Skip to content

The Good old debate 3 or 5 door

Featured Replies

3 Door = Often look better because this is how the car was originally designed. 5 Doors often just butchered 3 doors and look worse for it. Cheaper. Stronger. I think hatch backs should have 3 doors...but big saloons and estates...rock on the 5 door!

Aye, that's the point I was trying to make, you can pull off five doors if you design it well. Otherwise it looks poop.

  • Replies 46
  • Views 2.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I've got to say I perfer 5 Door Polo's... :-D

Not just because I own one but because there's something about them thats 'different'... Everybody ( nine times out of ten) goes for a 3 door car, they don't even consider a 5 door as there not sporty enough... I'm not saying in Polo's I'm meaning any small car! I also perfer 5 doors because there's less 'modded' ones going around whch makes them all the more cooler :-p

Agree... Yes/No ??

i do agree and also not just because i have a 5 door... i didnt have the choice of 3 door or 5 door it had to be 5 door as the parents bought it and i need to drive them around when needed and i dont regret it at all i love the for buying me the 5 door :D

I've got to say I perfer 5 Door Polo's... :-D

Not just because I own one but because there's something about them thats 'different'... Everybody ( nine times out of ten) goes for a 3 door car, they don't even consider a 5 door as there not sporty enough... I'm not saying in Polo's I'm meaning any small car! I also perfer 5 doors because there's less 'modded' ones going around whch makes them all the more cooler :-p

Agree... Yes/No ??

I agree. I know I have a 5 door lol and I'm not trying to justify or whatever..cus when I first had it I HATED five doors..but they have definetly grown on me and are definetly becoming more popular, with more people on here getting 5 door mk4s. I agree with what you say about them being 'different' I just love the way they look from some angles.

haha, i have always had the piss taken for having 5drs - my first car was a 5dr clio, seems it's about a ft longer so it's a 'stretch' clio :) I prefer the 3drs though on small hatches. The only reason I would have a 5dr is if I was putting people in the back often - it's the only time safety is an issue, it your in a smash anyone in the back of a 3dr has pretty much had it.

I didn't buy my polo for the fact that it had five doors (TBH I'm glad it does, the amount of stuff I'm picking up and moving for my project!) don't really matter does it, 5dr's can pimp as hard as 3dr's as far as I'm concerned...

Has any one ever seen a 5-door Integra...OMG...not good....

Impreza's look better as 3 door coupes than 5 door saloons.

aye I don't think it makes much difference at all, would be very far down the list of things i'd consider buying another car

i like the look of 3 door hatchs :) just self preference

I've had both 3 and 5 door cars - I have to say I agree with Tav about cars that are designed to be 3 doors - and I think the 6N is such a car - it looks like it was originally intended to be 3 door, then they went 'right, lets sort out this 5 door version then'. I had a mk 2 golf and that felt like it was intended to be 5 door - not sure how I'd feel about a 3 door one of those.

Also, the doors on 5 door mall cars are too small and can cause issues in themselves - once upon a time both me and my mum had renault 5's (yeah, I know....) I had a 3 door, and my mum had a 5 door. The front doors on the 5 door were so much shorter than on mine, that some people had problems getting into the car (admittedly mostly elderly relatives, but when you're young and have a car, you usually end up on granny-taxi duty at Christmas :lol: )

Edited by 6Newan

man I've never liked 5 doors, like already said, i am still yet to see a 5door car i like, it just doesnt work, i look and think, "man if that was 3 door it would be so much better...

jetta's and cars like that dont count as they have a big arse on them so can pull it off, but mk4's etc, the extra doors just look rubbish, no need!

man I've never liked 5 doors, like already said, i am still yet to see a 5door car i like, it just doesnt work, i look and think, "man if that was 3 door it would be so much better...

jetta's and cars like that dont count as they have a big arse on them so can pull it off, but mk4's etc, the extra doors just look rubbish, no need!

exactly.

I think, if you're gonna have 5 seats, you better have 5 doors. If someone takes out the rear seats in their car, 3 doors is better. Its such a wind up getting into the back of someones car when it has 3 doors.

it's basically looks Vs being practical, 2 door looks better anyday but 5 doors are much more practical obviously :roll: That is the way i see it anyway and it is up to you what you choose, and you shouldn't have to explain why you got a 5 door instead of a 3 door :roll:

I've never had a 5dr car but i think that the mk4/mk5 polo are the only small car that can pull them off

they have to be pretty pimp though otherwise they just look wack

marpols and that blue one on wellers are prime, like them a lot!!

5 door pimping all the way imo! they rock well if done up correctly that is

I prefer 3drs but some 5drs just look right:

NWVAGhomeandaway009.jpg

I agree that 5 doors can be good if designed around them. Take the Audi A3 Sportback. This car looks sooo much better than the normal 3 door just because of that different rear end. I wouldn't be surprised if this platform gets the RS3 engine, keeping in tradition with the RS line estate theme.

Iv owned a 3 door and a 5 door

I'm really into 5 doors now!

Its the way forward

final.jpg

4-7.jpg

17-3.jpg

* I make it happen!

Edited by VW_Technik

i think 5 doors are definitely more practical. Even more so with roofracks and towbars!

but, being a 17 year old with no family, 3 doors are way better lookswise, and are a bit lighter surely??

i prefer 3 doors but don't mind 5 doors especially when they look like the purple/maroon one in this gallery

http://www.cleaned.be/gallery/gallery.php?...s&cat_id=71

Edited by polo g

i have never owned a 5 door car, i just prefer 3 door models. some 5 doors can look great, especially if you take advantage of the extra doors, eg a mk2 golf with 4 A6 handles looks pretty trick.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.