Skip to content

What Polo should I go for?

Featured Replies

Hi guys,
I'm new here so forgive me if I have posted in the wrong section.
I was hoping for some advice, I want to purchase a VW Polo and I have a budget of around £5500 - £7000.
I have seen a lot of different models & engine sizes. The 1.2 70, 1.4 85 and the 1.2 Bluemotion interest me.

Would it be better to go for the diesel engines? (They cost about 1-2k more)
I have no idea what the best engine is and what models to look out for, I'm not too fussy with extras but as long as it has alloy wheels and an aux/usb or iPhone 5 connector, it would be ideal. No less then 2010 too.

Quite a long question but I really want to make sure I make the right decision before spending that amount of money. (I am also planning to make this my first car, so nothing too insurance heavy either)
Thanks icon_smile.gif

  • Replies 9
  • Views 659
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

hi daniiCEO

if this is going to be you first car and you don't really want heavy insurance then I wouldn't get anything over a 1.4.

with the case of getting a diesel to a petrol engine it all depends on how you drive and where you drive.

diesel are all about long distance driving due to there particulate filter with help to reduce emissions. if your just driving about in towns and sitting

in traffic the particulate filter builds up with soot and blocks the exhaust completely and then more costs to replace.

hope this helps. :D

The MPG on the bluemotion is out of this world but you need to do big miles to really make it worth your while.

To my mind, there is only one answer to "Which Polo?" and that is and always will be "G40" but I suspect insurance may be an issue.

Best bet is to go out and drive the different engine options, preferably back-to-back and make a choice after that.

Out of those options I'd say the 1.4 petrol engine would be the best 'all rounder'.

The 1.2 3 cylinder engines aren't great IMO and the early ones were prone to premature failure.

The bluemotion diesel are, as said, good on fuel but they do demand higher prices. Plus then the higher fuel price etc you'd have to be doing mega miles each year i.e. 40-50k plus in order to offset the difference in cost.

The 1.4 will be cheaper to buy, cheaper fuel price and should last longer than the 1.2 provided it is serviced regularly.

As for insurance, if this is your first car then the prices between them won't vary much, they will all be shockingly expensive.

  • Author

Hi, Thanks for the replies guys ! Really helpful.

The two frontrunners for me were the 1.4 petrol and the 1.2 bluemotion and I just wanted someone to justify the larger price tag.

Thankfully I only work 10 miles away so in the year I will be covering between 10 - 15k miles, Way off the 40-50k that I would need to actually save money.

I live in the outskirts of London and regularly travel in London where the traffic is pretty bad. A diesel wouldn't be good for that however when I commute to work its always on the motorway, and I like the idea of free road tax, more mpg etc.

So my final question will be, from what you know about the 2 engines, what would be the more fun to drive and better value for money (in terms of spec, extra features and running costs)?

Thanks in advance and apologies if these questions seem a bit much, I am trying to get as much info as I can before purchasing. :)

In terms of driving pleasure and options available you're best just going to a few dealers and getting test drives.

As for value for money, I personally think the 1.4 petrol would be the one to go for. Cheaper to purchase, cheaper fuel and probably more economical in traffic than the bluemotion would be.

Not really sure the petrol would be anymore economical in traffic?

Even over a ten mile commute, you will notice the fuel savings. It would also handle the short distance better.

Yes they are more money to buy, but, over the fuel savings, the cheaper tax ( if you intend to keep the car) and the higher value the blue motion will have over the petrol when you come to sell, I can't see much money in it really.

Buy the red MK2 coupe on eBay for 300 quid and spend six grand making it the best Polo on the planet.

You know it makes sense.

Not really sure the petrol would be anymore economical in traffic?

Even over a ten mile commute, you will notice the fuel savings. It would also handle the short distance better.

Yes they are more money to buy, but, over the fuel savings, the cheaper tax ( if you intend to keep the car) and the higher value the blue motion will have over the petrol when you come to sell, I can't see much money in it really.

The few diseasals I've had have been shit on short journeys. Even my Dad's F10 BMW 5 series diesel is uneconomical on short trips. But on long journeys can see 50+ MPG.

It would be a good consumer experiment to buy two identical cars, 1 petrol 1 diesel, treat them the same over say 2 years etc. then sell them on. See which one was cheaper overall.

Diesel all the way. Much better to drive than petrol, cheaper fuel, tax and hold value better. Plus diesels tend to last longer.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.