Skip to content

Has this ever happened to your car

Featured Replies

While slowly driving off a roundabout, my wheels locked up causing me to stop suddenly. I tried to get out but my door seemed to be jammed shut, after awkwardly getting out of the passenger door I found the wheel wasn't where it was supposed to be...

577524_281980131935739_1131190786_n.jpg

27121_281980095269076_1616199513_n.jpg

263603_281817171952035_2091302368_n.jpg

Ball joint had separated from where it connects on strut and driveshaft disconnected causing the wheel to be pushed up into the arch causing a little bit of damage...

Has this happened to anyone else?

After changing the balljoint I'm now in constant fear it'll happen again.

  • Replies 23
  • Views 1.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • kwijibo_coupe
    kwijibo_coupe

    That sounds about right to me, as you say it is only an M10 bolt and 50Nm is plenty to pinch the ball joint. The lock nut will prevent the bolt coming loose.

Yoooo! stance! :lol:

Just make sure the pinch bolt on the ball joint is tight lol

Yep, happened to me with both the red and blue one, all the same side too! I was going quite swiftly over a major roundabout on a dual carriageway the first time, the red one, spun me off the road. No other damage though.

Was at walking pace in the blue one, stopping in the left lane of a roundabout, doing only slight damage to the wing.

In both cases mine was the pinch bolt that clamps the hub to the ball joint. The first time it was an old bolt from before my time and had a thinner neck than it should've had. The second time i'd stupidly fitted a bolt with a shoulder that wasn't long enough, and the ball joint cut through the first thread of the bolt.

My current ones were carefully chosen! The ball joint and clamp do need to be in good order, seen two others report it on here.

It's actually the leverage placed onto the joint from the ARB that does it - if there was no ARB on the front but alternative stabiliser bars/wishbones it wouldn't happen. You must've been steering toward the left when it let go..

You can just see the damage to the first car in this pic - the arch trim covers the damage on the blue one..

UTF-8BVG9yZW5naW4uanBn.jpg

I had this. Nearly put me in the ditch. As mikey said, the pinch bolt had gone awol!

I had this happen to me as I was accelerating over a speedhump. I had just replaced the drivers side TCA. Turns out the TCA was a dodgy part from a dodgy dealer. Luckily for me I was able to pull to the side of road. With my AA cover I got it moved to my uncles garage the following day and replaced the TCA and the pinch bolt. I had been driving at a very fast speed on a good straight road only a few minutes before it happened to me. If it happened at highspeed the car woulda rolled over violently for sure.

This thread gets more worrying with every reply :shock:

This thread gets more worrying with every reply :shock:

I was just thinking that! :lol:

Makes me wanna check mine in the snow! :lol:

This thread gets more worrying with every reply :shock:

I was just thinking that! :lol:

X3 :lol:

  • Author

Glad I'm not the only one to have experienced this, I think part of the problem is my stiff shocks as well as a ball joint with at least 20k miles on it. I'm temped to go back to standard shocks if it'll help soften things up.

Any advice on how to prevent this? Replacing ball joints every year etc?

the Just keep checking you are bushes on your track control arm. When the bottom ball joint starts getting stressed or loose u will see the bushes in the track control arm start to bulge out one side and wear excessively quick. as inok 1 month and bulging the next. Just a suggestion of something to check. The pinch bolts start to slip as the stress stretches n wrecks the threads then its kaboom!

Glad I'm not the only one to have experienced this, I think part of the problem is my stiff shocks as well as a ball joint with at least 20k miles on it. I'm temped to go back to standard shocks if it'll help soften things up.

Any advice on how to prevent this? Replacing ball joints every year etc?

So I saw this thread while bored at work. While having a fag, I thought I'd have a look to see which bolt you guys meant. It was at this point I noticed, that on the drivers side, ITS FUCKING MISSING!!!!!!!!!!!

I'm driving home very carefully tonight.

funnily enough, this happened to me!!! in the snow last year!! lol

I wouldn't have driven anywhere on it Tim. There's nothing keeping that ball joint located except for the friction. And I grease mine to help ease them in. Here's hoping you got back all right, but I would have searched about for a bolt to at least get me back, and driven slowly!

Good awareness thread this, never knew about this problem. It got mentioned in my mot last week that there's a little play so will be changing it pronto!

Brother bought a minty mk2 coupe of a mod on here, he complianed of vauge steering on the trip home...

The nutwas hanging for dear life on the last few threads of the ball joint! :lol:

Edited by Matt G40

I wouldn't have driven anywhere on it Tim. There's nothing keeping that ball joint located except for the friction. And I grease mine to help ease them in. Here's hoping you got back all right, but I would have searched about for a bolt to at least get me back, and driven slowly!

I just drove very carefully home. I don't understand why it wasn't there, I definately put it back last time I had a play down there, which must have been around October time.

I've found a big old nut and bolt and friction washer to hold it for the time being, which seems tight, and I'll just check it every day.

Where do you reckon I could get another bolt?

Where do you reckon I could get another bolt?

VW should sell them. Unless they are no longer available!

I reckon most of this is them not being torqued up correctly meaning the strut is not fully clamped round the ball joint.. maybe... :?

First I saw of it was this:

IMG00290-20130311-1118_zpsf389f54f.jpg

In Duck Sherminator's thread. Then this thread popped up and I'm surprised and scared to hear the number of times this has happened or nearly happened.

I'm also a victim, guy who had it before me botched it.

I got a Tip off an old boy as this was fairly common on fords back in his day.

He said to tighten the bolt till its tight, them smack it with a hammer. Tighten more, smack it with hammer and tighten more. Worked for me, does always put that element of doubt in your mind tho once it's happened.

1 the bolts are 10.9 not 8.8 - so it may have snapped being lesser grade (if indeed it was) plus they are nyloc nuts - so as a rule should be used once.

  • 6 years later...

Resurrecting an old thread here but I'm going to be installing new TCAs and balljoint pinch bolts tomorrow and this has gotten me rather spooked to say the least!

 

I have two new 10.9 Febi set screws and locknuts to replace the old pinch bolts (has the right length of un-threaded collar). Haynes says they need to be done up to 50Nm - this sounds relatively low to me but I guess its only an M10 thread... Could do with some reassurance that following the torque settings and using these screws is going to be alright...!

9 hours ago, zob said:

Resurrecting an old thread here but I'm going to be installing new TCAs and balljoint pinch bolts tomorrow and this has gotten me rather spooked to say the least!

 

I have two new 10.9 Febi set screws and locknuts to replace the old pinch bolts (has the right length of un-threaded collar). Haynes says they need to be done up to 50Nm - this sounds relatively low to me but I guess its only an M10 thread... Could do with some reassurance that following the torque settings and using these screws is going to be alright...!

 

That sounds about right to me, as you say it is only an M10 bolt and 50Nm is plenty to pinch the ball joint. The lock nut will prevent the bolt coming loose.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.