Skip to content

Idiots valuing cars..

Featured Replies

So today I offered someone a swap, my car a 1.3 GT converted Polo with a 64,000 miles shell which is clean as hell without a spot of rust, in offer for his standard 1.0, Y reg lupo.

When I sent him the pictures he instantly started going on and on asif my car was a pile of sh*t basically. He valued his lupo at £1850 and insisted that my car was worth no more than £150!

My question is, are the polo's only really worth the money to the people who know more about the polo scene or was this guy just a complete idiot. Personally I'd value my car between £800-£1000. 3 owners from new, mint shell, GT engine, clocks, corrado interior, lowered, arb blocks, 3 spoke alloys etc.

Maybe I valued mine far too high and his too little? Sort of a little discussion, What's my car worth? Was I in the wrong? Was he?

I just found it all quite funny and just thought I'd bring the subject up, anyway after several abusive messages from him this was my reply..

2B458E7E-DCA9-4A6A-AB5D-3FA5C6728B25-185

So, my question to you. What car do you have? What mods does your car have? & How would you personally value your own?

This is a quick picture of mine for those of you that haven't seen it before.

6DDC731E-C2D6-4429-8F59-744112A52200-227

  • Replies 29
  • Views 1.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Just looking at them messages he sent you he seems to be a complete and utter prick plain and simple

But didnt you but it for £160? And is the GT engine fitted?

He's a tool regardless but if the car cost you so little its gone up in value a hell of alot

PS lupo a are gay and your cars much better

Edited by matt-c

£1850 for a y reg lupo rofl!

£1850 for a y reg lupo rofl!

Thats exactly what I thought! They guy is having a laugh

His lupo should be like 1k but then yours is hugely overpriced aswell. If you can buy a gt for less money then the conversion is overpriced. I'd personally value yours 6-800 maximum . For a mk3 polo to be worth 1k its got to be pretty special. G40s are easy worth over the 1k mark as the engine is loads of expensive bits bolted together, but seeing as GT conversions arn't worth much it doesnt add that much value to the car itself.

His lupo should be like 1k but then yours is hugely overpriced aswell. If you can buy a gt for less money then the conversion is overpriced. I'd personally value yours 6-800 maximum . For a mk3 polo to be worth 1k its got to be pretty special. G40s are easy worth over the 1k mark as the engine is loads of expensive bits bolted together, but seeing as GT conversions arn't worth much it doesnt add that much value to the car itself.

Thats old hat pricing though, Imo I do agree that GT/G40 conversions are worth less than an original but seem now G40's struggle to sell for 2k and above where GT's & Conversions etc are knocking on the 1k-1.5k mark quite easily due to the vw/rare/age factor now plus they need minimal maintenance, they are cheap insurance wise etc

Alot of the younger guys and girls are paying for what they want now even if it is "over" what people think....

As far as Lupo's go seem tdi's,sports and gti's hold there money but none of the others again Imo plus I know the belts need doing like every 40k as they snap about 40k seen a fair few about to or gone

  • Author

Well, I sold my last car, a 1.0 54,000 miles, fully standard, rusty arches for £700.

Yeah I payed £160 for it but what's the point in me selling it for £160 when I know it's worth a hell of a lot more? At the end of the pay he though his lupo was worth nearly £2k! There's coupes in classified ATM for £800+! Personally I'd say iv valued mine right, not fussed if it doesn't sell for that and I'm open to sensible offers but to be honest I think I'd rather keep it rather than deal with idiots like this everyday!

What happened to the deal with Andy Col? Thought that was happening on Sunday?

  • Author
What happened to the deal with Andy Col? Thought that was happening on Sunday?

He lost his job I believe mate, so he couldn't make it up! I can't get insurance for the bora either so looks like il be keeping this!

I bought my first polo for £200 with 40k on the clock but I wouldn't have scene taxed it just to scrape the extra dosh. I agree with jake here, all the younger members pay over the odds for the lower spec cars so the price has rocketed up.

People don't understand that modding cars rarely increases the for sale price. People buy a polo off a grandad pay 200 for a Phil j kitt and pic some wheels up from a scrap yard spay em with some paint then sell it on for triple the price.

When your knocking on the door of g40 prices I personally think its over priced. Maybe if yours was a 1.4 or 1.6 gt on coils then maybe it would be worth it.

It's why I've never sold a polo tbh, my first G got stolen but I'd still have it now if it hadnt been

I bought my first polo for £200 with 40k on the clock but I wouldn't have scene taxed it just to scrape the extra dosh. I agree with jake here, all the younger members pay over the odds for the lower spec cars so the price has rocketed up.

