vac-retard flying saucer too.

1.4 1W Turbo - same as above except it will have oil squirters so able to run a touch more boost. May be able to use the 1W crank for extra strength

Turbo to go one either is a Garret T25 with front mount intercooler and bailey dump valve. All will be rebuilt with new bearings, seals etc. All would need boost piping made too, but thats not an issue

Those are the choices. From what I've read turboing the diesel is 'easiet', fuel needs to be upped. To ge it running even better the head can be modifed to only add fuel on boost, but I'm not sure about the specifics. The two petrol models are more difficult due to the problems with det and being set up properly etc. The abd specced engine is similar to that which Tommo ran, and tbh, I'd be happy with 200bhp, but more that prepared to go 160-180 if possible. The diesel is obviously unique though.

So what do we go for? Opinions and advice. Watch this space also as whatever I decide against will be up for sale

Edited by prankstar2003

  • Replies 117
  • Views 3.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

tbh and i know I'm gona get shot for this but - if you can get decent power from a diesel lump then id go for that.

a) i dont think iv seen a uk diesel before, if i have then iv forgotten about it

b) cheaper to run :lol:

tbh and i know I'm gona get shot for this but - if you can get decent power from a diesel lump then id go for that.

a) i dont think iv seen a uk diesel before, if i have then iv forgotten about it

b) cheaper to run :lol:

i second that :-D

  • Author

I have a diesel (9n) as my daily, so fuel economy doesn't really come into it. The saloon will be a weekend car, so needs to be fun/worth driving

But I know what you mean about being unique. The only tuned 1W i have seen is Thomas's from swedin (iirc). He's pushing 130bhp, but he's put a bit of work into it. Getting mad toque though, which would be cool.

This is what I'm torn with, I have 'garaunteed' power, with a relatively well known unit in the 1.4 turbo (although it will be mech headed) but uniqueness of the 1W. I was hoping to try both, but I can't see me ever getting around to it. Hell, I can't even get the 1.6 running yet! The 1W would probably require less work as its only one wire for the glow plug and your away! (well, practically...)

forget the 1W turbo - you wont be able to get pistons, been discussed several times on ClubG40, they need a minimum batch order so unless you can find another 5 mates to buy some it wont happen- i believe it was the same for both wossner and accralite

  • Author

Yeah, wasn't really going to pay £600 for pistons. If i was serious about 1.5 I'd probably buy yours and flog what I have. Could likely get most of my money back

I'd be inclined to say a diesel cause its just something a bit different.

1.4 ABD turbo, its been tried and seen good results. Don't know why everyone feels the need to do something "different", yeah fair play for trying something new, but on a smaller scale.

Maybe you could take it one step further? Mechy head abd turbo? Could try a mad cam etc.

I'm trying a ABD turbo/super charged, with bike carbs, plenum and a mental cam.

diesel!!!

i say diesel, simply for the fact that if you can't get a 1.6 on bike carbs running properly, then its gonna be the safest bet out of those choices

that isn't a dig btw but it is something you need to seriously consider before diving in, which of these could you actually build and get running properly? you use tommo's engine as an example but he had a lot of knowledge to help him achieve what he did, and i'm not talking "i read a book" kind of knowledge

I think diesel would be different, have good power and be interesting tbh..

Isn't a turbo diesel gonna be just as hard though? especially for someone who's been learning about petrol engines.

not in the slightest, IDI turbo diesels are stupidly simple. bolt a turbo on and up the fuel, if it don't smoke up it some more

Really? hahaha sounds pikey man,

Still say ABD turbo though simon, it would be my choice!

Nothing pikey about it at all, that's what they did at the factory. An original td would normally have boost enrichment on the pump but good results have been had from the tall block vw IDI's converted to turbo but keeping the non turbo pump. There's no risk of melting anything if it runs lean, no risk of det if not set up right, you literally tune them by the exhaust. Want more power? Just turn the boost and fuel up

Personally I say play to your strengths, you seem to be able to put a car together ok but struggle trying to set it up, td's are easy to setup and and because there's non of the engine killing dangers associated with boosting a petrol, you can tune it yourself and have fun doing so safe in knowledge that you're not gonna kill it. Seriously I had so much fun pissing about with my jetta, on a Sunday take a drive out to the A5 with a flat ended screw driver and a 10mm spanner and have a tuning session :lol:

Plus they can sound mean as fuck with a straight through pipe on :-D

too much smoke .. down the pump .. fuck that jamie, up the boost..

