Skip to content

Spot the difference?! Which Wheel?

Featured Replies

Looking at treating my mk5 to a set of cheap wheels to get me to the spring.

Been looking at these. And for the life of me, aside from the brand name itself and the price i cant see the difference in these wheels?

So would i be mad to order the Rota's over the other ones?

JAERO WHEELS

ROTA WHEELS

Seem the same to me? But big difference in price.

  • Replies 30
  • Views 3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Is the first set not a replica

If the centre cap is correct on wheel one jbw are replicas generally

  • Author

Ok, i see... But really. both sets aint exactly expensive posh rims. So why would i not just get the cheaper ones?

They must have the same sort of warranty? Its not like they are fake splits?

Thoughts?

Pay for brand really, copies/replicas generally seem to be heavier too.

rota.jpg

:lol:

If your gonna buy cheap wheels you might as well just buy the cheapest, its not like your getting quality for the extra pounds

Couldn't agree more, or save and buy better ones that you actually want

Are rota wheel really that bad? I've always liked there styling but never owned a set, as said above, the weight thing properly is noticeable, and everyone likes a lightweight wheel!

  • Author

Maybe if your rallying, but most of us.. (myself in my daily) just drive a/b-roads and the motor way.

I'm sure they aint gonna snap. I'm sure they all just come from the same stuff. I'm saving for some better rims, but i dont see the harm in the cheaper ones here

the only reall difference i can see is the valve placement and a slight difference in centre cap

id say go for them, end of the day rotas are generally a shit wheel so something from a budget company will be roughly on par i would expect i doubt they would be worse, maybe have a google search for some reviews?

Rotas are replica wheels anyway haha

Rotas are replica wheels anyway haha

indeed they are. i'd go for whichever replica is cheapest if thats your thing. funny thing is though, for the price of a set of replicas you csan buy the real deal second hand for similar money. granted you will need to put some work into them to get them looking mint, but they will last better, hold there value better, weigh less and be made of far superior materials. i bet any of those cheap replicas will look tired within 2 years once the lacquer starts crazing and flaking off.

those are copies of sprint hart/racing hart jdm alloys btw

  • Author

I had no idea Rota were replicas?

Rota Grids are amazing! What are they a replica of?

not-sure-if-serious-or-sarcastic.jpg
I had no idea Rota were replicas?

Rota Grids are amazing! What are they a replica of?

grids are rays te37 I think

I had no idea Rota were replicas?

Rota Grids are amazing! What are they a replica of?

grids are rays te37 I think

Correct.

And yes while a set of Rota wheels isn't going to be as tough as a proper set of Japanese motorsport rims you're unlikely to find out without thoroughly binning your car. A lot of drift teams use them, for example. Tough enough to use in anger but cheap to replace, and cheaper than breaking suspension parts because your wheel is so hard.

If you're going rallying then perhaps budget for some Compomotives. For road driving in a Polo you're unlikely to ever see the benefits of buying overly expensive wheels. Apart from snob value.

I remember chatting to someone at a show once who looked at one of our project cars and said "Aww, bro, are those genuine Rotas?"

I wish I was joking.

Rotas are fine. They're not professional Motorsport wheels but they'll be just as tough as any other budget wheel and fine for daily use. They're not knock odds that fell off a lorry.

Edited by Alex

One of my mates raised the point about second hand wheels - you dont always know what they have been through previously?

He would rather have a new budget wheel that was going to be fine for his driving rather than wheels which are unknown.

Is a 20 year old wheel going to be as good as new?

I had some Heroes racing wheels from Japan - actually the ones in my avatar, and it turned out once they were stripped that a previous owners had sulphuric dipped them which meant that all the magnesium had gone leaving primarily aluminium. I'm pretty sure the magnesium would have been in there for a reason!

I ask the question? - i guess there are some that fall into both camps.

Edited by Retrotub

TE37's are expensive and I want some :(

in fact here you go, have the real thing

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Lightweight-14-J...=item337ec356fc

See i dont like the look of them. To me they "look" cheaper...

i would say that is more down to the poor photo, probably taken on a smart phone or similar. had thsat pic been taken with a decent quality camera, on a white background like the replicas, i think it would look fine. Having owned endless sets of 20+ year old jdm wheels, i would have them over replicas all day long. not because rotas are going to shatter into a thousand pieces (as lets face it, unless your really unlucky and get a deffective one or you smash your car really hard into a curb, it is unlikely to occur! For me its the quality of the material used in the genuine old skool jap wheels that makes the difference. The polished lips on most old jap wheels are bare, you can run the through winter and they won't oxidise like a bitch, they are just better quality.

As retro-tub points out, you are gambling on the fact that a previous owner hasnt done something really stupid to the wheels, but 9/10 with a bit of common sense you can buy second hand wheels and not suffer any ill effects.

Fake BBS splits are a prime example of cheap wheels working out more more expensive in the long run than buying the real thing.

Original cost + price of a refurbing after their first winter on car + money you loose on them when you sell them = cost of buying a decent set of second hand genuine splits

I know that its unlikely a rota will snap, but you can't really have a thread about them without at least one of the many comedy pics about them being posted :thumbsup:

Fake BBS splits are a prime example of cheap wheels working out more more expensive in the long run than buying the real thing.

Original cost + price of a refurbing after their first winter on car + money you loose on them when you sell them = cost of buying a decent set of second hand genuine splits

I know that its unlikely a rota will snap, but you can't really have a thread about them without at least one of the many comedy pics about them being posted :thumbsup:

This I agree with entirely, wasn't meant to be a dig about the demotivational poster I was just clarifying it's more myth than reality.

Cheap wheels with polished lips are a catastrophically awful idea. From experience, as you said, one winter on the car with no kerbing and the lacquer had crazed all over the place. A few months after fitting them and they were worthless. False economy.

Greetings from South Africa.

Thought I'd add my 2cents.

I'm all for having original rims over replicas. I currently have genuine BBS RXii splits on my 6R. This is the first genuine rim I have owned. I must say the difference is noticeable.

However, the question of cost comes into play. I picked my BBS up for a good price. A replica costs at least 3 times that of a replica. In SA, it is not really worth spending large amounts of cash on original rims that may end up buckled from a pot hole.

In SA, it is not really worth spending large amounts of cash on original rims that may end up buckled from a pot hole.

welcome, I didnt realise SA roads were so similar to ours!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.