Skip to content

Should winter tyres be legal in the UK

Featured Replies

Then we're in agreement, that attitudes need to change a bit. Insurers need to support winter tyres and/or extra training. And that at the moment neither are a solution, given that there aren't enough training centres or a suitable storage infrastructure to support either as a legal requirement.

Seems that 'Tyre Hotels' were a bit more prevalent than I thought - presumably not promoted much due to relatively low UK demand for winter rubber. But it sounds like there's options there if you don't want to stick your alternative rubber in the garage/shed/loft. A work colleague pays £15 at Kwik Fit for 6 months storage on 4 tyres.

http://www.kwik-fit.com/winter-tyres-faq.asp#F

http://www.atseuromaster.co.uk/news/tyre-n...s_800721394.htm

http://www.halfordsautocentres.com/en-gb/N...-at-Tyre-Hotel/

Unfortunately I think for most people, priority number one is money. Same story with eco-friendly cars, it's the cost of running a thirsty, high-CO2 car that puts people off, not a sudden shift in public attitude about being green. If drivers can recover the cost of a preventative measures through lower premiums, then maybe they'd be more willing to make the effort to do so.

Money's always an issue, presumably the same reason that people don't bother with using screen wash or buy 50p Chinese tyres made from recycled nylon. But the point does stand, you're not wearing out your summer rubber whilst you're driving on winter stuff - so it's really cashflow rather than outright cost.

I'd strongly support incentives from the insurance industry to encourage use of winter rubber. The likes of IAM or RoSPA advanced driving courses don't specifically give you any low-mu surface training, and places that can offer it are expensive - not because of exclusivity, but because the surfaces and equipment are pricey to buy and maintain.

  • Replies 65
  • Views 3.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I use M+S (all season) tyres from Nov to April on 4.5" rims. I don't drive into the Alps to go skiing anymore so I don't need the full winter tyre high road-noise/dry speed-limit experience.

But I've also got some Knipetak Elkim a/s snowgrips (from Norway). They are like snowchains but fit and remove in a minute. They have got me up a Welsh mountain side road in snow and ice and out of an icy car park up a slope.

Winter tyres do make a difference, i use bridgestone blizzak winter tyres and they have saved me a few times but lack of snow/ice, wear and reduced fuel economy mean i can't justify fitting them especially as they cost £350+ for 4 and at the moment my budget summer tyres are doing the job just as well.

if the snow starts sticking or it gets really icy i'll swap them over otherwise they will stay in my garage.

Edited by polo45

Unfortunately I think for most people, priority number one is money. Same story with eco-friendly cars, it's the cost of running a thirsty, high-CO2 car that puts people off, not a sudden shift in public attitude about being green. If drivers can recover the cost of a preventative measures through lower premiums, then maybe they'd be more willing to make the effort to do so.

Money's always an issue, presumably the same reason that people don't bother with using screen wash or buy 50p Chinese tyres made from recycled nylon. But the point does stand, you're not wearing out your summer rubber whilst you're driving on winter stuff - so it's really cashflow rather than outright cost.

I'd strongly support incentives from the insurance industry to encourage use of winter rubber. The likes of IAM or RoSPA advanced driving courses don't specifically give you any low-mu surface training, and places that can offer it are expensive - not because of exclusivity, but because the surfaces and equipment are pricey to buy and maintain.

I had no idea there were so many about, that must be fairly recent. I guess recent years and a glut of press coverage have put winter tyres on people's minds a bit more of late. I remember a few years ago writing about winter rubber for the dealer mag I used to work for, and back then people were struggling to get a case together for them. A few harsh winters and suddenly they're very much talked about.

Unfortunately I don't think the fleet industry is as enthusiastic. I guess most are worried about shelling out for two pairs of tyres for their cars, and then storing them through the winter. One person I interviewed, off-record, said he and a few others had the attitude that it was better to have drivers watching what they do in snow and bad weather rather than giving them a false sense of security by fitting cold weather rubber. Brilliant though snow tyres are, snow and ice are still low grip surfaces and even the best rubber won't stop you as quickly or let you corner as hard as you would in the dry. Physics again, tricky bastard that it is.

Ultimately as we've said, regardless of anything becoming mandatory (and the driving test revisions are massively unlikely to happen, this goes without saying), it's an issue the insurance industry needs to be getting behind. There's a complete lack of understanding on their part, I've found. A few rumours of premiums going up due to non-standard tyres going on the car (which implies those who swapped and didn't say anything are risking a sneaky back-out if they crash, insurance companies being what they are), and Caroline's insurer responded to my question about raised premiums by saying "Winter tyres, they're the wider ones used to grip on snow, right?" before going off and speaking to a supervisor to work out what to do.

I know that's a call centre monkey on the end of the phone, but it ought to be a commonly understood upgrade that they know how to handle. I'd like to think private buyers who have the good sense to swap to winter tyres probably have a higher awareness of low grip too. Mind you, I suppose the same applies to driving courses.

I'm all for winter tyres personally..

I dont think it will solve anything though, it will simply make drivers that are already fine in snow/ice better, and morons even more idiotic because they believe they can drive normally because they have better tyres.

I remember ringing my insurers (Sky) the first time I got winter tyres, and they were massively bemused that I'd thought they'd see it as a modification. :lol: I'd figured I'd tell them just to be on the safe side, being as the Biased Broadcasting Corporation had been saying you'd be hung out to dry by your insurers if you didn't mention it.

