Skip to content

Should winter tyres be legal in the UK

Featured Replies

winter tyres turned a 200sx from the worst car I have ever driven in the snow/ice to the best. They provided a huge amount of grip... the only issue with them is the fact that the person behind might not be able to stop as quick as you can!

The winters go on Nov/Dec and then come off again Feb. They are not just for snow and ice they are for low temperatures which we get lots of here.

I wouldn't knock them until you have tried them! :)

This^^^.

I've stuck some on my Datsun too. Four mid-brand summer tyres for it are around a grand, but I got some good brand part-worn winters from Europe for £180 - and a set of crap alloys for a ton. That's an awful lot less than my insurance excess!

  • Replies 65
  • Views 3.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Mikey- You should write for the Daily Mail.

I don't read the rags. But on that, maybe then the Daily Mail are realists..

Only someone who doesn't read the Daily Mail would describe it as a realist point of view. :lol:

OH MY GOD, SNOW!!!! PANIC BUY OR YOU WILL STARVE!!!!!

MAN INJURED ON SNOW. FEAR FOR YOUR LIVES!!!

SNOW STOPS, BUT THE WORST IS STILL TO COME!!!!

SNOW NOW MELTING, FEAR THE FLOODS!!!!

It's an outpouring of always sensationalist, often racist, sometimes vaguely paedophilic lies, published by scaremongering nutcases who seem hell bent on making us all stay in our homes fearful of benefit-stealing, drunken, Royal-hating terrorist yobs and cancer-giving foods. The worst thing is, it dresses up as a broadsheet newspaper and delivers its hateful tabloid twaddle like it's well-researched journalism. Evil, evil, evil newspaper.

Excuse the tangent...

Above not meant to be cutting Mikey, but "realist" and "Daily Mail" in the same sentence is unlikely as "saint" and "Jimmy Savile"

He was ... TO me anyway :( ... lol

Agree on the 2 sets of wheels.. in the long run its better as they last longer

Great for the type of snow you get in most countries i guess but not here.

Clearly, you'v never driven on snow tyres then.

Watch these videos:

'Clearly' i never said i had anyway? I have driven on them in dry conditions in the spring though (after buying a car with them on) and thought it had no tred left until i checked. People don't seem to realise the type of snow we get over here is significantly different to the colder places who get snow for months on end. It's so cold in some countries the Snow is almost like sand and you can use a leaf blower to get rid of it.

I completely agree with someones earlier post about making it TOO easy for drivers to just presume what they have underneath them will keep them safe, and not just think safe to begin with. I get that you are defensive over the winter tyres because they work for you... they would certainly work for me too... but they don't suit the majority and that's what counts in this country at the end of the day.

Training drivers in ALL conditions is better then bringing in a costly law to fix just the one. DEcent ALL ROUND tyres are perfectly fine for 95% of the UK's weather. Simple as that.

On a side note, it always baffled me why you could pass a driving test but it doesn't include or even mention (apart from the theory sometimes) motorway driving. Our driving test is inadequate.

That doesn't mean they're crap above 7°C either, they just tend to wear out quicker at warmer temps.

They increase stopping distances.

Edited by Liquidice

No, they don't. Perhaps at +30°C maybe, but they don't go crap just because it's +8°C.

  • Author

why don't we just get two breadvans at 40mph on a normal spring day to emergency stop and see what happens :)

No, they don't. Perhaps at +30°C maybe, but they don't go crap just because it's +8°C.

Granted I've not tested and only googled for infomation... but everywhere seems to suggest they lack performance at warmer temps.... If anything, i see there being a bigger reason to enforce a law saying you can't run winter tyres in the Spring, Summer and Autumn then one to enforce having to run them in just winter.

And if they do wear down quicker as you have suggested, people will be (as people are) to lazy to keep checking and are more likely to not only be running winter tyres in the summer, but also winter tyres that are dangerously worn.

I'm not against winter tyres in the slightest and in fact will be getting a set ready for next year no doubt, i'm just against them being the solution.

Edited by Liquidice

why don't we just get two breadvans at 40mph on a normal spring day to emergency stop and see what happens :)

To me again two people will always drive differently as in the video's above it looks like the white Seat actually slowly leaves the line while the red one just rev's and lets the clutch out...

