Skip to content

Mk2 Breadvan as First Car?

Featured Replies

Essentially I've been looking at these little beauties (Mk2 Polo Breadvan) for a while now and wanted to know if they would be a suitable first car? Also in terms of insurance where would I be looking, considering I'll be a new driver 18/19 years old. I'd like to get an older model so would I be able to qualify for classic insurance? Just read that somewhere.

Thanks!!

  • Replies 14
  • Views 4.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • prankstar2003
    prankstar2003

    I only drove Mk2s for about 8 years until it was written off. I then moved to a 9n (53 plate) and the experience was totally different. Brakes were a little harsh on the 9n, it was quiet, larger, easi

think with classic insurance you have to be over an certain age too

I'd say they're good as a first car.

Are you or do you know anyone who's a keen mechanic? Take them along and check out all the usual stuff and just make sure it's solid. You don't want a rust bucket.

I have a breadvan(mk2f) as my first car and it is so much more fun to drive than the newer cars that i learnt to drive in.

if i remember correctly you have to be over 21 to qualify for classic insurance

I am 18 and this is my first year of insurance and cost 1600 with a black box

personally i would say the mk2f is a better first car due to it having brake assistance and extra crash protection but just down to want you want

  • Author

think with classic insurance you have to be over an certain age too

Ye that confusion has now been sorted, although I did see on one insurance company that they offered it to young enthusiasts of classic cars but I don't know.

I'd say they're good as a first car.

Are you or do you know anyone who's a keen mechanic? Take them along and check out all the usual stuff and just make sure it's solid. You don't want a rust bucket.

Ye I have a friend who knows a lot, and I'm not too bad myself, I usually consult him on stuff anyway!

I have a breadvan(mk2f) as my first car and it is so much more fun to drive than the newer cars that i learnt to drive in.

if i remember correctly you have to be over 21 to qualify for classic insurance

I am 18 and this is my first year of insurance and cost 1600 with a black box

personally i would say the mk2f is a better first car due to it having brake assistance and extra crash protection but just down to want you want

I've heard if they're lowered then they also handle much nicer and are more fun to drive, have you done this?

So what engine size do you have then?

Yeah I think I'll go with the mk2 breadvan because I love the shape and style :)

Depends. I'm not going to lie to you, don't expect to drive it like a modern car because it will feel like a bag of shit, and sooner or later, it will bite you.

The brakes are worse

The brakes are harder to press

The brakes are easy to press too hard

The clutch is heavy

The steering is heavy if you try to dry steer

The interior is basic

There's no ABS

There's no traction control

There's no airbags

They don't handle

They don't handle a lot better unless you spend decent money on suspension

The headlights are shit

.... but then plenty of grannies drove them in the 80's-00's, so they can't be that hard to get on with

If you go into a corner too quick and put a modern car into a ditch nose first at 20mph, you're probably going to walk to the ambulance. Do it a Mk2, you'll more likely to wake up in hospital.

Basically, they don't do anything to help you. But, if you can adjust your driving style to that, up your game and run hazard perception out right down the road in front of you, you'll be driving at another level to most people on the road.

I have had a Mk2 for thirteen years and not regreted keeping it ever. It has never totally broken down. But it has taken work to keep it on the road. It is very simple compared to modern cars. A carburated car has little electronics. Mine only has an amplifier for the hall sensor on the ignition. Lots of parts are still available. The forum is good with a lot of people who know what they are talking about. I drive a very complex hybrid car that drives itself almost but I very much enjoy getting into my breadvan because it's going back to basics and there are no electronics taking over the driving.

Regards

Phil

think its all been said

for a older different car they're cool and can be reliable when maintained well

they're worlds apart from modern cars so you really do need to want to have the polo , and dont expect to buy one for a few hundred and put 1000s of miles on it with no work , chances are it will need a good going over upon buying it then regualr maintence and rust repair to keep it nice

first thing you want to do before worrying about a lowering kit is to replace all the worn out parts on the car then fit some good quality tyres , i see so many "moded" cars where the owner can afford all this bolt on tat but they ride around on mis matched cheapo tyres , good tyres can really make a difference and are worth buying

  • Author

think its all been said

for a older different car they're cool and can be reliable when maintained well

they're worlds apart from modern cars so you really do need to want to have the polo , and dont expect to buy one for a few hundred and put 1000s of miles on it with no work , chances are it will need a good going over upon buying it then regualr maintence and rust repair to keep it nice

first thing you want to do before worrying about a lowering kit is to replace all the worn out parts on the car then fit some good quality tyres , i see so many "moded" cars where the owner can afford all this bolt on tat but they ride around on mis matched cheapo tyres , good tyres can really make a difference and are worth buying

I am prepared to maintain the car regularly because I want to use it as a way to get even more in the know of car maintenance, so that wont be an issue, the only thing hindering that will be the cost of doing so. Aside from buying the car, roughly how much would I be looking at in replacements and general maintenance of the vehicle?