Why would insurers get their knickers in a twist about it though? After all, they're not arsed when someone's got pattern part brake pads, or non-OEM brand tyres, or even tyres with the wrong speed or load rating. I guess it's because we love a good rumour, especially if you can take a fact; mis-interpret it and then twist it out of context Daily Fail style to invent a story! Bring back the Daily Sport!

The fleet industry is too cost driven IMO - they want infinitesimal service intervals, which is why the OEMs have bowed to their pressure, being as fleet customers make up a significant amount of new vehicle buyers. I've got friends with fleet cars through work, and they all have to wait 'til their tyres are illegal before they can get them replaced - it was the same with the pool car fleet too at a previous employer, an automotive engineering consultancy!! I'm sure if fleet insurers started pushing for winter rubber and/or more driver training it'd happen. Having said that, most of the OEMs I've worked with/for have some sort of basic driver training/test for you to pass before driving their cars to keep the insurers happy. And anyone doing high-speed, low-mu, cold weather, handling, high performance etc. driving would have to be appropriately trained with regular refreshers.

Mikey- You should write for the Daily Mail.

I don't read the rags. But on that, maybe then the Daily Mail are realists..

Only someone who doesn't read the Daily Mail would describe it as a realist point of view. :lol:

OH MY GOD, SNOW!!!! PANIC BUY OR YOU WILL STARVE!!!!!

MAN INJURED ON SNOW. FEAR FOR YOUR LIVES!!!

SNOW STOPS, BUT THE WORST IS STILL TO COME!!!!

SNOW NOW MELTING, FEAR THE FLOODS!!!!

It's an outpouring of always sensationalist, often racist, sometimes vaguely paedophilic lies, published by scaremongering nutcases who seem hell bent on making us all stay in our homes fearful of benefit-stealing, drunken, Royal-hating terrorist yobs and cancer-giving foods. The worst thing is, it dresses up as a broadsheet newspaper and delivers its hateful tabloid twaddle like it's well-researched journalism. Evil, evil, evil newspaper.

Excuse the tangent...

Sounds like the mail are sensationalistic, like much of the press then really, because drama sells big. Which rules me completely out of being an appropriate writer for them..

Got bored reading the first page, some good points made and some stupid.

Winter tyres are generally beneficial in cold conditions, but IMO you still need to be able to drive.

Not get the feeling people will put them on and think they can drive like its a warm summers day?

Snow is pretty grippy.

Compressed snow/ice is where the problem lies.

Made me laugh about the Range Rover turning into a petrol station, just because it's a 4wd doesn't mean it's fine to do so haha.

I don't know about other motor manufacturers but we spend at least 3-4 months a year in Sweden in well below Zero temps in snow and ice, a lot of its tuning software for systems like mikey listed, but the difference between tyres is crazy.

Jags, BMWs etc, always stuck, throw a pair of winter tyres on the rear and It TRANSFORMS it.

Tyres are the single thing in contact with the road - no matter what you do to your car, they are still the one thing touching the floor. Unless you have a gay splitter.

Also, driver training such as skid pans, all well and good, but that's a controlled environment, you're expecting it to happen; by the time youve started to "skid" or "slide" on the road you'll probably have smashed into several parked cars.

How would you police it?

You get told you have to pay say £100 for a days course, then have that put onto your license, how long would it take for every license holder to obtain this qualification?

Then would the police have to conduct license checks on everyone to see they're allowed to drive in that days conditions? What dictates if the conditions are bad enough to need the qualification to drive in them?

2 days a year, however many people on the road - would you not just drive anyway? Think, people are happy to drive without tax, insurance, no MOT, who's gonna want to pay for a course which they may need for a day a year, maybe not even that. Ok obviously new drivers learning I could be made mandatory and integrated into the test, but upsilons all the license holders? Good luck.

Fact is people don't adapt out of ignorance, they need to be put into a car and slide down an icey hill into a tree, shake them up a bit, then have someone at the bottom saying "see, slippery that"

  • Author

Fa

ct is people don't adapt out of ignorance, they need to be put into a car and slide down an icey hill into a tree, shake them up a bit, then have someone at the bottom saying "see, slippery that"

:lol:

Interesting range of responses. Unfortunately ignorance will always increase the more people take things for granted, my biggest question though, is how would you teach someone to drive better in conditions like ice or snow when it snows for 2 weeks a year

Seen these before?

skidcar.jpg

No 0_o

What does it do, simulate sliding? (going on basis it says 'skid car' :L)

this is part of my training at work. I great bit of kit!

Still got the Astra there for cradle work?

Mrs Koop's driving instructor took her down an icy road the other day, told her to turn & yanked on the handbrake, saying 'now you know what it feels like to skid' :lol: Good to know some instructors are thinking about training people for adverse conditions not just passing their test! I'm hopefully taking her up Buxton tomorrow to find a nice snowy car park for some skid pan training in the 6n2 ;)

My current tyres are one of the worst things I've ever came across in the snow, I have a pair of Toyos on the front. They are ridiculous, as soon as they touch a spot of snow and ice it's game over.

Being a non retarded member of public I'm about to change these over to a set of winter tyres. It's all well and good saying that all season tyres do they job, but they are not a requirement. The amount of bald tyres you spot is pathetic, never mind tyres that are capable of harsh weather.

My Nankangs are epic in snow and ice :badgrin::unibrow:

My Nankangs are epic in snow and ice :badgrin::unibrow:

I'm starting to like the idea of winter tyres - but only on the front axle :badgrin:

Toyo's are the worse. Fine in slush and wet, but snow, ahahahahahahhaaaaa. :lol:

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.