Skip to content

Woudln't normally ask..

Featured Replies

Si, you can get the 1.6 td vw engines into mk2 golf 16v performance for less than £150 (most of that is the price of a front mount and some pipe to make an exhaust). My jetta used to pull through the range and was still pulling until it hit the hard limiter, so non of this pissy 2k power band bullshit either :lol:

I don't think you'd have a hard job getting a boosted 1.4 IDI to 100bhp, you mention MPG but I thought this was a weekend toy?

It's your choice but I think your totally underestimating the performance you could get from one of these with some simple mods. There isn't a lot documented about the 1w turbo, but there isn't a lot that couldn't be swapped over from tuning the big block IDI motors, and there is shit loads of info on that

Obviously a boosted petrol engine would out perform one, but its a hell of a lot more expensive to do properly, especially if your going efi and getting it mapped properly

  • Replies 117
  • Views 3.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Winston has done a budget mech head turbo Simon , remember?

maybe by the time you've started this , me and nick will have begun building a FI bike carburetor'd engine, so you could go for something simular to get the desired peak power from an otherwise compromised engine choice like the mechanical headed units.

oh, and if anyone says getting good results out of a biked carburetord engine is hard your an idiot pure and simple. I can't stress how easy they are to fiddle with. a wideband helps but is not essential for good results.

guy did yours dump a lot of smoke?

Edited by MaxGT

Under fairly large load yeah, great for when some poser in a tt soft top started tailgating me through a 30 zone, put it in 5th and floored it. He wasn't as eager to get up my arse after that :lol:

It's all about how they are setup tho tbh, I could of cut the smoke down a lot by adjusting the pump to suit but what's the point in a diesel that doesn't leave a huge cloud of black smoke when you dust some idiot in a BMW off the lights? 8-)

  • Author

Thanks again chaps for the input. I will say once again, despite seeming niave, and having a lack of experience with either engine, this isn't a project I'll be taking on lightly, and I'm aware of the costs of attempting a 1.4T, especially once EFI is introduced etc.

I have considered the FI bike carb option too Max, but it does mean having a plenum made up, which wouldn't be too much problem as I have a friend who could knock one up pretty easily for minimal charge. But I'm aiming for a period look I think and I hefty stainless plenum won't fit the bill. I know my current set up is far from OEM, but it doesn't stand out too much. The engine will be part of the complete car, and I know sacrifices are going to be made regarding power etc. So before anyone sticks the boot in regarding that, it's all been considered

Guy, I'm interested in hearing about the smoke issue. From what I've seen of modified diesels, they do chuck out a lot of muck. But then I haven't seen many. Also, any idea how to retrofit a boost enrinchment system? I read through the GTD forum, but couldn't find too much info, and all of it refered to the tall block engines (with the pump the other way). The 1W is almost unheard of, and what there is about it is all Tommas' car.

Yesterday I was leaning towards 1.4T, but on the drive to work I went the other way to the Diesel. I think the Diesel is the more do-able but will it provide the smiles of a petrol turbo?

hahaha guy sounds good. not for me though.

Simon, you'll have a nightmare finding a non fucked/leaky r5 carb.

Edited by MaxGT

I'd go with the simplest, safest, most reliable route to the power you want and enjoy the car.

My old G40 was a handful at 170bhp but an absolute hoot to drive. Anything the bright side of 130bhp in that car will feel like a rocket ship.

All for projects but sometimes you just want to have a car to enjoy without having to work on it every weekend.

I'd go with whatever you feel most competent in setting up. This is the downfall of a large majority of conversions (usually coupled to a set of bike carbs) because people don’t have the time, expertise, cash to complete the job themselves, and won’t pay someone to do it for them.

1.4 ABD is a nice idea, but a pointless one in my opinion, clearly the engine makes no more power than a G40, and won’t have the durability to match. It’s different yes, better, no.

Diesel- yeah that would be interesting, but there’s a fair amount of custom parts involved in making a 1W give big power (Check the one on Club G40) and if you’re going to be buying hybrid turbos etc for one, then why not buy it for something with more than 130bhp?