Depends. I'm not going to lie to you, don't expect to drive it like a modern car because it will feel like a bag of shit, and sooner or later, it will bite you.

The brakes are worse

The brakes are harder to press

The brakes are easy to press too hard

The clutch is heavy

The steering is heavy if you try to dry steer

The interior is basic

There's no ABS

There's no traction control

There's no airbags

They don't handle

They don't handle a lot better unless you spend decent money on suspension

The headlights are shit

.... but then plenty of grannies drove them in the 80's-00's, so they can't be that hard to get on with

If you go into a corner too quick and put a modern car into a ditch nose first at 20mph, you're probably going to walk to the ambulance. Do it a Mk2, you'll more likely to wake up in hospital.

Basically, they don't do anything to help you. But, if you can adjust your driving style to that, up your game and run hazard perception out right down the road in front of you, you'll be driving at another level to most people on the road.

Seems like the brakes and driving the car can be the most problematic. How easy is it to adjust to the different driving style?

I have had a Mk2 for thirteen years and not regreted keeping it ever. It has never totally broken down. But it has taken work to keep it on the road. It is very simple compared to modern cars. A carburated car has little electronics. Mine only has an amplifier for the hall sensor on the ignition. Lots of parts are still available. The forum is good with a lot of people who know what they are talking about. I drive a very complex hybrid car that drives itself almost but I very much enjoy getting into my breadvan because it's going back to basics and there are no electronics taking over the driving.

Regards

Phil

Cheers Phil, how often did you need to work on the car to keep it on the road?

parts are still pretty much affordable , what i do is plan ahead and search ebay/classifieds and snap up any bargains that will come in handy , but yeah a couple of hundred quid would get all the parts to refresh most of the brakes , suspension and a engine service

biggest expense you might have is if the car needs welding , mine did so i got a welder and learned how to do it myself , paying a garage would cost alot

best bet is to search for a rust free car , then look after it so you wont need welding for a good while , take someone with you if need be , someone that knows the difference between rust free original and tarted with a spray can

  • Author

parts are still pretty much affordable , what i do is plan ahead and search ebay/classifieds and snap up any bargains that will come in handy , but yeah a couple of hundred quid would get all the parts to refresh most of the brakes , suspension and a engine service

biggest expense you might have is if the car needs welding , mine did so i got a welder and learned how to do it myself , paying a garage would cost alot

best bet is to search for a rust free car , then look after it so you wont need welding for a good while , take someone with you if need be , someone that knows the difference between rust free original and tarted with a spray can

Ye that sounds fair enough, couple of hundred is fine, just glad it's not crazy expensive! So brakes, suspension and servicing the engine would be the priority when first getting it?

Luckily I know someone who could do the welding for me for free or a low cost so that's all good, was looking at learning myself so you never know!

Annoyingly a lot that I'm seeing have rust but I know how to remove it, just got to maintain it then, was planning on taking someone to view as well for that purpose. Thanks for the advice :)

19 with a 2f and insurance around £800 for a 1.3!

Only little bits of maintenance here and there, but so far so good!

  • Author

19 with a 2f and insurance around £800 for a 1.3!

Only little bits of maintenance here and there, but so far so good!

That's really good! So much cheaper than most modern stuff!!

I've been considering the mk2f purely for the superiority over parts of the mk2

A basic mk2f 1.0 or 1.3 doesn't really have much superior parts compared to the mk2, certainly the later ones (1986 onwards) anyway. They are all fuel injection which I think is a bit more reliable but there are many people who still run the original carbs and they carry on fine.

I only drove Mk2s for about 8 years until it was written off. I then moved to a 9n (53 plate) and the experience was totally different. Brakes were a little harsh on the 9n, it was quiet, larger, easier to steer and generally, for day to day, much more pleasurable as I wasn't always waiting for it to break down all the time. After about 4 years I bought another mk2 (for this summer to have a bit of fun in) and tbh, I was tense the whole time.I noticed every rattle, hesitation, squeak, bang etc. I sold it at the end of th summer as it had served its purpose and although I missed it for the aestetics, I found i wasn't driving it much because of these concerns I had. And this one had a tasty engine, uprated brakes and suspension so wasn't even like the shabby standard affair. Now I love old polos (i still have one being renovated) but I'd never go back to one as a daily. So as above, be aware that the car you learn in will be totally different to an old polo. Personally, learning and cutting my driving-teeth in an old car was great. Taught me about driving safely and not pushing beyond the limits of the car or my own ability. They are unforgivable if pushed too hard, and not in a spectacular F1, on the limit way but rather a slower yet unstoppable slide towards a ditch/hedge/other car. And if you have a collision, it's more than likely to be written off. So my advice is go for it, but be prepared for the problems classic cars throw up and respect it with your driving style.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.