Skip to content

Should winter tyres be legal in the UK

Featured Replies

Since the UK is crap at handling snow, everything goes into a panic and shuts down, and even after a week or so on clear roads people are driving around at 20mph, looking terrified. All the cul de sacs are still covered in snow where I live and everyone has parked their cars up on the main road making it difficult to get two cars past each other, which in turn is slowing everything down. I watched three cars slowly drift into the same patch of fence which that satisfying "keeerrrruunnnch".

So I was wondering, why aren't snow tyres (or winter tyres at least) a legal requirement in the UK like in some european countries? I appreciate that we don't have the same sort of winters as everyone else, but the amount of people I've seen crashing into things and wheelspinning non stop is just silly. Surely for the couple hundred pounds it costs to get some crap steelies and winter tyres, it would save so much hassle?

I put snow tyres on my mk2 bready last year, for about three months, and they are back on my car now - and honestly it handles the snow like a landrover. Will hardly slip at all.

What do you think?

  • Replies 65
  • Views 3.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I'm in full agreement mate. Should be compulsory as there are so many people with no clue how to drive in good conditions, let alone winter. The only reason i'm not running them is that i cant afford them. However its a law that would be near impossible to enforce, police would have to pull over and check every vehicle, and i cant see them doing that.

hmm, i think most crashes are from ice, or patted down compressed snow which in effect acts as ice. Not even snow tyres would do any good there.

The problem we have is the type of snow, the temperature flirts around freezing point and so the snow constantly melts a little and refreezes. Causing it to look like snow but act like ice.

Snow tyres, (correct me if i'm wrong) have wider gauges in the tread and so gather snow within them, giving cars better grip when in loose snow. Great for the type of snow you get in most countries i guess but not here.

The solution isn't to force everyone to get better tyres. It's to create a test like the swedish (?) where they have a driving test per season/weather type. And you can't drive in those conditions unless you have the driving licence to do so!

Edited by Liquidice

For the one or two days of snow we get, it is hardly worth forking out a couple of hundred quid for. I think what would be more useful is educating people on how to drive properly in it, too many people are giving it the beans to try and get grip when the key is to use a high gear/low revs for the torque.

I think ice is more of a problem now than snow, and even winter tyres cant really help you there.

ice is more of a problem rarther than snow

himm studded ice tyres ?

there no good on a little bit of clear road tho like wearing football boots with studs in on tarmac haha

Looking a bit more into winter tyres... they are pretty dangerous to use when the temperature goes above 7 degrees..... and in my area, it was -1 this morning and expected to be around 7/8 this weekend....

Therefore, what i can see happening is people being lazy and not changing back to their usual tyre, and we'll start seeing crashes in good conditions due to snow tyres in warmer temperatures causing longer braking distances!

  • Author

I think what you lot have said would probably be better, actually learning how to drive in snow. I had lessons after I passed from my dad who spent many years in Siberia in the oil industry, so have a good idea how to drive in snow. I just think that yes, even though it's quite pricey to buy the tires in the first place, unless you are getting rid of your car, it's cheaper than potentially crashing. But I do understand people wont be bothered to change them over even if it only takes 10 minutes.

grip in the snow? Where's the fun in that?

Fuck the Eu & its regulations!

I'm in full agreement mate. Should be compulsory..

The only reason i'm not running them is that i cant afford them.

Just brilliant. That's some oscar-winning shit right there.

And what, exactly, makes you think say 90% of the rest of the country can afford them..?

As it happens, i've got three different brands on the Golf, different tread patterns, different compounds, different tread depths, and they aint winter tyres. And i've got on just fine. But then, the weather here in Britain has been mild. Snow? You aint been there.

How much should we welcome a call for a law to come into force, where we're forced by law to run winter tyres? Why? Because it aint necessary, and more the point, it wouldn't solve anything - gave people ABS and they braked harder and later. Gave people traction control and they nailed it harder. Gave people PAS and they just got more impatient in car parks. Gave people stability control and they take roundabouts at 60mph.. now we're getting cars that can park themselves and, most frighteningly, auto braking..? People are just gonna depend on it.

So winter tyres? You know what that'll lead to - big profits, big tax revenue, motorist getting shafted.. And MORE accidents from people who get cocky running them. Great.