My mates old 306 tdurbo was such a animal and didnt spend any money on it ..

There's a time and a place for diesel, and it ain't in a featherweight car.

I like torque, but i found it possible to have too much bias in a MK2 even with petrol, so I wouldn't fancy a grungy turbo diesel.

You really wanna start by deciding what kind of power delivery you want, what personality/character of an engine you wanna use, then go from there - .

  • Author

Thanks for the input folks.

Guy, you are right, having a right mare witht the bike carbs, but I think thats down to buggered carbs and me being too stubborn to pay for more! We'll see this weekend when I get the new carbs bolted up. However, I am doing much more research into this turbo set up than the bike carbs. And I may yet go with EFI and get someone (PPP as they're not far) to tune it correct. But I take your point, a turbo conversion comes with many potential pitfalls.

A diesel would be cool yes, but I don't want to trade the AEA performance for lower diesel performance. Yes it will have loads of torque and a bit of power (though I can't see it making near 100bhp) and return mpg, but its still a turbo diesel in the end. Unique: yes, and potentially a doddle to get looking nice in the bay (which is also a consideration) due to the sheer simplicity but I'm not sure it's going to give the character I want (like Mikey says). I don't often drive petrols these days, except the Mrs 1.4 clio now and then, and I must say, I like the instant power of a petrol. This can only be improved with the turbo yes?

Max, a mech head is the way I'd go. My concern is the small valves however, and the lack of turbo specific cams. Apparently the Cam fitted is the GK, which was the early MK2 GT equivalent and should be ok in the absence of a turbo specific cam. This engine would have a certain amount of exclusivity (bar winstons) but in the end another turbo.

Hmmmm, still not sure. So many things to consider, but all parts for both engine (bar bearings and boost piping) are ready and present.

Wouldn't worry too much about the small valves, you could get them smoothed, which should decrease the flow co-efficient somewhat, allowing them to flow as good as a bigger valve. Yes it won't flow as well as a smoothed hyrdo head valve.

You could also send the head off to whoever has been working on "tav's" head, i think they've managed to up the CFM of it by a good 1/3

Coupe that with the GK cam and it should be great. Id certainly try and run it as a 1.5 too, 1W block etc

If youve got the torque gear it higher and it will still accelerate and pull hard.....?

Petrol FTW

Hate to be the bearer of bad news but once you get into the land of silly power budget double whatever it cost to get you there and then use that to try and make the power usable.

Its no secret that Pete, Andy and I (although granted they make more power and use theirs more) can eat gearboxes for breakfast. Up front we have turned our Polos into Golfs.

Nothing personal but whats the latest craze with bastardising engines?

You can safely get 100, 130, 150 bhp with pretty much stock engines which dont exactly cost the earth and are infinitely easier to do.

Edited by GiorgioGT

  • Author

I won't be doing a 1.5 conversion, can't justify the additional money and need to sell some of this set up to get a bit of the money back. And yes, I could have valves and head modified, but as you say, with a well modified hydrohead, the benfits will be greater. Especially when you consider that there are BVHs availlable for the G40. There is a possibility of larger valves though, apparently there's some ford valves that can be used as larger inlet valves or something. Still be a fun project, and the additionally rigidity of the mech head, and lack of 'bounce' may make up somewhat by allowing a higher red line.

Nick, I have a couple of 085 gearboxes but I'm not sure how much further I could increase the gearing without going for a G40 box, which again, I'm not willing to pay out for. AEE/AEA boxes have higher ratios?

Overall though, I'm not looking for 200bhp, somewhere more around 160-170 I think. Like Kiz has said somewhere else, I have no need for a 200+ car. The chassis can't take it in its current state, and I'm not willing to modify the chassis to accomodate that sort of power. Additionally although its to be a weekend car, I still need it to be fairly reliable.

Go hard or go home. Whatever you budget, expect more

  • Author

Was writing that before your reply came up.

Bastardasing engines? Not really sure. Budget is part of it. I have aquired the head, block and internals for the 1.4T for less than half the price a G40 engine would cost. Also trying something new, and I don't mean I want to be unique. I have never seen a mech headed turbo, not to say they don't exist, but I'd like to see what it can achieve.

I know 130/150bhp is easily possible with out of the box or mildly modified standard engines, but it's not just power I'm chasing. I like the 8v engines, especially the look of the early heads. Andy, pete and yourself have build some awesome cars in terms of power, but thats not all I'm after. I'll be keeping hold of the AEA incase it all goes tits!

Thanks for the input though

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.