Skip to content

Which Polo decision?

Featured Replies

Hi there fellow clubpolo'ers, Basically I'm in a bit of a pickle, basically have 4 car options:

1) 1.4 16v 6n

2) 1.4 16v 6n2 (75bhp)

3) 1.4 16v 6n2 (100bhp)

4) 1.6 16v gti 6n2

I would love to go for the gti straight. But there's me thinking out of the four it may not be a wise choice. As I'm looking for some power now but when I want to be sensible will still be decent on the juice.

Would be driving to and from Uni (around 40mile drive each way)

Before anyone says what about the 1.4 tdi, not really after a diesel.

Which would be a good choice?

Thanks

  • Replies 20
  • Views 1.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

if you can afford a gti get the gti. driving it normally as you would the others it shouldnt be much different on fuel

Get the fastest one you can afford, as if you were just after economy you'd get the diesel.

Driving style is the most important factor in getting cheap miles, so hoon it when you feel like it, and granny it everywhere else

  • Author
if you can afford a gti get the gti. driving it normally as you would the others it shouldnt be much different on fuel

My budget would be around £1000 for the car, I've seen a few gti's around that, and insurance seems ok. When you put it that that is true

Get the fastest one you can afford, as if you were just after economy you'd get the diesel.

Driving style is the most important factor in getting cheap miles, so hoon it when you feel like it, and granny it everywhere else

Haha definitely! gti is so tempting and your quite true in saying that. But none of these are not really a matter of money just power and economy. Which one would be a winner overall?

1k gti's will be 1k gti's for a good reason. I'd got the the 6n because the afh lump is better than the alloy block 6n2 engines. They like to rust tho but once the shell is dead you can reshell the lump into something more interesting

  • Author
1k gti's will be 1k gti's for a good reason. I'd got the the 6n because the afh lump is better than the alloy block 6n2 engines. They like to rust tho but once the shell is dead you can reshell the lump into something more interesting

Thanks for those wise words Mclovin. That's true in a sense the ones I've been looking at are either really high mileage or have something wrong with them. But my dad (mechanic) said hrs up for a challenge so maybe buying a gti that needs some work doing to it may be good. But tbh I'd rather it require no work to be done.

So 6n2's are kind of a no no then? I wouldn't mind a 6n at all, but my dad did say the 6n2 looks less of a banger haha and a bit more modern.

For that money you might stretch to a tidy 6n 16v. As per previous gti's for that cash would mainly be rubbish however there was a red five door on here recently for £1400 which was spot on. The 6n2 75bhp 16v are not quick and the 100bhp are sought after and quite rare and will be more than your budget. What about a mk2 golf gti.

  • Author
For that money you might stretch to a tidy 6n 16v. As per previous gti's for that cash would mainly be rubbish however there was a red five door on here recently for £1400 which was spot on. The 6n2 75bhp 16v are not quick and the 100bhp are sought after and quite rare and will be more than your budget. What about a mk2 golf gti.

Hmm that is true tbh, I mean I possibly could stretch to around £1200 for a decent gti.

Funnily enough I have been looking at the mk2 golf gti 8v, which for me is decent on insurance, I actually really like the old mk2 golfs, but whats putting me off is maybe the reliability compared to the polos. I dont want to be messing around too much fixing one up because I'm only still at uni so funds are low.

Thanks for the advice

The 6n2 does look more modern and the interior does look nicer place to be, they probably have a few more bells and whistles than the 6n too.

If your dads willing to roll his sleeves up and get dirty a lower priced GTI with the 'right' sort of issues might not be all that bad an idea. If you can get the price down on one because it has faults that you know you and your dad can easily sort you could end up with a good GTI for under market value. You will have to be very careful when buying tho because if a problem turns out to be worse than thought costs could spiral quite easily

Mk2 golfs can be very reliable, but a bad one can be a fucking pain in the arse :lol:

I've got the 6n2 75 bhp 16v for £1200. The engines smoother than my old 6n, looks more modern on the outside and inside plus has a cupholder! But I am having my old 6n back next year because i miss it

  • Author
The 6n2 does look more modern and the interior does look nicer place to be, they probably have a few more bells and whistles than the 6n too.

If your dads willing to roll his sleeves up and get dirty a lower priced GTI with the 'right' sort of issues might not be all that bad an idea. If you can get the price down on one because it has faults that you know you and your dad can easily sort you could end up with a good GTI for under market value. You will have to be very careful when buying tho because if a problem turns out to be worse than thought costs could spiral quite easily

What would you consider the "right sort" of issues? Like gearbox maybe? But I get get you mean and make a lot of sense!

