Skip to content

MPG?

Featured Replies

what MPG does the mk2f 1043 cc get? and is there any fairly cheap ways to improve it? I've heard with it being carbed its not going to be very good, about 30mpg? is there any engines that are fairly economical that i could swap it with, that have a bit more power too? i was wondering what MPG an AFH gets? I'm just very tempted to change the engine for somthing that gives a nice amount of bhp, I'm not wanting 200bhp, just somthing that i can be confident in when overtaking. maybe 80-100 bhp?

  • Replies 21
  • Views 4.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Mk2f carbed? No they have SPI...

When I had my first Mk2f 1.0 it easily did 50+ MPG, it was really good on fuel.

I've recently got a Mk2F GT and it too is great on fuel and does nip on when asked, so that could be a conversion to think about?

If your 1.0 is only getting 30MPG just now though there must be something wrong with it...what kind of driving are you doing in it?

what MPG does the mk2f 1043 cc get? and is there any fairly cheap ways to improve it? I've heard with it being carbed its not going to be very good, about 30mpg? is there any engines that are fairly economical that i could swap it with, that have a bit more power too? i was wondering what MPG an AFH gets? I'm just very tempted to change the engine for somthing that gives a nice amount of bhp, I'm not wanting 200bhp, just somthing that i can be confident in when overtaking. maybe 80-100 bhp?

I averaged 41mpg in my old 1043 loon. Not bad but then not that great either.

A 3F (GT) lump would provide enough power they are 75bhp, which gives a nice healthy 100bhp/ton (or thereabouts) which in my opinion is perfect for comfortable overtaking etc. This would also be an easy swap as engine mounts etc would be in the correct place, only trouble is usually sourcing a decent wiring loom.

  • Author

I've not driven it any distance yet, thats just what I've been told and what I've found on the internet, but thanks for the quick reply. if my 1.0 is that economical, i may just tune it a little to get some more power. might do a 1.0 turbo, but do it properly instead of that 1.0 turbo breadvan with the cocksock.

and i was told it was carbed as i haven't had chance to look properly. but if its SPI then thats great :D

I'd say a GT is more like ~87hp/tonne unless you've got a mk2 or lacking a lot of mk3 interior

The 1 litre mk2f I had wasn't great on fuel at all but that was probably mostly due to it being so slow, having to almost nail it to get it out of junctions safely isn't really great for economy. On the other hand my mk2 1.6 AFH injection was very good on fuel in comparison (I could pull numbers out my arse but they would be so scientifically inaccurate they would be meaningless).

might do a 1.0 turbo, but do it properly instead of that 1.0 turbo breadvan with the cocksock.

:lol:

if you couldnt work out that your car isnt carbed i wouldnt advise trying to turbo it lol

In the late 80s it was no big secret that the 320i drank more fuel than the 325i. Tax laws along with BMW's aim for smoothness with the popular business use 2.0 engine meant this continued into the E36 initially but it couldn't continue. In motorsport the 320i was a 4-cylinder engine and the farce was embarassing BMW. It had to stop.

The big question from most, was why the 2.0 six-cylinder engine wasn't efficient? Well, because it was a short stroke, had a large surface area of moving parts for it's size. Simple physics.

The 1043cc engine in the MK2/MK2F has the same problem. The pistons don't even travel six centimetres. That means the engine has to rev to give any power. VW dumped the engine altogether in 1994 and replaced it with a totally different 999cc engine for the heavier third generation car in 1995 in the form of the 6n.

The extra leverage from the 1.3 gives that engine a more relaxed torquey nature, meaning a 1.3 can keep up with a 1.05 using far less energy. Generally then, the 1272cc engine is more economical than the 1043cc engine because the percentage in which the 1043 works in addition overrides the percentage of it's digestion reduction at stable revs.

Bit like the Prius using more fuel than an M3 in the busy rush hour. An engine being thrashed is not efficient. An engine being tickled is. So get the engine size right if you wanna use the least fuel - and that's gonna be a bigger engine than most people would expect!

Know what I meeeen?

OMG you don't even know mate, you weren't even there, you're not even ready.. Know what i mean..

Bit like the Prius using more fuel than an M3 in the busy rush hour. An engine being thrashed is not efficient. An engine being tickled is. So get the engine size right if you wanna use the least fuel - and that's gonna be a bigger engine than most people would expect!

