Skip to content

Which one should i get?

Featured Replies

Hi i am new on here and have always been into vws and currently have a mk1 golf gti which i am restoring.

My name is Harry i am only 16 and not turning 17 till august. However i am planning on buying a crash damaged polo to repair for my first car as i have all the tools i need to be able to do it and it is all i can afford.

Now the part i need help with i am looking to buy a 6n2 model but not sure which one to get here are my choices,

1.0 Petrol - £3100 insurance

1.4 16v petrol - £3500 insurance

1.9 SDI - £3500 insurance

What do you think the best choice is as whichever one i choose it will be going to the floor with some other mods.

Thanks for reading and appreciate any comments.

  • Replies 19
  • Views 1.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Dude for the extra £400 on insurance for the 1.4 16v is that for a 100bhp or 75bhp?

Fucking hell! Are they the current prices? Insane!

get a gt like my cousin, his insurance is 2200 on it which is the same if not cheaper then a 1 litre corsa

Thats why I ended up with black box insurance. Sucks that I have to drive well but it was only £1200 fully comp. worth looking into if you aren't going street racing haha. But i think for the little difference you would have better fuel economy on longer journeys in the 1.4 or the 1.9, or if you are just driving into town and back then you only really need a 1.0. Personally I would have the 1.4 :p

Fucking hell! Are they the current prices? Insane!

Define current prices, I did some quotes last night and found my insurance on shit like MX5's has dropped a good 400 quid 8-)

  • Author
Dude for the extra £400 on insurance for the 1.4 16v is that for a 100bhp or 75bhp?

I think it's just for the 75bhp but will have a check when I am next on my laptop.

  • Author
Dude for the extra £400 on insurance for the 1.4 16v is that for a 100bhp or 75bhp?

Yeah it's ridiculous for me, I think it is because of where I live and that it is only kept on the road.

  • Author
Fucking hell! Are they the current prices? Insane!

I can't get insured on one at all had a check last night.

  • Author
Thats why I ended up with black box insurance. Sucks that I have to drive well but it was only £1200 fully comp. worth looking into if you aren't going street racing haha. But i think for the little difference you would have better fuel economy on longer journeys in the 1.4 or the 1.9, or if you are just driving into town and back then you only really need a 1.0. Personally I would have the 1.4 :p

Yeah these quotes are from a black box company.

I will driving quite a lot in the car so I think the 1.0 is out of question really, just put it there to compare with I think I'm just not sure one will be better for performance in the long run e.g after the first year I will be on a normal policy.

If i was starting out now i'd never afford a car at all. Cant wait to be 25 so i can insure most things at a reasonable price (only 15 months to go :-D) . Quite happy with a 1.0 until then, and probabbly after that too as it is perfectly fine. Are those prices fully comp? If so theres no point in fully comp insurance, as being an old car it will be written off anyway if you crash, so no point paying more. I've never been fully comp. You can forget modifying it as well at your age (i left my first car alone apart from a few stickers and a cheapo stereo system). Most insurance companys of the few that will insure you wont touch you when you start declaring lowering kits and alloys etc. And if you dont declare, and crash (which is a certainty, everyone does) they wont pay out and you could be landed in all kinds of trouble.

The 1.0 will be fine for lots of driving. I use mine for long motorway journeys regularly and was using it to go to work before i lost my job. A 6n2 is alot more refined than a 4 speed MK2F too. No point paying £400 more for the more powerful engine when you have one of those boxes and have to drive like a pensioner anyway.

Best way to go is the 1.0 and leave it totally standard for the first year with the box in.

I can actually insure almost anything, was on trade insurance for years but these days i'm looking at no hike for limo stuff - been looking at 750iL's and Merc S500s in my wonder for something different, i think in the push for 4/5drs with no commute anymore and it's only a matter of time before i go for something like that.

The insurance isn't stopping me but the fear that a V12 won't exite like a carb'd Polo can is rather scary..

where are you getting those prices from? they're a bit steep! but if i were you, i'd wait til you've passed your test before you get a car, then when you renew your insurance next year, you can say you've got 1 years driving experience... not 9 months, for example :wink:

but back on topic, try going on www.tiger.co.uk and try getting quotes on there. its a compare site for young drivers which got my insurance down a fuck load! :thumbsup:

  • Author
If i was starting out now i'd never afford a car at all. Cant wait to be 25 so i can insure most things at a reasonable price (only 15 months to go :-D) . Quite happy with a 1.0 until then, and probabbly after that too as it is perfectly fine. Are those prices fully comp? If so theres no point in fully comp insurance, as being an old car it will be written off anyway if you crash, so no point paying more. I've never been fully comp. You can forget modifying it as well at your age (i left my first car alone apart from a few stickers and a cheapo stereo system). Most insurance companys of the few that will insure you wont touch you when you start declaring lowering kits and alloys etc. And if you dont declare, and crash (which is a certainty, everyone does) they wont pay out and you could be landed in all kinds of trouble.