Because unlike some countries the entire country doesn't get snowed on regularly or for that long compared to parts of North America/Canada/Scandinavia. I don't want to be forced into buying expensive winter tyres for the three days a year that I might get snow around here. better driver training is the way forward in my opinion.

Exactly. Give people a fast car and they think they're a highly skilled racing driver, give them a rear wheel drive car, they think they're a drift master, give them a big vehicle and they think they can barge people out of the way, giving them snow tyres will just make them think they can drive with their heads as far up their arse when it's snowing as they do the rest of the time.

What's needed is better driver training. I saw someone get it wrong with a Range Rover on snow the other night (chucked it into a garage forecourt at 20-30mph, and met Mr Understeer). I didn't have any loss of traction on the same peice of road myself, and I was on a scooter.

Winter tyres aren't just about snow, though. They're designed to perform better in cold conditions, whereas normal tyres the grip starts to drop off below 7C. They also have zig-zag patterns which trap snow, as someone said, which means they grip better when the roads are covered.

The simple fact is, as others have said, we don't get the sort of regular, predictable snowfall that other countries have. We also don't have the infrastructure to support it - Germany has tyre hotels where you store your winter/summer wheels when they're not in use. Not everyone here has a garage to store a spare set of wheels in, and we don't have enough storage facilities set up as yet. So if it did become a legal requirement, there'd need to be additional investment in setting that up.

I totally agree that they're worth having when the weather is bad, but I can imagine the vast majority of the British public thoroughly resenting having to fork out for them. The Daily Mail would have a field day about the Eurocrats interfering, interviewing someone who can't afford to feed their kids but has had to buy winter tyres, etc. It'd be a tough one to bring in.

I also agree that the battle here is education, before we shift to winter tyres. I've seen masses of people driving around with four or five inches of snow on their roof this week, spilling huge mounds all over the motorway as they drive along and risking ending up blind when they brake and it slides down over the windscreen. I've seen people in SUVs assuming 4WD and low profile summer tyres are fine for this sort of weather, skidding out of junctions and sliding down hills. I've seen people braking late like it's a bone dry, warm road under their tyres. A day of simulated ice driving would benefit a lot of people, and probably moreso than fitting cold weather tyres then assuming they're back to normal grip.

The thing is, at least with snow people slow down. You get days where it's -7/8C below, and people drive normally if it's dry forgetting they're low on grip and blissfully unaware of black ice.

Fuck snow tyres, if you can't drive in it you shouldn't be on the road!!

Also why would you want to enforce something that's gunna cost everyone monies?!

Also the snow usually doesn't last more then a week so what the fucks the point in putting snow tyres on for probably over a £100 for a week?! Snow tyres are appauling when its not snowing so its lose lose either way.

And I still bet just as many people crash with them on as without. Pointless IMO

EDIT: Alex jeffco now do tyre hotels :lol:

Edited by matt01

  • Author

Interesting range of responses. Unfortunately ignorance will always increase the more people take things for granted, my biggest question though, is how would you teach someone to drive better in conditions like ice or snow when it snows for 2 weeks a year

Interesting range of responses. Unfortunately ignorance will always increase the more people take things for granted, my biggest question though, is how would you teach someone to drive better in conditions like ice or snow when it snows for 2 weeks a year

Seen these before?

skidcar.jpg

  • Author
Interesting range of responses. Unfortunately ignorance will always increase the more people take things for granted, my biggest question though, is how would you teach someone to drive better in conditions like ice or snow when it snows for 2 weeks a year

Seen these before?

skidcar.jpg

No 0_o

What does it do, simulate sliding? (going on basis it says 'skid car' :L)

Edited by samwii

hmm, i think most crashes are from ice, or patted down compressed snow which in effect acts as ice. Not even snow tyres would do any good there.

The problem we have is the type of snow, the temperature flirts around freezing point and so the snow constantly melts a little and refreezes. Causing it to look like snow but act like ice.

Snow tyres, (correct me if i'm wrong) have wider gauges in the tread and so gather snow within them, giving cars better grip when in loose snow. Great for the type of snow you get in most countries i guess but not here.

The solution isn't to force everyone to get better tyres. It's to create a test like the swedish (?) where they have a driving test per season/weather type. And you can't drive in those conditions unless you have the driving licence to do so!

Clearly, you'v never driven on snow tyres then.