Also in the video's these are `fresh` tyres, will still get the same results when your winter tyres that have been stacked in the garage for 4 or more years. Tyres dry out and get harder?... They must have a life span? Hopefully we can leave the EU when this vote comes about and we wont have lots of issues in all fields caused by EU regs aswell

  • Author
To me again two people will always drive differently as in the video's above it looks like the white Seat actually slowly leaves the line while the red one just rev's and lets the clutch out...

Also in the video's these are `fresh` tyres, will still get the same results when your winter tyres that have been stacked in the garage for 4 or more years. Tyres dry out and get harder?... They must have a life span? Hopefully we can leave the EU when this vote comes about and we wont have lots of issues in all fields caused by EU regs aswell

Did you watch the one with the beemers?

And I'm just curious, don't take this as a personal attack as it's merely a question - Have you actually driven with winter tyres?

And I'm just curious, don't take this as a personal attack as it's merely a question - Have you actually driven with winter tyres?

I know this question wasn't to me but i'd like to point out i don't think anyone here is stating winter tyres are no good. I think the majority just don't think (referring back to your original question) they should be made legal requirements in the UK.

Also, took me a sec to re-find this thread... should be in the general and not polo section?

Edited by Liquidice

  • Author
And I'm just curious, don't take this as a personal attack as it's merely a question - Have you actually driven with winter tyres?

I know this question wasn't to me but i'd like to point out i don't think anyone here is stating winter tyres are no good. I think the majority just don't think (referring back to your original question) they should be made legal requirements in the UK.

Also, took me a sec to re-find this thread... should be in the general and not polo section?

I know some of you aren't saying they are bad, but it just seems some of the people posting are saying they are bad, and I wanted to know if they had actually used them. I know that a lot of you are saying they shouldn't be made legal, which is fair enough - This thread was made to discuss opinions.

And yeah I just noticed, my bad :S Admin can move it perhaps?

No, they don't. Perhaps at +30°C maybe, but they don't go crap just because it's +8°C.

Granted I've not tested and only googled for infomation... but everywhere seems to suggest they lack performance at warmer temps.... If anything, i see there being a bigger reason to enforce a law saying you can't run winter tyres in the Spring, Summer and Autumn then one to enforce having to run them in just winter.

And if they do wear down quicker as you have suggested, people will be (as people are) to lazy to keep checking and are more likely to not only be running winter tyres in the summer, but also winter tyres that are dangerously worn.

I'm not against winter tyres in the slightest and in fact will be getting a set ready for next year no doubt, i'm just against them being the solution.

I've had no problems on +15'C days at all, but I change my tyres for summer use anyway.

Jake- As with any other tyre the performance drops off as tread reduces and the tyre ages, no diff here, most European Countries replace at 3mm I think, rather than 1.6mm as we do, so their tyre life span isn't as long as ours is.

Realistically you've a much higher chance of getting the UK common individual to purchase winter tyres than send drivers on a training course- which you'll want them to pay for too, no one likes being told they're a shit driver, or that they need further training unfortunately, and most insurers won't recognise even the highest standard of advanced driver training/certification, so there's little financial incentive currently.

Make them law- I've already got a set, and I'm an 'advanced driver' - winter tyres help me more than my driver training, although that won't be the same for everyone.

Wow some proper narrow mindedness on here.

All I will add is that I would have one written off Corrado on Friday night if it were not for my winter tyres. Not through me not being able to drive but someone else. They afforded me the grip to get out of the way of some fish tailing idiot who would have hit me because he lost control. Never mind your 'I'm alright Jack as I'm a driving God on my summer tyres' as has been said, You cant beat physics.

Wow some proper narrow mindedness on here.

All I will add is that I would have one written off Corrado on Friday night if it were not for my winter tyres. Not through me not being able to drive but someone else. They afforded me the grip to get out of the way of some fish tailing idiot who would have hit me because he lost control. Never mind your 'I'm alright Jack as I'm a driving God on my summer tyres' as has been said, You cant beat physics.

Probably the best argument FOR the use of winter tyres so far... HOWEVER... if the dumb-ass could drive a little bit better in the first place the whole thing wouldn't have happened, bringing us back to the "driver" issue.

What's the saying? never blame the tools? Well i guess this is roll reversal. Never praise the tools. I bet you were clued up enough to notice he was going to hit.. then drove faster. there was a combination of your driving skills and tyres there.

just saying.