Thanks for your wise words once again. :) :thumbsup:

Also should the higher mileage ones kind if be avoided? Unless they have been wells serviced?

  • Author
Mk2 golfs can be very reliable, but a bad one can be a fucking pain in the arse :lol:

Oh right ok, yeah that's the thing I wouldn't really want to be paying an arm and a leg for just a decent one.

Because its an old car I don't want that feeling at the back of my mind thinking oh what if it doesn't start on a cold day or Somin haha

  • Author
I've got the 6n2 75 bhp 16v for £1200. The engines smoother than my old 6n, looks more modern on the outside and inside plus has a cupholder! But I am having my old 6n back next year because i miss it

Really lol I could imagine that happening to me because I used to drive a 6n for a short period of time but had to sell up. I really liked the 6n, never even driven a 6n2 so not sure on what they are like to drive compared to the 6n.

Are the driving positions similar to a 6n, would you know?

los angeles is the model of blaupunkt stereo fitted, and the gooseneck looks like some sort of remote for it

The right sort of issues would be stuff that you and your old man could sort easily yourselves. With him being a mechanic then yeah stuff like gearbox issues would no doubt be an afternoons work for you two, but if it was going to a garage to be fixed could cost a fair old wack, so would be an ideal way of bartering the price down.

Whereas if you worked in a body shop then one with cosmetic damage would probably be more suited.

Personally I've never found mileage or service history important when buying a car, the way the car drives is far more important and should tell you all you need to know about how a car has been looked after. The timing belt setup on these engines isn't the best tho so that is something to bare in mind when viewing. If a belt or tensioner is warn its not really something that will show up on a test drive unlike stuff like warn bushes ect. If it hasn't got any proof of a cam belt service its better to assume it hasn't been done than to assume it has. Cam belt failure can be expensive to fix :-(

  • Author
los angeles is the model of blaupunkt stereo fitted, and the gooseneck looks like some sort of remote for it

The right sort of issues would be stuff that you and your old man could sort easily yourselves. With him being a mechanic then yeah stuff like gearbox issues would no doubt be an afternoons work for you two, but if it was going to a garage to be fixed could cost a fair old wack, so would be an ideal way of bartering the price down.

Whereas if you worked in a body shop then one with cosmetic damage would probably be more suited.

Personally I've never found mileage or service history important when buying a car, the way the car drives is far more important and should tell you all you need to know about how a car has been looked after. The timing belt setup on these engines isn't the best tho so that is something to bare in mind when viewing. If a belt or tensioner is warn its not really something that will show up on a test drive unlike stuff like warn bushes ect. If it hasn't got any proof of a cam belt service its better to assume it hasn't been done than to assume it has. Cam belt failure can be expensive to fix :-(

Mate if there was a rep button, it get pressed haha. Bit confused about that quote at the top though lol. That's quite true as we could carry out the work and save on possible labour costs. Oh right ok yeah tbh i think a polo with mechanical work would be a bit more sorted than cosmetic. But then again sorting out cosmetics would be a lot more convenient than mechanical.

Was talking to my dad and he said the exact same as you! Its all the way the car drives and sounds. So I'd defo be taking him on test drives so he can listen to the car and stuff. He also said a lot of people do forget about servicing gearboxes so that would help reduce the gearbox of going kaput!

Well thank you for your advice, appreciate you time typing that all up lol.

  • Author

Alright Guys basically I'm wondering what mpg would be like 6n2 gti compared to the 1.4 16v 75bhp model.

Looking at autotrader figures there seems to be a small difference of around 2-4mpg which seems silly, due to the excess power of the 1.4 16v 75bhp model.

With all that extra power is it really the same-ish mpg.

Real life figures must be different right.

For arguments sake lets say we are comparing motorway mpg between the two

Thanks!

Have the 16v 75bhp model myself and it doesn't seem to be too bad on the juice. Well i never drive it cause I'm not 17 but travelled three quarters the length of Ireland to get it and on the way home it only used about 30-35 euros worth so not bad at all but then again it was me mother driving it home so there was no rally driving happening :D

extra power means less effort on the accelerator! so it evens it out. my mk2 with a bike carbed 1.6 16v was better on fuel than with the standard engine haha

I've got the 16v 75hp model and it uses more fuel than my 1l 6n but they're quoted at the same mpgs. But it's probably because you just drive faster. And the gearbox isn't the right sort of issue to have if it goes it was £500 to replace in mine.

if you payed £500 to replace you gearbox your a mug :lol:

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.