The 1.0 will be fine for lots of driving. I use mine for long motorway journeys regularly and was using it to go to work before i lost my job. A 6n2 is alot more refined than a 4 speed MK2F too. No point paying £400 more for the more powerful engine when you have one of those boxes and have to drive like a pensioner anyway.

Best way to go is the 1.0 and leave it totally standard for the first year with the box in.

Yeah i know that this is the right option and the one i am swaying to at the moment, then get a more powerful one after my first year of driving.

From the quotes i have had fully comp is the cheapest for the time being and on a black box policy you have to be fully comp anyway.

Thank you,

Harry

  • Author
where are you getting those prices from? they're a bit steep! but if i were you, i'd wait til you've passed your test before you get a car, then when you renew your insurance next year, you can say you've got 1 years driving experience... not 9 months, for example :wink:

but back on topic, try going on www.tiger.co.uk and try getting quotes on there. its a compare site for young drivers which got my insurance down a fuck load! :thumbsup:

Cheers gonna have a look at that site now, The prices are from a black box insurance company called Ingenie which seems to have been the cheapest out of the few i have tried.

Am looking to buy the car now as i am buying one that has been written off as i have all i need to be able to repair it, so it should be cheaper. I dont turn 17 till august and am planning to pass my test straight away.

Thank for all the comments going to go and have a look at a few things now and then decide what is going to be the best option.

I would just like to say i love forums like this where people are willing to help you when your just new here.

The insurance isn't stopping me but the fear that a V12 won't exite like a carb'd Polo can is rather scary..

If you get more excited over a Polo on carbs than a sexy ass merc v12 you must be have been breathing the fuel vapors again? :lol:

Thats why I ended up with black box insurance. Sucks that I have to drive well but it was only £1200 fully comp. worth looking into if you aren't going street racing haha. But i think for the little difference you would have better fuel economy on longer journeys in the 1.4 or the 1.9, or if you are just driving into town and back then you only really need a 1.0. Personally I would have the 1.4 :p

Yeah these quotes are from a black box company.

I will driving quite a lot in the car so I think the 1.0 is out of question really, just put it there to compare with I think I'm just not sure one will be better for performance in the long run e.g after the first year I will be on a normal policy.

If it helps, my 1.0 6n2 averages at 37mpg driving around town, its not great, but when you get up to 60mph in it, it is sitting at 3200rpm and it drinks the fuel

What do you think the best choice is as whichever one i choose it will be going to the floor with some other mods.

Thanks for reading and appreciate any comments.

dude being a young kid, those insurance prices are astronomically high, and will only increase with mods such as lowering it 'on the floor'

Be very careful with your choice of insurer as some that will quote you the best standard price, might not even touch modified cars, which means a higher quote from a specialist insurer may net you savings, when you come to modify it.

don't run undisclosed mod's, just rock a standard car, pile your cash into your mk1 golf resto, and you'll appreciate driving that much more when the time comes, over a tiny engined slammed newish car :)

  • Author

Thanks to the help and comments on this site i have decided just to go with the 1.0 now.

If i do this it means that the cost of insuring the 1.4 un-modified i can insure the 1.0 with mods for a similar price and the speed doesnt really bother me anyway as my future plans will sort the speed side of me out (Harry goes into a daydream).

Basically my plan is to take the 1.0 off the road and hopefully insure a 1.4 tdi for a year during this time i plan to put a 1.9 GT TDI engine in the 1.0 which will hopefully become my daily during my third and fourth year of driving. Then when i turn 21 i hope to be able to afford to put the Golf on the road.

Thanks again Harry.

The insurance isn't stopping me but the fear that a V12 won't exite like a carb'd Polo can is rather scary..

If you get more excited over a Polo on carbs than a sexy ass merc v12 you must be have been breathing the fuel vapors again? :lol:

Depends what floats your boat - I live near a karting track but I don't have to use it thanks to the Polo. I have a sofa at home I can use for free instead of a barge. I think the only way a V12 is gonna fill a void in my life is if I put it into an MGB.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.