People don't understand that modding cars rarely increases the for sale price. People buy a polo off a grandad pay 200 for a Phil j kitt and pic some wheels up from a scrap yard spay em with some paint then sell it on for triple the price.

When your knocking on the door of g40 prices I personally think its over priced. Maybe if yours was a 1.4 or 1.6 gt on coils then maybe it would be worth it.

It's why I've never sold a polo tbh, my first G got stolen but I'd still have it now if it hadnt been

I reckon Gt's in good condition with a good engine ect is worth a good 1200firm. That's my opinion anyway Id happily pay that for one that is in good condition drives well and pulls fairly good!

  • Author

£800 is not knocking on the door of G40 prices! Triple it then yeah! I didn't buy mine off an old man though, and when the exhaust is worth more than I payed I'm not stupid enough to give it away!

My car has 60k on the shell and 70k on the engine and its clean as hell! I'd say its worth every penny of £800.

Lupos are worth fuck all :lol: What an idiot!

Your polo will be worth more than that Lupo easily!

I love Lupos & I'd still say a 1.0 had better be on air for £1850, or have about 10K on the clock :lol:

  • Author
Lupos are worth fuck all :lol: What an idiot!

Your polo will be worth more than that Lupo easily!

I can't find one below £1k :/

  • Author
I love Lupos & I'd still say a 1.0 had better be on air for £1850, or have about 10K on the clock :lol:

I sold my 1.4 lupo for £750 and I felt like I robbed the guy, to be honest it was a bit of a dog for £750 but I can't see how a 1.0 will be worth over a thousand pound more. Slow & sluggish in comparison to the 1.4!

I love Lupos & I'd still say a 1.0 had better be on air for £1850, or have about 10K on the clock :lol:

I sold my 1.4 lupo for £750 and I felt like I robbed the guy, to be honest it was a bit of a dog for £750 but I can't see how a 1.0 will be worth over a thousand pound more. Slow & sluggish in comparison to the 1.4!

My mate had to accept £400 for his 1l lupo because no-one wanted to buy it :lol: My brothers 1.4 isn't worth a great deal more either.

Can I ask why you want to move from a mint polo GT to a Lupo? Other than build quality, Lupos are pretty crap you know, especially in comparison to a polo GT! :? They're overcomplicated, boring, undersized, overpriced compared to your polo. If it was GTI then its a different story.

Edited by Phataz1

  • Author
I love Lupos & I'd still say a 1.0 had better be on air for £1850, or have about 10K on the clock :lol:

I sold my 1.4 lupo for £750 and I felt like I robbed the guy, to be honest it was a bit of a dog for £750 but I can't see how a 1.0 will be worth over a thousand pound more. Slow & sluggish in comparison to the 1.4!

My mate had to accept £400 for his 1l lupo because no-one wanted to buy it :lol: My brothers 1.4 isn't worth a great deal more either.

Can I ask why you want to move from a mint polo GT to a Lupo? Other than build quality, Lupos are pretty crap you know, especially in comparison to a polo GT! :? They're overcomplicated, boring, undersized, overpriced compared to your polo. If it was GTI then its a different story.

I don't know! After I owned mine I just really wanted another! I personally think they look amazing slammed on there arse on ats classics! That's all I want, oh they're also VERY cheap insurance!

Your Mk3 is tasty, I'd offer to swap my Lupo sport but you won't get classics over the brakes ;)

  • Author
Your Mk3 is tasty, I'd offer to swap my Lupo sport but you won't get classics over the brakes ;)

Can't insure sports either :(

I find it funny that you value your car at the same price as the Corrado 2.0 16v in the for sale section. Youngsters at home always have disposable income but can only realistically insure small engines. Just crazy when you think about the value of the cars new.

  • Author
I find it funny that you value your car at the same price as the Corrado 2.0 16v in the for sale section. Youngsters at home always have disposable income but can only realistically insure small engines. Just crazy when you think about the value of the cars new.

Does this mean I'm valuing my car too high? :lol:

i sold my bog standard 1.0 genesis for £695 to a middle aged bloke in scotland(not vw scene) it had 48,000 on it was on a k plate

didnt have tax either and hes was over the moon =6 moths ago

I've also sold a ex crash damages gt for £650 with no tax and it was a dog=1 year ago (not vw scene either)

so in my opinion its worth £800 anytime

I sold a dog of a gt on here for £200 with 6mths mot and 1 day of tax.

My opinion is I wouldn't give you £800 but I'm sure someone will.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.