Skip to content

The Good old debate 3 or 5 door

Featured Replies

Post pics of both 3 and 5 door polo's mk4

As finding a 3 door is proving difficult well a decent one anyway

I don't mind 5 doors had a few before ;)

Edited by Adam...

  • Replies 46
  • Views 2.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I'm going to be biased and say 5 door :p

DSC04666.jpg

One of my fave 5 doors! ^^^

/\/\/\ And look he paid money to remove his rear handles because he was so ashamed.

3 Door FTW!!

Edited by kerrly

/\/\/\ And look he paid money to remove his rear handles because he was so ashamed.

3 Door FTW!!

:lol:

No..he didn't need them anymore..But that doesnt justify getting a five door..haha oops

Edited by Dub James

HAHA Kerrly i agree 3DR FTW also

Theres seems to be a lot of love for 5 doors lately....

  • Author
I'm going to be biased and say 5 door :p

DSC04666.jpg

One of my fave 5 doors! ^^^

Was parked near that at Oxford Edition show was very nice

I wouldn't remove the handles tho

Saying that, someone mistook mine for a 3 door the other day - asked for the seat to be put forward so they could get in the back :lol:

You see so many 5 door cars where they have spent tons on their cars modding them and they get to that stage when they wish they stared with a 3 door in the first place. That when they remove the rear door handles, but it will never be the same :cry::cry::cry::cry:

I know its a mk5, but 5 door can look ace:

post-8807-1191787508.jpg

post-8807-1191787903.jpg

You know how I feel about my 5dr...

DSCF0173.jpg

... will look much better when I finally get round to colour coding the handles!

I think the 3dr does look better with the Mk4 Polo being a small car but it still looks good with 5, there are pleanty of other 5dr hatch backs out there that look complete pants with 5 doors, corsa B for example!

I was going to say its different to have a 5dr but there seems to have been an influx of them recently lol

Edited by marpol

Marpol's ^^ one of the best examples on here :thumbsup:

more doors = more whores

i would buy an old skool 3dr mk1 jetta but not a 5 door, but you can do the 5 dr mk4s well as seen above

do like the look of that blue one up top.

Dubbings is a great example of a 5dr Mk4...

clicky

Edited by marpol

I think more modern looking cars suit being a 2 door. Like a 6N does, but I think older cars like mk1 Golfs can pull of the 5 door thing. Specially if they are retro colours like beige with a brown interior :lol:

5 door all the way an is very true more doors more whores. and the 3 doors are too small so there isnt a problem with smoothing the rear door handles as it looks like a 3 door but put right :)

You see so many 5 door cars where they have spent tons on their cars modding them and they get to that stage when they wish they stared with a 3 door in the first place. That when they remove the rear door handles, but it will never be the same :cry::cry::cry::cry:

LOL

never used to likes 5doors on anything but some more modern dubs pull it off nicely. mk2 and mk3 golfs are by far the worst 5door models imo

  • Author
You see so many 5 door cars where they have spent tons on their cars modding them and they get to that stage when they wish they stared with a 3 door in the first place. That when they remove the rear door handles, but it will never be the same :cry::cry::cry::cry:

LOL

never used to likes 5doors on anything but some more modern dubs pull it off nicely. mk2 and mk3 golfs are by far the worst 5door models imo

I beg to differ on the mk3 golf thing my old dub

Picture020.jpg

not a fan of 5 doors just no need for the extra doors tbh. I think its funny when people try to justify havin 5 door car its like admitting u wish u had 3 doors lol the same for having rear handles removed and smoothed one of the worst mods on a 5door imo.

some cars look cool in 5 door form deffo 6n Polo! but the 9ns look a bit dodgy with 5 doors

Ste

i want a 5door mk4 valver :cry:

any one wnata swap me for my 3door :biggrin:

t

I think more modern looking cars suit being a 2 door. Like a 6N does, but I think older cars like mk1 Golfs can pull of the 5 door thing. Specially if they are retro colours like beige with a brown interior :lol:

Nah I reckon it's the other way round, I've never been keen on five door Mk1 Golfs, they're a bit too small for it.

never used to likes 5doors on anything but some more modern dubs pull it off nicely. mk2 and mk3 golfs are by far the worst 5door models imo

I'm gonna have to disagree with you too :p

I think as far as Mk2 Golfs are concerned, I'm not big on small bumper 5 door models. With big bumpers I reckon they look pretty cool, in fact I reckon they're on a par with a 3 door.

With the Mk3, I don't think they look any better either way. Lots of flat metal everywhere, it doesn't make much difference.

The Mk4, meanwhile, has really nicely designed rear doors. I like the way the line of the rear bumper and lights is followed by the door, it gives the rear quarter panel a sweeping line that's really cool.

Not the best example, but it illustrates it well:

golf01.jpg

Making rear doors work on small cars is hard, not many do it well. They need to be a part of the design rather than looking like someone's stuck some extra doors on.

I think, actually one of the best examples of a small car soaking up the extra doors without looking cluttered is the new Mazda2. We've got one of these in on test, and I dig the way it looks. The back doors look fine, and it's a tiny car.

mazda2_sm.jpg

3 doors look better on smaller cars. 5 doors get away with it more the bigger the car

3 Door = Often look better because this is how the car was originally designed. 5 Doors often just butchered 3 doors and look worse for it. Cheaper. Stronger. I think hatch backs should have 3 doors...but big saloons and estates...rock on the 5 door!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.