Skip to content

What to do with my G40

Featured Replies

Hi all,

I need thoughts on what I should do with my G40.

Some may know the story so far with how I bought it back in 2009 and melted a piston the day after.

Since then I've had the bottom end rebuilt and got the engine back together.

After 2 years and lots of time, money and effort I did get the car running, kinda but then the oil pump failed.

Took the engine out, replaced the oil pump and since I was now renting a garage for my cars I took my time and tidied things up before the engine went back in.

For about a week the car seemed to run fine, but I was just starting it up, letting it run and taking it little runs around where my garage is.

One afternoon I went to see the car and found the battery was dead so I hooked the car up to a battery charger which also has an engine start function.

The car fired up fine but then died after about 3 seconds and since then the engine hasn't run at all.

I've spent a fair bit of money since chasing electrical and mechanical problems which I think might be causing the issue.

Now I've run out of patience with the car and I have come up with a list of 3 options for the car.

1, Keep going buying new/used parts (which includes wiring looms, engine parts etc) and hope I stumble across the problem soon.

2, Buy a crash damaged, failed MOT G40 which runs and make 1 good car out of 2.

3, Buy a good complete G40 and use mine for spares.

I don't want to give up completely as I want my G smiles again but I need to know the best way forward.

  • Replies 25
  • Views 2.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Out of interest have you tried a different ECU , i fried mine on the GT a few years back by using a charger with a starting function , took weeks of head scratching till i finally tried another ECU .

Take it to a specialist - the reason I say this is that I used to own one having wanted one for years. When I finally bought a stock low mileage one it kept stalling on me which although it ran used to drive me mad as there was nor rime or reason to it. I spent loads of money on alternator, fuel pump, timing, pipes only to take it to stealth racing who diagnosed it as having a faulty ecu code that had not been deleted.

Don't give up though g smiles are great.

wow kudos for patience, I get tired of fixing new things every 2-3 months, but at least it works well in between.

All those options are going to be pricey, imo i'd say keep at see if it can't be salvaged, its a lot of effort to give up on it now, but if you have the money keep an eye out for good un, but make sure it really is a cracker lol, wouldn't want to end up with two non runners thats for sure.

  • Author

If I was to keep buying parts my next port of call would be the engine loom and ECU but it's finding good ones at a decent price.

I don't want to take it to anyone else to fix, I hate paying someone to do something I can do myself.

What ever I do it's going to be pricey but I new owning a G40 would be a costly venture.

Edited by kwijibo_coupe

I have a G40 engine loom that I bought as a spare for mine. G40 is long gone but the loom still remains. £60 including courier.

You could try this company to test the ECU Link

  • Author

If it has done the ECU will it have killed it completely?

The reason I ask is I do believe the one I have has an 8k limiter chip in it.

If I get another ECU and it works would it be worth swapping the chip over or could that be fooked too?

If it has done the ECU will it have killed it completely?

The reason I ask is I do believe the one I have has an 8k limiter chip in it.

If I get another ECU and it works would it be worth swapping the chip over or could that be fooked too?

If your lucky it might of only damaged the internal power supply, they should have protection against high voltage spikes that might of occured when you used the jumpstart pack.

If you did get another ECU you might as well try the chip, nothing to loose.

  • Author
If it has done the ECU will it have killed it completely?

The reason I ask is I do believe the one I have has an 8k limiter chip in it.

If I get another ECU and it works would it be worth swapping the chip over or could that be fooked too?

If your lucky it might of only damaged the internal power supply, they should have protection against high voltage spikes that might of occured when you used the jumpstart pack.

If you did get another ECU you might as well try the chip, nothing to loose.

I might just play it safe and get a new chip for the car.

Thanks everyone for the responses to this thread so far, a couple of options have opened up as a result, I'll update in the near future with what I decide.

Just hope I get the G smiles back soon :)

Dont give after all the hard work and time !

bring it down to my house and leave it for a week or so when its sunny, can play the swap and try game.

cant give up after all that.

bring it down to my house and leave it for a week or so when its sunny, can play the swap and try game.

cant give up after all that.

Yay for Rich. don't sell up regardless itll be something minor and you'll be buzzing when you get to drive it again, no matter for how long till it goes again!

Bin the chip, having it standard will be easier to resolve.

I don't want to take it to anyone else to fix, I hate paying someone to do something I can do myself.

Without sounding harsh mate...you can't. Otherwise you'd have it running.

Do you want to try your ECU on my G40 since I know my motor runs, or vice versa my ECU on your car?

Checking continuity of loom wouldn't be difficult with a multi-meter.

I take my both my vws to a local specialist who has a passion for VW polos - i think that i know a bit about cars but not really and diagnosing a fault can be a nightmare. Having had a g40 with running issues myself i would take it somewhere that i trust.