I agree entirely with most of this - but a Prius is built for heavy traffic because it's running on electricity at low load with the engine turned off. It's flowing motorways where it falls down on fuel economy, because the electric motor is doing next to nothing and the petrol engine is working to haul its batteries around. Hybrids suit urban stuff.

However, I'm finding the latter is frequently true. Downsized engines work brilliantly in the NEDC test, but real-world usage isn't quite that simple. Best example I can present here is the Mercedes ML 250 BlueTEC. It's an ML with a four-cylinder diesel engine, supposed to do about 45mpg on the combined cycle. That's a really efficient engine in a C-Class, but in the ML I was struggling to get more than about 32-33mpg if I really tried. And believe me, I really tried.

I haven't had the ML 350 BlueTEC (the six-cylinder) for a week as yet, but my guess would be that it'd return fairly similar figures (if not better) under the same conditions because the engine isn't working flat out to haul two tonnes of luxury SUV around. Put simply, it's the right engine for that size of car.

That's not saying small engines don't work. I have a Honda Civic as a long-termer at the moment with the new 120bhp 1.6 diesel engine, claimed to do a dizzying 78mpg. If I'm honest, it's so efficient that it's hard to motivate myself to push the economy - it gets about 60mpg without any effort. Last week I set a speed limiter at 70mph (it creeps up beyond that if you don't keep an eye on it) and drove it gently from St Albans to Cardiff (about 150 miles) and averaged a claimed 75.5mpg. Annoyingly I didn't have the foresight to do this from a brimmed tank but at worst case scenario, even if that's 10% out, that's still 68mpg with the climate control on full blast and a sensible cruising speed. Again, though, that's exactly the right size engine for a car like that.

The thing is, high economy and low CO2 emissions are great for selling cars, and great for reducing tax liability. But it's quite hard to reflect that to people buying cars. In my experience, though, the better the engine is matched up to the size of car the better the economy you'll get out of it. Including the new Porsche 911 - take one busy motorway jaunt to St Albans and the PDK-equipped Carrera averaged over 37mpg without any effort to drive it economically. Just cruising.

Right engine, right car. Not the be all and end all as a shit engine is shit whatever it's in, but it's a good starting point. Gearing helps, too, I'd have saved a fortune in petrol if my old Passat had been equipped with six gears. But I could wring 40mpg out of that if I could be bothered.

The public need educating on how to choose the best powertrain to suit their needs, rather than relying on increasingly irrelevant NEDC efficiency data. I bettered the NEDC combined figures frequently on my Saab 9-5 Aero, and on the 350Z - but my commute is mostly motorway/dual carriageway and they were both relatively powerful engines for the cars. The wife's Mazda3 does the opposite, but then that's only 105bhp in 1300kg of car and does one billionty rpm at 65mph.

Downsized powertrains make sense if they're not getting thrashed up and down the motorway, and are doing the school run etc. where you can leverage their relatively decent efficiency at low loads. Otherwise, go bigger!

This is why a 1.6 in a shit old light polo running bike carbs can do 1824184914801mpg

Yeah, this is it. But while there are cars to be sold I can't see it happening.

Another case in point for you. The Peugeot 508. In the two years since that car launched I've driven most of the diesel engines available in that car, and it's been quite interesting seeing how they stack up.

We had a 140bhp 2.0 diesel as a long-termer, which would do 51mpg if you drove it like you were late for your child's birth, or 55mpg if you were going sensibly. Good car.

I had a 1.6 for a week. On paper that's more economical, but it only has five gears. It averaged 51mpg on my old commute to work, which is lower than the 2.0 diesel.

Then I tried the Hybrid4. This has a 2.0 diesel engine up front, and an electric rear axle. Claimed 78mpg, but again I got about 53mpg on the motorway. Above 40mph the electric motor and battery is dead weight.

Of course, if you were a predominantly city-based driver, you'd get better economy from the Hybrid compared to the other diesels because you'd be able to cover short distances using the electric motor. But that's left up to people's common sense.

Horses for courses.

