Skip to content

Is the breadvan an estate?

Featured Replies

A pub debate occurred the other day, and I need clarification.

We were discussing the mk2f/mk3. The coupe is a hatchback and the saloon is obviously a saloon, but when I showed a friend a picture of the breadvan and claimed it was an estate, he disagreed, claiming that estates need 4 doors while the mk2f bready only has 2.

I did some research using the ever-reliable Wikipedia, which says estates can have either 2 or 4/5 doors, but by this time the entirety of the pub was united against me and adamant that a car needs at least 4 doors to be classed as an estate.

When I asked what they would therefore call the breadvan, the general response was "a piece of shit" -.-

So I ask the Polo owners community - is the mk2f breadvan an estate? If not, then what is it?

  • Replies 30
  • Views 2.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Avant works. Avant enough money for an Audi estate , so I've got a Polo. :)

  • With only two doors surely it is a shooting brake like a Volvo P1800, Ferrari FF or a BMW Z3M, though Mercedes have now bucked the trend. If it was sold in Us of A it would be a sub-station wagon.

  • Dog hearse.

Posted Images

Hatchback. Listed by insurance companies, car sales, hpi checks, dvla

But on the topic of 2 door estates. Land rover disco 1/2, various escort estates, mini clubman and so on

And to add to that the polo COUPE yes it maybe classed as a hatch but it's in the name...

Edited by xumado

  • Author

But if the bready is a hatchback, then

then what's the estate in the series?

post-918081-0-31751600-1434302089_thumb.

Edited by Vio

That's Wikipedia though fella, it maybe what it is but my v5 says it's a hatch

I'd you Google mk2 polo hatch you get breadvans as the first thing

  • Author

I'd you Google mk2 polo hatch you get breadvans as the first thing

But you get the same thing if you google mk2 polo estate :tongue: I think the main difference between estate and coupe is the D pillar, but that being said the 71 Chevy Vega, Ford Del Rio and Mercury Communiter don't have a D pillar and are still classed as estates. The bready's the right shape and everything, it even fits the dictionary version of estate (but then so does the coupe).

Ah well. Whatever it is, it works :tongue:

When the mk2 was taken out the 'breadvan' was classed as a hatchback. But that meant they needed to come up with something else to suggest a difference between that and the 'sportier' looking version. So that's why they came up with the 'coupe' title. So I've heard anyway. Lets face it the 'coupe' isn't really a coupe at all.

  • Author

So I guess the saloon is the only sensibly-named body style out of the lot :tongue:

With only two doors surely it is a shooting brake like a Volvo P1800, Ferrari FF or a BMW Z3M, though Mercedes have now bucked the trend.

If it was sold in Us of A it would be a sub-station wagon.

Dog hearse.

I was about to post that its obviously a shooting brake - but dvderlm was there first.

If this is a hatchback:

15Zoll_TH-Line_VW+Polo+6N_Felgen.jpg

Then so is this:

1983-volkswagen-polo-mk2-27.jpg

As far as I'm concerned, the 6N adopted the "breadvan" shape and ditched the coupe and saloon versions, aside from the Toledo/Ibiza based versions.

I do, however, think the "coupe" thing is a bit of a misnomer considering the Polo Coupe has a near identical silhouette to all the hatchbacks of the time.

A true Mk2 Polo Estate would be a cross between a Saloon and a Breadvan. Longer behind the rear axle than a hatch.

There was a silver saloon that someone had put a breadvan rear end on to make an estate. It was a German car. Does anyone have any pics?

"As far as I'm concerned, the 6N adopted the "breadvan" shape and ditched the coupe and saloon versions"

this is what i think, in modern terms you don't get a coupe shape anymmore. they all have almost virticalrear windows

The brochure's all list the coupe as a coupe (the only VAG things with a similar shape at the time were the Rocco and Audi Coupe), and the breadvan as a hatchback.

I'll go with Shooting Brake though, I've been shooting in one, I've only taken a Coupe to archery, so yeah, it makes sense.

I'm suddenly imagining how cool a breadvan would look with a split tailgate.

Like this, but with a pug or a Yorkshire Terrier to keep the scale right:

L405_13_NCAR05_HUB_fh_2_281-83435_680x45

Wouldn't be too hard to engineer, surely?

The saloon is more of a traditional Coupe shape I'd say, with 2 doors. Like that 3 series coupe (I don't know which one).

I'd call it a squareback, but ze germans call it a steilheck - which means hatchback.

I'd say it can't be an estate without having four doors.

Depends who you ask:

Untitled-31.jpg

Technically though I can't understand how this is an estate, given that it's no longer than the hatchback. It's a squareback Escort.

I'd call it a squareback, but ze germans call it a steilheck - which means hatchback.

I'd say it can't be an estate without having four doors.

Steil means steep.

Didn't Bmw call their 2 door estates Tourers?

It's an Avante.

That's Audi that call them "Avant".

BMW call their estates "Touring", probably because the bootspace is shit for an estate car :lol:

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.