Skip to content

* Consider running your Slowlo on Momentum 99 *

Featured Replies

Hi all, would just like to share my findings when running different grades of fuel in my car, a 2002 Polo 9N 1.2E 55 (6 valve AWY) with 125K on the clock (11K in my ownership).

My typical tank of fuel is burned in a mixture of town work with mild to moderate traffic, and some rural & dual carriageway in a 3:1 (town:other) ratio.

My driving style is mostly sensible (sticking to limits, changing before 3 - 3.5K RPM and no more than 3/4 throttle - bearing in mind it is a 54HP car) but occasionally spirited (i.e I do sometimes floor it, and I do sometimes rev to between 4.5 & 5K. I do sometime cruise at over 70 on a dual carriageway, but not too often)

From 3 tanks of 95 RON Tesco petrol I averaged:

34 MPG

36 MPG

35 MPG

From 6 tanks of 95 RON Esso petrol I averaged:

36MPG

37MPG

35MPG

36MPG

36MPG

37MPG

From 6 tanks of 99 RON Momentum 99 I averaged:

40MPG

39MPG

38MPG

40MPG

39MPG

37MPG

I do not have a fuel computer, these are brim to brim readings with the aid of the trip, the reciept, and a calculator.

I didn't count any tanks which broke away from my general driving routine (i.e those which contained a motorway run or an abnormally long dual carriageway run)

From this it looks like it would be worth trying Momentum 99, at least with the AWY engine (obviously I have not tried others) as I seem to get an extra 2 - 3MPG over Esso 95 and an extra 3 - 5MPG over regular Tesco 95.

Using Momentum for me, works out as approximately £1 - £1.50 cheaper per 100 miles compared with 95 RON petrol, it has the added benefit of knowing that you are being kind to the injectors and so on by feeding through a higher quality fuel.

I believe that the engine is very slightly more plucky, and the issue I had with acceleration flat spots seems to have been lessened slightly, though this may be due to the placebo effect, so don't take my word as gospel!

I intend on trying a few more tanks of regular 95 to further ensure that changes in driving style are not a factor, and I intend on trying a few tanks of VPOWER at some point, though I haven't so far due to Shell garages being inconveniently located for me.

I have not tried 97 RON Super or 98 RON BP Ultimate, as they are priced similarly to, or sometimes higher than Momentum 99.

Thanks :)

Edited by acme15

  • Replies 13
  • Views 2.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Normal supermarket petrol is so rubbish these days. I haven't done anything like your research above but with my own cars I have noticed that supermarket (regular 95RON) makes any car with a bit of power run like shit and returns no economy.

With my G40 I religiously run it on either Tesco Momentum 99 or Shell V-Power.

Earlier in the year down my garage I was being slightly childish with normal Asda petrol and put some on the ground and tried to light it. Bearing in mind this was fresh out the pumps from Asda it struggled to light. To burn it all up I had to hold the lighter on the puddle of fuel. So really if the fuel is struggling to catch with a naked flame to it no wonder some cars run like shit with normal supermarket fuel.

On a similar note I also filled a clear tub full of diesel from Asda, it was fucking green!! Pretty sure Diesel used to be clear like petrol so I dunno what they are putting in it these days to turn it green.

Always use momentum 99 from Tesco in my g40. It's a good price aswell for a more premium fuel. Nice to see somebody doing so proper real tests. Well done

I only use Tesco normal and I'm getting a regular average 48~52 mpg according to the trip computer from my 1.4 8v AUD on a steady 60mph trip

Working of you are lowest mpg figures from all 3 test 34 35 37 2mpg difference from normal pump gas to higher octane gas isn't a significant increase to which u would notice on a daily basis and the fact there so many variables in testing this on the road for instance road surfaces either dry or wet, wet give less friction meaning less fuel being used how close was each test to a service and so many other things tyre

Pressures weight in the car. However fair play for actually testing it.

I run my GT on shell v power always.

If I fill up with £20 of supermarket fuel, or £20 of v power, despite getting less volume with v power, I get more miles.

  • 2 weeks later...
  • Author

Went on a midnight motorway run of about 50 or 60 miles within the last (344 mile total) tank (there was a purpose to the trip, don't worry), sat between 90 and 110 for most of it (my car has a magical AWY block which defies the printed specs), at around 5K RPM (I was on the Autobahn.....................) and still averaged 39MPG from the tank. :tongue:

Edited by acme15

Good test and a post written in a fair, down to earth way - well done.

I did similar things between normal shell & V power with my 6n a few years ago and the extra cost of the V power paid for itself with economy gains

YMMV...using spritmonitor

100 octane unleaded (There's no 99 octane in Germany.)

= average 7.26 l/100km = 38.9mpg for 358 drivers

versus

98 octane unleaded

= average 7.17 l/100km = 39.4mpg for 684 drivers

versus

95 octane unleaded

= average 6.95 l/100km = 40.7mpg for 505 drivers

versus

E10 10% ethanol (perhaps close to Momentum?)

= average 6.77 l/100km = 41.7mpg for 857 drivers

This is any petrol Polo any age and obviously a self-selecting sample of drivers who care to record their consumption.

E10 is recent so perhaps used by more modern more economical cars like 69bph 6R.. I think people who buy 100 octane do so to go faster on the Autobahn.

  • 2 weeks later...
  • Author

If that is any petrol Polo of any age then it is probably, sadly, fairly useless information. I expect that many of the 98 / 100 octane users are driving GTI's or similar, whereas the 95 users are probably mostly 1.2's, 1.4's and so on. Hence the higher average overall for 95.

e; Just checked.

92 GTI's in the 100 catagory

170 GTI's in the 98 catagory

40 GTI's in the 95 catagory

Edited by acme15

I always find my 1.4 6N runs a lot better on Shell fuel than any others. I was putting in Shell V-Power for a short time but got told if I do it all the time the High Octane of the fuel could "perish" (Burn?) my fuel tank?

  • Author

I'm not convinced that higher octane fuel would have any effect on your fuel tank. It isn't as if you are filling up with a 100+ RON ethanol mix.

I am back on 95 RON Tesco fuel for a few tanks now, to see what the figures look like for crappy fuel the second time round.

Another observation though, in the 1.2 Polo AWY, a 200 mile motorway run at 70 - 80MPH returned 41MPG, and a 200 mile motorway journey at 55 - 65MPH returned 51MPG. Slow down fellas! :wink:

Thats a good point you raise there, with small amount of power these engines have, you have to "keep your foot in" to keep at higher speeds on motorways, so while you may think your cruising at 70-80 you actually have the throttle open quite a way to keep it there, I can back up acme15's post by saying that over a 100 mile motorway journey at 70ish I used a lot more fuel than just trundling along at 60ish.

I find the sweet spot for me is around 62 (100KPH coincidentally) with my box thats 2500-2600 RPM and the throttle is a lot less open, resulting in a good saving :)

I would also like to add that I recently switched from Morrisons fuel to Texaco 95 and the car is just so much happier on that fuel, a lot smoother and quieter :)

Edited by R10tz0r

  • 3 weeks later...
  • Author

My testing has been cut short due to a disagreement with a tree... Just a technicality... I will resume once the car is back on the road, and if it never ends up back on the road, I will start over with my replacement Polo... :tongue:

Edited by acme15

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.