And don't get me started on plug-in hybrids. Not picking on Toyota specifically (it's just they have a good example) but you can get the Prius at 72.4mpg, and the Plug-in Prius at 134.5mpg. Those really aren't comparable figures, and yes you could argue it's common sense that the latter is a bit arbitrary (you could exceed it if you only went a few miles per day and kept it charged all the time) but i wonder how many consumers really know the difference.

I can get 50mpg out of my NZ'd mk2f if I really try, if I'm being sensible I can get 40mpg.. hooning I get around 25 to 30mpg, which isn't bad considering I'm not meant to get better than like 38mpg... baring in mind this on the isle of wight as well, loads of stop start!

I can get 50mpg out of my NZ'd mk2f if I really try, if I'm being sensible I can get 40mpg.. hooning I get around 25 to 30mpg, which isn't bad considering I'm not meant to get better than like 38mpg... baring in mind this on the isle of wight as well, loads of stop start!

Taking in to account the inaccurate fuel gauge and the fact the odometer is operated by a vastly inaccurate seedo, in reality you probably are only getting about 38mpg :lol:

I'm on 13's with 135/20/13 tyres, says I got 19492 miles to a tank! Really I just went round the block

the Plug-in Prius at 134.5mpg. Those really aren't comparable figures

If only you knew how much debate there was amongst SMMT members just to accept (I won't say 'agree', because no-one does!) the method of publishing mpg figures for plug-in hybrids and range-extended EVs. The VCA has pushed for a Point-of-Sale (ironically referred to as a POS...) label like the one below - just like you'd find on a new fridge. This contains a large amount of often meaningless data, in theory to allow consumers to compare between cars - but in reality its bastard confusing.

efficiency-label.jpg

They quote an electrical efficiency rating where appropriate, and the Prius comes out an order of magnitude better on electrical efficiency than a Nissan Leaf - predominantly because the Prius burns some petrol on the cycle, thus saving electricity. (Pruis is 11.9 miles/kWh, Leaf is 3.6 miles/kWh.) In an attempt to reduce confusion the labelling quotes indicative fuel and energy (i.e. electricity) prices - and a 'Total Energy Cost' for 12,000 miles. Of course, given that all this data is incredibly drive-cycle and driving style dependant for electrified powertrains, it is all virtually meaningless.

Have a look at the data yourself - Vauxhall Ampera and Prius Plug-in is another interesting comparison:

http://carfueldata.direct.gov.uk/search-ne...-used-cars.aspx

Going back to the original topic, I've always found the 1.3 Mk2/f 's to be better on fuel that the 1 litres. The best one I ever had for fuel was a very well serviced GT which did 50mpg on an A-road commute, after that was a 1.3 MH with a 4+E box which did 44-46mpg, mostly motorways.

I've got an inkling. Funnily enough I posted a discussion about this on our forum, and had a call from someone in the industry about this topic this week. Big issue being that the electric range is literally that - it's a distance it can travel on a fully charged battery. A bit like saying a Bentley Mulsanne will travel further on one tank than a Toyota iQ.

I worked out that on the same route from Cardiff to St Albans, both using a fully charged battery and brimmed fuel tank, both the Prius Plug-in and Volt I had last year averaged just under 63mpg. The difference is, the Prius averaged 58mpg once its battery ran flat, and the Volt averaged 44mpg. Obviously the Volt offers a longer electric range, interesting to see it's actually half as efficient in electric mode too if I understand those figures. But based on NEDC figures it's 235.4 vs 135.4mpg in the Volt's favour.

However... wasn't aware of that website. I'm going to mail it to myself. The company which runs the back-office system for our websites has this, which is potentially quite useful:

http://noexhaust.co.uk/electric/comparison/?clk=32

Quite interesting to twiddle the menus around on that and see what it might cost to run.

I might be getting an Ampera as a six-month long termer from September, by the way.

Proves how confusing all that additional data makes things for the consumer. Quite clearly if you're doing two 20-30 mile commutes each day and have the ability to charge at work, then the Volt/Ampera wins over the Prius plug-in as you'll do most of your trips in EV mode. However, if most of your trips are longer motorway stuff and/or just trips to the shops, the Prius has the edge. Probably.

Volt isn't necessarily less electrically efficient than the Prius, it just uses less engine during the NEDC test so uses more electrical energy. This is why it has a crazily good mpg figure, but also why the Prius uses less electricity!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.