Watch these videos:

If you have 2 sets of tyres all being equal you buy them at half the rate- so there's no increase in revenue for the Government at all, local scrap yard might see people buying more old steelies to chuck a set on in the winter though.

No amount of driver training will help the situation when someone pulls out on you because they haven't seen you, no driver can beat physics.

Mat01- Snow tyres are f'in awesome in the cold wet conditions (what the UK has most of the winter), they displace water much better than rain tyres too.

Given that most peoples insurance excess is more than a set of winters, it's a no brainer for me. No stress when it does snow.

Give it another few years and UK insurance companies will force a law to be passed, they'll get sick of paying out millions for minor accidents which could be avoided- it's what happened in Europe, and it will happen here no doubt.

Mikey- You should write for the Daily Mail.

Discount for using winter tyres on insurance etc would make alot of people use them ..

Althought would be hard to enforce, but if you false claim them and have a crash..

Winter tyres are ace..

My boss said his old m3 with winter tyres was alot better then his A7 tdi quatro he has atm with all year tyres ..

Shows they do work ;)

  • Author
Discount for using winter tyres on insurance etc would make alot of people use them ..

Althought would be hard to enforce, but if you false claim them and have a crash..

Winter tyres are ace..

My boss said his old m3 with winter tyres was alot better then his A7 tdi quatro he has atm with all year tyres ..

Shows they do work ;)

Winter tires most definitely work. That was the whole reason I started this thread - it wasn't me saying that people should pay, I was more trying to point out they are good, and would save a lot of damages in crashes. I appreciate not every one can afford them, but if they were on your car from october to march, where the average uk temp is less than 7 degrees, that's £300 which will save a lot of money and hassle if you were to crash, and even injury.

I don't know. All I'm saying is from my own experience, my tires have saved me from potential impacts 3 or 4 times since I've had them.

Yes, there are ignorant people out they who will just assume they will make your car AS SAFE as driving on a dry road in the summer, but for the majority, it would make driving easier for them.

Mikey- You should write for the Daily Mail.

I don't read the rags. But on that, maybe then the Daily Mail are realists..

winter tyres turned a 200sx from the worst car I have ever driven in the snow/ice to the best. They provided a huge amount of grip... the only issue with them is the fact that the person behind might not be able to stop as quick as you can!

The winters go on Nov/Dec and then come off again Feb. They are not just for snow and ice they are for low temperatures which we get lots of here.

I wouldn't knock them until you have tried them! :)

  • Author

For the record, these are the tyres I have. They are called kingpins, I believe the company makes them out of recycled tyres, so they are nice and cheap. I bought 4 steelies off ebay and 4 kingpins in 155x70x13, I think it cost me £40 to get them fitted. all in all I think it cost £300, and like I said, for the 3 months I had them on, they were bloody good.

295308_10200450391809383_1491602197_n.jp

Now, I appreciate that this topic has become a bit heated. So to relax a little, as this is only a debate - Please enjoy this picture of my lizard stuck upside down in a vine.

317042_10200450391929386_1091127973_n.jp

An obvious middle-ground would be for insurers to offer discounts to those switching to winter tyres, rather than making a legislative requirement immediately.

You're spreading your tyre wear across two sets of tyres, so aside from the initial investment, long-term ownership costs aren't significantly increased. In countries where winter tyres are mandated they're a lot cheaper than in the UK, but if you shop around and buy online from European sites you don't have to pay UK-premiums for them.

Insurance companies potentially gain from fewer claims, the infrastructure/transport network gains as traffic can still flow and people can get to work. Economical benefits there are obvious. Your local tyre fitted makes a few quid extra a year which comes out of your pocket, this would sting initially - but eventually the drop in insurance premiums would probably make up for it. I take the view that the tyre fitter cost is cheaper than paying my insurance excess though!

Storage is a pain, but on the continent most tyre places will store winter tyres for next to nothing. I think it was BMW over here that were offering a deal on buying winter tyres through them and getting free storage. It's an issue to overcome, but not one that's without a solution.

I also appreciate the argument re: lack of consistent snow in the UK. But as has been pointed out already, winter tyres aren't just snow tyres, they're a tyre designed to work optimally in sub 7°C conditions - regardless of snow/ice/water/dry. That doesn't mean they're crap above 7°C either, they just tend to wear out quicker at warmer temps.

i have had no problem driving in winter with my normal stretched tyres. so for me its a bit mehhh.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.