Also, i don't expect anyone to retrain. Hell, the current driving test is 10 times harder then it was when most of us passed, but no ones made us do it again right?? Cheapest option to TRY and solve not just winter driving issues but general driving issues is to make that damn test not harder with eco questions in a theory, but longer by making sure every driver trains in every type of condition.

Edited by Liquidice

  • Author
Probably the best argument FOR the use of winter tyres so far... HOWEVER... if the dumb-ass could drive a little bit better in the first place the whole thing wouldn't have happened, bringing us back to the "driver" issue.

What's the saying? never blame the tools? Well i guess this is roll reversal. Never praise the tools. I bet you were clued up enough to notice he was going to hit.. then drove faster. there was a combination of your driving skills and tyres there.

just saying.

Also, i don't expect anyone to retrain. Hell, the current driving test is 10 times harder then it was when most of us passed, but no ones made us do it again right?? Cheapest option to TRY and solve not just winter driving issues but general driving issues is to make that damn test not harder with eco questions in a theory, but longer by making sure every driver trains in every type of condition.

To be honest I think a couple of lessons should be provided but for like a fiver an hour on a skid pan, attractive price, and hell, it's a skidpan - why wouldn't you want to do it!

But that's the thing. I don't think winter training should be additional, I think it should be a pre-requisite before you take your driving test. An extra module to pass. Half a day on a skidpan, learning what ABS and sliding about feel like. I think it was Mercedes who told me that it's not uncommon for people to trample on their brake pedal, feel it judder or pulse and then lift off a bit wondering what's going on.

It's like motorway driving. What percentage of drivers have been properly taught how to use the motorway? Very few, as it's not part of the driving test. It's no wonder so many people hog the middle lane and do stupid things. Separate issue, I guess, but all part of the same problem.

Ultimately, yes, you can't beat physics and having winter tyres will always be a benefit. And yes, you can't force people to take in what they're taught, but it's got to be better than not training people at all. You only have to look at the number of winter accidents on here to know that young Brits often learn the hard way that driving without adjusting to the conditions is a bad idea. You still still need to adjust your driving, regardless of what rubber you've got.

Edited by Alex

But that's the thing. I don't think winter training should be additional, I think it should be a pre-requisite before you take your driving test. An extra module to pass. Half a day on a skidpan, learning what ABS and sliding about feel like. I think it was Mercedes who told me that it's not uncommon for people to trample on their brake pedal, feel it judder or pulse and then lift off a bit wondering what's going on.

It's like motorway driving. What percentage of drivers have been properly taught how to use the motorway? Very few, as it's not part of the driving test. It's no wonder so many people hog the middle lane and do stupid things. Separate issue, I guess, but all part of the same problem.

Ultimately, yes, you can't beat physics and having winter tyres will always be a benefit. And yes, you can't force people to take in what they're taught, but it's got to be better than not training people at all. You only have to look at the number of winter accidents on here to know that young Brits often learn the hard way that driving without adjusting to the conditions is a bad idea. You still still need to adjust your driving, regardless of what rubber you've got.

+rep.

Everything i have been trying to say only put across a hell of a lot better.

But that's the thing. I don't think winter training should be additional, I think it should be a pre-requisite before you take your driving test. An extra module to pass. Half a day on a skidpan, learning what ABS and sliding about feel like. I think it was Mercedes who told me that it's not uncommon for people to trample on their brake pedal, feel it judder or pulse and then lift off a bit wondering what's going on.

It's like motorway driving. What percentage of drivers have been properly taught how to use the motorway? Very few, as it's not part of the driving test. It's no wonder so many people hog the middle lane and do stupid things. Separate issue, I guess, but all part of the same problem.

Ultimately, yes, you can't beat physics and having winter tyres will always be a benefit. And yes, you can't force people to take in what they're taught, but it's got to be better than not training people at all. You only have to look at the number of winter accidents on here to know that young Brits often learn the hard way that driving without adjusting to the conditions is a bad idea. You still still need to adjust your driving, regardless of what rubber you've got.

There’s no golden bullet here, but reasons why training current UK licence holders would be nigh on impossible:

1- You’ve got to make it the law for people to take the training up. Current insurance policies don’t recognise advanced driving training enough currently (so no current financial incentive for individuals)

2- Logistical nightmare, you’ve got 15million current road users – good luck in staffing, running and certifying additional training within 10 years.

3- New drivers- yes make it law, train them, doesn’t help the current majority on the road.