1.4 1W Turbo- good route, Nick’s car has been properly setup and he’s spent the time on it (and lots of cash), to then get less power than a 1272cc K03 Turbo thrown together by Hayesey who’s spent money on the parts that count, and has reliability and power.

I’d like to see a 1.6 16v AFH done properly on throttle bodies with a pair of Schrick cams in, giving in the region of 160bhp. Similar to Mitch’s Lupo motor- definitely different, sounds much better than any of the engines above, not as fast, but different.

  • Author

Yoof; I have read and re-read Thomas' build about the TD and you're right about the money needed for big power, which is one of the reasons I'm a little put of tbh. Practically everything, bar the block is custom or aftermarket, so its pretty far from the original 1W he started with.

A 1.4T wouldn't be as fast as a standard T40? How come? Not that I doubt what your sayiny but there's no replacement for displacement!

1WT - based petrol is out since i need to get some money back from the parts I have to move either project forward. Using both engines is a no go therefore

Again, I know what your saying about setting it up. But with Andy just up the road (or at least not too far away) thats where I'd go for setting up if I did decide to use injection. I'd maybe have a faff with a set of carbs, after considerable research of course. This won't happen for another year at the least I wouldn't have thought

Max; I have an R5T Carb (whether its leaky or not, I dont know) but this is my dilema. I have practically everything for either conversion but I'm stuck deciding which would be best. Maybe a 1.6 16v is the way to go....

I didn't say that, I've not mentioned how fast either of them are...

  • Author

Ok, more powerful. My mistake

I'm kinda in the same boat Simon, bit undecided on where to go and what to do.

Gearbox's suck really, not sure how long they'd last with diesel torques?

Yoof, I was contemplating a highish spec 1.6 16v, but then thought maybe a stronger one with a turbo maybe better, not sure what piston availability is mind!

  • Author

That was my next issue, gearboxes. The power delivery of a TD ought to be fairly progressive and tbh, there's going to be similar issues with a high spec petrol turbo too. Luckily I'm hoarding 085 boxes!

Maybe it's worth selling the lot and looking into 16v power

Probably a stupid question but would the afh head fit to the 1w block

And Nick forged piston availability is non existent really I did contact acralite but there's a minimum order of 3 sets and they want 60-70% of the money upfront before even starting

Thought that AFH turbo was forged?

  • Author

Not sure Pete. The 1w block is very similar to the standard 1.3/abd/g40 blocks. How so?

I'd go with whatever you feel most competent in setting up. This is the downfall of a large majority of conversions (usually coupled to a set of bike carbs) because people don’t have the time, expertise, cash to complete the job themselves, and won’t pay someone to do it for them.

1.4 ABD is a nice idea, but a pointless one in my opinion, clearly the engine makes no more power than a G40, and won’t have the durability to match. It’s different yes, better, no.

Diesel- yeah that would be interesting, but there’s a fair amount of custom parts involved in making a 1W give big power (Check the one on Club G40) and if you’re going to be buying hybrid turbos etc for one, then why not buy it for something with more than 130bhp?

1.4 1W Turbo- good route, Nick’s car has been properly setup and he’s spent the time on it (and lots of cash), to then get less power than a 1272cc K03 Turbo thrown together by Hayesey who’s spent money on the parts that count, and has reliability and power.

I’d like to see a 1.6 16v AFH done properly on throttle bodies with a pair of Schrick cams in, giving in the region of 160bhp. Similar to Mitch’s Lupo motor- definitely different, sounds much better than any of the engines above, not as fast, but different.

To which context are you reffering to? a turbo ABD is gonna make more power than a G40

Not to mention the reason why youd use a ABD engine in the first place, the fact it costs a fraction of the G40s price.

Nick are you on about Danz16vt engine being fully forged if so I have asked him 2-3 times for info about the pistons and so have other people but he hasn't given any but it maybe because he bought the engine forged already so may not know and I don't know who he bought them off to ask

I'd go with whatever you feel most competent in setting up. This is the downfall of a large majority of conversions (usually coupled to a set of bike carbs) because people don’t have the time, expertise, cash to complete the job themselves, and won’t pay someone to do it for them.

