Skip to content

Your advice please...

Featured Replies

My polo may be about to get to the end of it's useful life. It's a 1.4 petrol manual 5 door.

The clutch has just started to slip. This is not major at this stage - you only feel it under hard accelaertaion (which is generally how i drive it)

The starter motor can take upto 4 goes to crank. It's like playing starter motor roulette in the morning and makes the funniest sounds.

The pipe that has the hydraulic fluid for the PAS and clutch has a weep / leak. It needs topping up every 2-3 months.

My trusty mechanic reckons all three jobs should either be done together or not at all. Reason being that pipe goes under the battery around the gearbox under and over. To repair the faulty parts of the pipe, it needs to come out without further damaging it and to do that it's easier with the 'box out the way and that would be part of doing the clutch and that is part of doing the starter motor.

He reckon £3-350 quid total for all of that mainly split 50/50 between parts and labour.

The car has a couple of months MOT left, 6 months tax, like new tyres (part worns)... and it drives pretty well.

SO.......... what to do. it surely aint worth chucking 350 at a car that's not worth much more is it?

Just wondered what some of the thoughts are on here of you guys. Scrap it? Fix it? Break it and sell the parts? Sell it as it is and let someone else fix it?

  • Replies 6
  • Views 725
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Thing is you could get rid and buy another car that turns out to be a money pit.

If there's nothing else wrong with it and you enjoy driving it then keep it and get it done.

Likelyhood is any car you ever own you will never make your money back on what you spend on it to keep it on the road safely.... Just one of them things

In 8 out of 10 cases, are car you already have is the cheapest one available.

The other two cases are for big problems etc

Another 2nd hand car will have thingsnthat need doing nearly always. There comes a time when a change is sensible, but its often later than you think.

Imho

Had this thought with the MK4 Golf. Got it for a grand, it's tidy but had done 140k, i figured it was good for a year or two and then get the same price passing it on. But it's cost a DMF/clutch and a new turbo rebuild kit!

I've managed to source all that for less than £500 altogether and fit it myself, but it puts us in a new position. I'd now be lucky to get the money back but we have a Golf4 PD with it all done, with the cambelt i did in the first week it's good for another 50k/5yrs now. So why sell it..?

Yeah i've thrown a few more ton at it than i intended, but it's now a good strong perfectly-working reliable car. She's happy with it, that's the whole point, so i now don't wanna risk getting anything else instead, and inherit a load of new issues.

If you know it's a good car, knowing the car, it's often best to just bite the bullet and sort what needs doing, to get it right again.

Are you sure the starter issue isn't because you've got an old battery?

thats sounds like a fairly decent mechanic to me i think i'd just get it sorted like as above unless your spending a few ££££ and buying a newer car not much point in getting another car because your just gona end up with the same problem

Sounds a lot cheaper than changing cars.

As has been said, if you change it, you could be buying a different set of issues anyway which could cost even more.

I wouldn't consider getting rid because of such trivial issues, plus your mechanic sounds like he is not a rip off merchant as he is rightly grouping the jobs as one for labour and not doing the usual of quoting labour as a separate item for each job when they overlap.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.