Skip to content

CFD polo

Featured Replies

just out of interest has any one done a flow analysis of a mk3 coupe?

cheers.

  • Replies 15
  • Views 1.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

as in air flow?

i cant see it being much better than a brick :lol:

I did, results as follows:

Vehicle: Polo Mk3 (86c)

Date: 02/07/12

Software Version: 22.9033.12a

Analysis By: NJH

Results:

Shit.

Cd of 0.39 sticks in my head for an early coupe, can't find anything on Google though.

Current Bluemotion is 0.3, which is dam good given it's based on a Polo!

Think one of the formel e brochures has a number in, which one or what it is I don't know.

Yoof is right for the MK2 coupe, in the brochure VW commented on the importance of aerodynamics and light weight at the time, and claimed a drag co-efficient of 0.39.

To put that into perspective, the smooth-front Nova of 1991 was 0.42 and the 1990 Calibra (claimed to be the most aerodynamic production car in the world at the time) was 0.29 although that was without tiny details like windscreen wipers, badges, repeaters..

I think the early '90s Cavalier was 0.39 and that is far more slippy-looking than the wrinkly MK2 Polo coupe but aerodynamics aint a simple science.

Wonder what this was..

http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5255/5436764...a13a5e451_z.jpg

I know that pics off GT4 but you all know the one :)

Probably not very good.

Classic Jaguars for example, such as the D-type, C-type, E-type, XK120/150 etc are terrible for drag - they weren't very good at understanding aerodynamics in the old days. As i say it's not as simple a science as it seems and that racer has the common trait of a low rear (it might work for an aeroplane wing, but notice the Calibra was flat-backed - as is anything modern and aerodynamic, or at least having spoilers to create the same effect).

Yoof is right for the MK2 coupe, in the brochure VW commented on the importance of aerodynamics and light weight at the time, and claimed a drag co-efficient of 0.39.

To put that into perspective, the smooth-front Nova of 1991 was 0.42 and the 1990 Calibra (claimed to be the most aerodynamic production car in the world at the time) was 0.29 although that was without tiny details like windscreen wipers, badges, repeaters..

I think the early '90s Cavalier was 0.39 and that is far more slippy-looking than the wrinkly MK2 Polo coupe but aerodynamics aint a simple science.

Wonder what this was..

http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5255/5436764...a13a5e451_z.jpg

I know that pics off GT4 but you all know the one :)

Probably not very good.

Classic Jaguars for example, such as the D-type, C-type, E-type, XK120/150 etc are terrible for drag - they weren't very good at understanding aerodynamics in the old days. As i say it's not as simple a science as it seems and that racer has the common trait of a low rear (it might work for an aeroplane wing, but notice the Calibra was flat-backed - as is anything modern and aerodynamic, or at least having spoilers to create the same effect).

D-Type was regarded as having cutting edge aerodynamics of its day...

Perhaps you should read this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malcolm_Sayer

Malcolm Sayer (who had a hand in early Jags) is regarded in the industry as an aero Grandfather.

2584a12584dcea216e766c4bbcb514eb.png

Fd is the drag force, which is by definition the force component in the direction of the flow velocity,

Rho is the mass density of the fluid,

V is the speed of the object relative to the fluid and

A is the reference area.

the polo has a smaller frontal area which helps it's Cd

No disrespect to Mr Sawyer, his work was impressive for it's time, but i did emphasize the time issue - the Jaguar E-type was stunning to look at upon it's release but it wasn't as aerodynamic as a VW Polo 20yrs later.

The D-type was for motorsport, and the average 7-seat people carrier today is more aerodynamic.

No disrespect to Mr Sawyer, his work was impressive for it's time, but i did emphasize the time issue - the Jaguar E-type was stunning to look at upon it's release but it wasn't as aerodynamic as a VW Polo 20yrs later.

The D-type was for motorsport, and the average 7-seat people carrier today is more aerodynamic.

He's not wrong kiddies! but Rumpler we making even more aerodynamic vehicles than a mk2 polo in the 20's.

today the XL1 concept has a Cd of 0.19.

Cd is however not the be all and end all of drag, the whole vehicle must be considered and due to its size, I am almost cetain the MPV will have more drag as a figure measured in newtons than a mk2 polo.

No disrespect to Mr Sawyer, his work was impressive for it's time, but i did emphasize the time issue - the Jaguar E-type was stunning to look at upon it's release but it wasn't as aerodynamic as a VW Polo 20yrs later.

A candle isn't as bright as a 100W electric light bulb either, but in their day they were a lot better than sitting in the dark.

Malcolm Sayer is credited as being one of the first people to apply aero theory to automotive applications, so it's hardly surprising that two decades later someone's managed to better it in a shopping hatchback given 20 years of progress in manufacturing; design and engineering processes and equipment.

got nowt to do with the thread but a fascinating fact none the less, the Austin Allegro had a better drag coefficient going backwards than it did forwards!

Edited by KiZ

got nowt to do with the thread but a fascinating fact none the less, the Austin Allegro had a better drag coefficient going backwards than it did forwards!

It also had a higher top speed going backwards :-D

No disrespect to Mr Sawyer, his work was impressive for it's time, but i did emphasize the time issue - the Jaguar E-type was stunning to look at upon it's release but it wasn't as aerodynamic as a VW Polo 20yrs later.

A candle isn't as bright as a 100W electric light bulb either, but in their day they were a lot better than sitting in the dark.

Malcolm Sayer is credited as being one of the first people to apply aero theory to automotive applications, so it's hardly surprising that two decades later someone's managed to better it in a shopping hatchback given 20 years of progress in manufacturing; design and engineering processes and equipment.

Yep.

It all goes to echo how motorsport development helps road cars develop.

I think latterly motorsport's not doing a huge amount for passenger vehicles outside of materials technology development. You've got increasingly diversifying legislation in both areas to thank for that. When KERS was introduced into F1 I know for a fact that one of the main constructors turned to an automotive consultancy with hybrid vehicle expertise to design, test and develop a system for them.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.