1.4 ABD is a nice idea, but a pointless one in my opinion, clearly the engine makes no more power than a G40, and won’t have the durability to match. It’s different yes, better, no.

Diesel- yeah that would be interesting, but there’s a fair amount of custom parts involved in making a 1W give big power (Check the one on Club G40) and if you’re going to be buying hybrid turbos etc for one, then why not buy it for something with more than 130bhp?

1.4 1W Turbo- good route, Nick’s car has been properly setup and he’s spent the time on it (and lots of cash), to then get less power than a 1272cc K03 Turbo thrown together by Hayesey who’s spent money on the parts that count, and has reliability and power.

I’d like to see a 1.6 16v AFH done properly on throttle bodies with a pair of Schrick cams in, giving in the region of 160bhp. Similar to Mitch’s Lupo motor- definitely different, sounds much better than any of the engines above, not as fast, but different.

To which context are you reffering to? a turbo ABD is gonna make more power than a G40

Not to mention the reason why youd use a ABD engine in the first place, the fact it costs a fraction of the G40s price.

No it isn't- Andy's G40 (stock head) with K03 made 207bhp , Tommo's made 208bhp (both at Aldon) Tommo's also had a T25, not a tiny K03!

ABD Turbo isn't cheaper than a PY turbo, Hayesey picked his bottom end up for £50. Tommo's was cheap because he was able to do all the machining work himself.

Boosting an engine, not designed for boost, with reliability, isn't cheap, take it from someone who's been there and done it, not read about it on the Internet.

Well in Pete, pisses me off people who read shit with no actual experience.

what? :lol:

you said a G40 , no mention of a turbo.

and because one person got a bottom end for stupidly cheap doesnt mean thats what they're now worth.

and you cant compare them two engines, they're worlds apart , the bottom end is not the only difference.

doesnt need "real life experience" to figure that out.

  • Author

I can appreciate the cost of the build, which atm is fairly low due to waiting for parts to come up cheap and general bargain hunting. The rotating gear is from Tommos motor so no more machining should be needed on that side of things, reducing costs. What I have bought has been bought for fairly cheap except the ABD piston rings that are hard enough to get hold of. IF i was to go for an ABD turbo, I wouldn't be pushing it as hard as Tommow did, which may therefore strengthen the argument against building it in the first place. Annoying thing is I sold a g40 bottom end in the summer, which may have made a better base :-( Costs can spiral no doubt, and again I have done my research so I am at least slightly aware of what else is needed and I have some idea of the money thats involved. I'm also fully aware that reading stuff on the internet doesn't make a genius but nonetheless, it can only help, especially when the source is considered. I know who to trust and who to ignore when discussing such things, and have read plenty of threads on clubg40. However, and don't feel like I'm going against you advice Yoof, but if everyone did the same thing, we'd never workout what works and what doesn't. As you've said, you've made your mistakes and blown a few engines and you're far more experienced than most, and people will continue to make theirs. The advice is taken on board and duly noted, and is up there with the best advice I could get. But don't be too suprised if i choose this route, its not because I think I know better, but will be based upon the evidence I have collected from many sources.

Saying all that though, I am leaning towards the TD :lol:

When is someone gonna man the fuxk up and fit a rotary engine

what? :lol:

you said a G40 , no mention of a turbo.

and because one person got a bottom end for stupidly cheap doesnt mean thats what they're now worth.

and you cant compare them two engines, they're worlds apart , the bottom end is not the only difference.

doesnt need "real life experience" to figure that out.

I also said 1.4 ABD - no mention of a turbo.

PY motor can be had for cheaper than modifying a 1.4 ABD to take boost.

Engines are worlds apart, one is proven reliable, one isn't.

Agree- but clearly it helps.

but this thread is about a ABD turbo, so you clearly did mean it.

ok, i can modify any engine to run a boost friendly CR , thus allowing me to convert an ABD to run boost cheaper than buying a PY block.

however, that doesnt mean that all boost friendly ABD engines are now cheaper than a PY block.

anyway, lets not ruin this thread with more shite.

Edited by MaxGT

Dam, you got me.

I'll just look for some fucks to give...

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.