4- On cost- 1hr with a driving instructor in an unfamiliar car wouldn’t help a great deal. Any ‘learn to drift’ event is evidence enough of this, novice ‘drifters’ just get the hang of it by the end of 6hrs, and they’re ‘car people’

Question- for those who preach driver training is the answer, how many of you have done any recognised advanced driver training/car control courses- if so what were they?

No argument from me about more driving training, but it's not a 'fit and forget' type skill - it's one that needs regularly refreshing and developing. Additionally, correct driver training for low-mu surfaces (instructor, training vehicle, cradle, track) is not cheap - so I'd argue winter tyres are massively cheaper. The last training I did was only half a day and cost my employer around £1500.

However, I don't think this is a winter tyres vs driver training trade-off, both are beneficial and enhance your safety in different ways. Driver training helps you to reduce the amount of danger you expose yourself to, and better manage that danger when it's present - so it's hugely beneficial. It does sweet F.A. to combat physics though, so I'll take increased mechanical grip so I don't skid in the first place, rather than the ability to control a skid 6 times out of 10 in a controlled environment on a skid pan.

Then we're in agreement, that attitudes need to change a bit. Insurers need to support winter tyres and/or extra training. And that at the moment neither are a solution, given that there aren't enough training centres or a suitable storage infrastructure to support either as a legal requirement.

Ongoing training is invaluable, obviously. But that applies in the wider sense. I'd say the majority of drivers on the road won't have picked up a copy of the Highway Code since they took their test. There's no incentive for them to do so. Same applies with training. Obviously you can't re-train everyone on the road, but at least if you start people off in the right way they've got some idea what they're doing. I agree it'd need huge investment though.

Unfortunately I think for most people, priority number one is money. Same story with eco-friendly cars, it's the cost of running a thirsty, high-CO2 car that puts people off, not a sudden shift in public attitude about being green. If drivers can recover the cost of a preventative measures through lower premiums, then maybe they'd be more willing to make the effort to do so.

Yes, I've done a few driver training courses, if you're wondering (though not sure that was aimed at me) :thumbsup:

For the one or two days of snow we get, it is hardly worth forking out a couple of hundred quid for. I think what would be more useful is educating people on how to drive properly in it, too many people are giving it the beans to try and get grip when the key is to use a high gear/low revs for the torque.

This tbh.

Since the UK is crap at handling snow, everything goes into a panic and shuts down, and even after a week or so on clear roads people are driving around at 20mph, looking terrified.

I put snow tyres on my mk2 bready last year, for about three months, and they are back on my car now - and honestly it handles the snow like a landrover. Will hardly slip at all.

What do you think?

gave people ABS and they braked harder and later. Gave people traction control and they nailed it harder. Gave people PAS and they just got more impatient in car parks. Gave people stability control and they take roundabouts at 60mph.. now we're getting cars that can park themselves and, most frighteningly, auto braking..? People are just gonna depend on it.

So winter tyres? You know what that'll lead to - big profits, big tax revenue, motorist getting shafted.. And MORE accidents from people who get cocky running them. Great.

This is the problem, i'd rather people pootle round doing 20 if they're not confident on road conditions than doing 30/40

I had one guy the other day speeding along because the road looked clear but what he didn't know was that just ahead on the right hand lane was a shit load of ice and snow so he stained his underwear and almost wrote his car off by swerving into in my lane - if he had snow tyres i expect he would have done the same since most peoples natural reaction is to panic in situations they are not accustom to or have little knowledge of how to deal with the issue

I'd happily run winter tyres but i say make it part of the driving test, which should actually be more of a course anyway

No point, We hardly have snow so it's a waste of money and something I can't afford to buy,

Were I live I've had one day were the roads have been iced and snowed on, but then it all melted and now its fine.

People just need to learn how to drive, That's the main problem.

Question- for those who preach driver training is the answer, how many of you have done any recognised advanced driver training/car control courses- if so what were they?

Quite a bit, but I haven't had enough coffee today to get into a pissing match, so assume I've got a tractor licence and a Blue Peter badge.

Based on that, I can safely say that when I was 17, my driving test got cancelled so my instructor took me round Skeggy on the ice, snow, slush, slopes and threw in a few emergency stops for good measure. Granted, it was only hour 1 of my education on driving on the slippy stuff, but it held me in very good stead for a lot of years.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.