Turn the ignition on without turning the starter motor over. You should hear the fuel pump priming for a couple of seconds under the back seat. If this happens then your ECU is basically working (although the ECU could still have problems it means that your 8K chip is definately OK; this holds the complete program for the microprocessor in the ECU and it will not run at all if this chip is damaged). If nothing happens possible failed parts are the 2 relays near the ECU; one is for the ECU power itself and the other is for the fuel pump. Also worth checking the earth connections; the bolts holding the coil on are one of the earth points; one of my G40s died completely because this was corroded. I would think you would be unlucky if the problem was the loom itself unless someone has hacked about with it or there is an immobiliser fitted. If the fuel pump primes check for a spark when turning the engine over. If there is no spark possible problems are the hall sensor in the dizzy (this would also mean no fuel - fuel pump would only run during the priming), the coil (would still get fuel) or the coil drive transistor in the ECU (would still get fuel). Spark but no fuel suggests a problem with the fuel pump relay or fuel pump relay drive transistor in the ECU. You can check for fuel injectors running by looking to see if the plugs are wet after cranking it over for a bit. If you get a spark then the hall sensor in the dizzy is definately OK.

I have a spare ECU that works Steevo...you can have that if you want it..?

  • Author
I don't want to take it to anyone else to fix, I hate paying someone to do something I can do myself.

Without sounding harsh mate...you can't. Otherwise you'd have it running.

Do you want to try your ECU on my G40 since I know my motor runs, or vice versa my ECU on your car?

Checking continuity of loom wouldn't be difficult with a multi-meter.

I can fix it but if you see what I'm working with it's generally just a mess of standard, bodged and aftermarket bits all over the place.

I've been over the loom with a multimeter but it's been hacked up, chopped and bodged so many times I'd be happier with a complete standard loom just to rule that out as I hate dealing with wiring.

I didn't know you had a G40 just now...I've got a plan in place now anyway but if it fails I wouldn't mind a second opinion with a running G40.

I have a spare ECU that works Steevo...you can have that if you want it..?

I have some goodies in the post along with an ECU so I should be ok Scott, cheers anyway though, I'll let you know how I get on.

Best of luck hope you get it sorted these things need saving.

Best of luck hope you get it sorted these things need saving.

I don't want to take it to anyone else to fix, I hate paying someone to do something I can do myself.

Without sounding harsh mate...you can't. Otherwise you'd have it running.

Do you want to try your ECU on my G40 since I know my motor runs, or vice versa my ECU on your car?

Checking continuity of loom wouldn't be difficult with a multi-meter.

I can fix it but if you see what I'm working with it's generally just a mess of standard, bodged and aftermarket bits all over the place.

I've been over the loom with a multimeter but it's been hacked up, chopped and bodged so many times I'd be happier with a complete standard loom just to rule that out as I hate dealing with wiring.

I didn't know you had a G40 just now...I've got a plan in place now anyway but if it fails I wouldn't mind a second opinion with a running G40.

I have a spare ECU that works Steevo...you can have that if you want it..?

I have some goodies in the post along with an ECU so I should be ok Scott, cheers anyway though, I'll let you know how I get on.

Keep me posted, just down the road.

  • Author

Well thanks to the kind man that is Stinkypete I now have a replacement engine loom and ECU along with a couple other bits and pieces for my G40.

I will not give up...:)

Turn the ignition on without turning the starter motor over. You should hear the fuel pump priming for a couple of seconds under the back seat. If this happens then your ECU is basically working (although the ECU could still have problems it means that your 8K chip is definately OK; this holds the complete program for the microprocessor in the ECU and it will not run at all if this chip is damaged). If nothing happens possible failed parts are the 2 relays near the ECU; one is for the ECU power itself and the other is for the fuel pump. Also worth checking the earth connections; the bolts holding the coil on are one of the earth points; one of my G40s died completely because this was corroded. I would think you would be unlucky if the problem was the loom itself unless someone has hacked about with it or there is an immobiliser fitted. If the fuel pump primes check for a spark when turning the engine over. If there is no spark possible problems are the hall sensor in the dizzy (this would also mean no fuel - fuel pump would only run during the priming), the coil (would still get fuel) or the coil drive transistor in the ECU (would still get fuel). Spark but no fuel suggests a problem with the fuel pump relay or fuel pump relay drive transistor in the ECU. You can check for fuel injectors running by looking to see if the plugs are wet after cranking it over for a bit. If you get a spark then the hall sensor in the dizzy is definately OK.

Here's a great guide for how to go about your fault finding.

  • 2 weeks later...
  • Author

Right update on this.

I got a new loom and ECU as mentioned above.

The main issue I was finding before was the starter couldn't draw enough power to turn the engine over quick enough to start, even with fresh batteries put on...then after a couple goes said fresh batteries would be stone dead flat, but I was getting fuel and spark...a weak spark but it's a start.

New loom and ECU fitted and the starter issue and killing batteries has gone....however fuel pump no longer primes and I have no sign of a spark.

Tried both ECUs and get the same results.

I'm thinking about removing the new loom, unwrap it all and check for continuity in all the wires.

Stuff like the coil and dizzy I have spares off and none of the ones I have improve the no spark issue whereas before I know they all worked.

Anything else I could have missed?

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.