Skip to content

Is a classic polo better in any way than recent model?

Featured Replies

someone on this forum mentioned to me that classic polos are better than recent models. I have a different opinion to that, I think recent models are better in almost every way,I wonder what the rest of you guys think?

  • Replies 44
  • Views 2.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Classic Polos? So, Mk1/2/3?

I'm not a Mk1 fan, but Mk2 and Mk3 Polos are the best looking IMO.

Sure, 6ns and newer handle better, are better in accidents etc - but definately not as reliable. When was the last time you heard of a Mk1/2/3 Polo spitting its gearbox every 30k? In fact, Mk2/3s only really have a couple of very cheap faults to fix.

And, of course, VW are still to release a Polo that accelerates faster than a G40!

4 cylinders FTW

Classic Polos? So, Mk1/2/3?

I'm not a Mk1 fan, but Mk2 and Mk3 Polos are the best looking IMO.

Sure, 6ns and newer handle better, are better in accidents etc - but definately not as reliable. When was the last time you heard of a Mk1/2/3 Polo spitting its gearbox every 30k? In fact, Mk2/3s only really have a couple of very cheap faults to fix.

And, of course, VW are still to release a Polo that accelerates faster than a G40!

Thats a valid point, the other person was convienced that the classic are better. I see what you mean!

4 cylinders FTW

I'm not very familiar with that model!

I had a MK2 which had a personality about seeing as it was 20 years old and had its little foibles and now I have a MK4 and I have to say the MK4 (6n) is a better car reliability wise and its much easier to drive and less costly to maintain seeing as I had to replace the carb and the distributor in the same week on the old mk2. I think in terms of as i said personality a MK2/MK3 has more but dont think id go back now I've got a mk4.

I also would have thought recent polos are more comfortable, have more gadgets , better handling , maybe less reliable, but surely that makes them better than classic polos!

I also would have thought recent polos are more comfortable, have more gadgets , better handling , maybe less reliable, but surely that makes them better than classic polos!

Depends how you determine "better". I think the older polos have a better design. Sure they don't handle as well and don't come with electric windows and a cd player, but they have a lot more character imo and really define the "dub" scene. I have a mk4 and I love it, but I really would like an older polo too :D

It does depend on what you see as better!

There couldn't have been a better car for me to properly learn to drive in (as in, a year on the road with it) than my Mk3 1.0 Polo.

It handled crap, it was slow. But, I knew exactly how it drove, you had feel in everything you did, from the rod change gearbox, the non-power assisted steering, the shit brakes, etc.

I like a thrash around the lanes here, and I found myself sideways in the Polo more than once, but the 1st time I found the limits, the times after that was controlling the car on the limit - and fun!

That's the whole thing. The older Polos are fun to drive - the minute you start adding power assistance, I'm not interested anymore!

All depends on what your opinion of "better" is.

I'm sure newer Polo's are better cars when you look at it based on dictionary definition of what a car should do. They are safer, more comfortable, quieter, more efficient etc etc. ... but driving a car isn't about rear leg room or cabin noise. A car should be entertaining, fun and have character. It should feel special to drive and engage you. I'd like someone to find a Polo that does any of these things better than a Mk3 G40.

I have a new Ford Focus and an Audi A6 to drive. If you look at the aformentioned tangible points they are both better cars than a Polo G40, but any day of the week I would choose to drive the G40 over them.

No newer car communicates quite so clearly what is happening through the steering, brakes or the seat of your pants. No newer car makes you giggle your ass off as you scrabble out of a corner in a hail of slight wheel spin and whoops of boost return (the passenger ride into town on Thursday was fully of me giggling, alot!)

The older cars do have some better tangible qualities than the newer cars though...

I think the Mk3 G40 must be one of the most comfortable Polo's to date thanks to its seats. No other car have I driven 500miles, over 10 hours and got out without any aches or pains. The seats are spot on.

You can have central locking and electric windows on a Mk3...other than that what more do you need? The omission of air con can be a little annoying but many new Polo's don't come with that either, just the option.

So to conclude....the newer Polo's are better but I'd rather have a G40. I saw G40 specifically because it has the power, brakes and steering components to make an older Polo feel great to drive.

Edit: hayeset just summed up my post in 1 line above....bastard...

Edited by Tav

I've owned a mk4, driven a mk5 and 6 and i a have to say i find them bland, no different to drive than any other modern supermini. the only good thing about new cars is the improved safety, cos lets face it all the gadgets on a new car can be fitted to an old one, without to much hassle. my mk4 was very reliable, but I've no end of mates who have had rather expensive faults develop. i dont think modern polos are built as well as they used to be either, though maybe this is down to some of the added complexity? yes in std form the mk4 onwards handle better, but the early ones can be made to handle very well without spending a fortune

very interesting points made! Putting aside comfort features like; aircon, etc concentrating on more just performance, handling and reliability of the cars, its safe to say older models are better then?

give me an old car anyday! they just have so much more feel. all this stuff like power steering and abs just makes me feel that I'm not in direct control. i would guess a mk4 without power steering, with a tuned chassis, 16v engine and all the electrical toys would be a fun car and probably a good mix between having modern bits and a more retro feel driving wise, shame only the pov spec mk4 polos got non pas!

newer polos are for ladies :)

newer polos are for ladies :)

now thats very interesting Ballemann, why do you say so?

well an old car wont depreciate as fast as a new one :lol: :lol:

Theres alot more joy to be had in an old car

newer polos are for ladies :)

now thats very interesting Ballemann, why do you say so?

have no idea, they look so ladie'ish :p here in norway polos are all owned by ladies :S

if they are better i have no clue :)

I have had a mk 3 gt, and now have a polo 6n2 and i hate it.

I'm gona sell it and go back to the gt!

Theres alot more joy to be had in an old car

I totally agree. I've driven loads of newer cars and find them utterly boring. I've driven fast ish ones and slow ones from mg zt's to pug 307's.

For me I like driving for 'driving' i dont even need a radio! I don't mind a radio but stuff like electric windows and air con, it's for fat lazy Americans as far as I'm concerned.

New cars have all this electronic shite on them you hardly feel as though your driving, it's almost a false sense of security. In my g40 I feel as though I can trust it, it will tell you through the honest mechanical make-up that it's at it's limit, no electronics making out that your still ok. Things like brakes, yeah they're a bit poo on my polo but I like that, you learn to live with it.

I'd never buy a new polo not just because I think they look awful, well the facelift is 100 times better than the 9n, but just because of how bland they are. That's just my opinion, obviously people do like them as they sell, but for me it's the older car.

Theres alot more joy to be had in an old car

I totally agree. I've driven loads of newer cars and find them utterly boring. I've driven fast ish ones and slow ones from mg zt's to pug 307's.

For me I like driving for 'driving' i dont even need a radio! I don't mind a radio but stuff like electric windows and air con, it's for fat lazy Americans as far as I'm concerned.

New cars have all this electronic shite on them you hardly feel as though your driving, it's almost a false sense of security. In my g40 I feel as though I can trust it, it will tell you through the honest mechanical make-up that it's at it's limit, no electronics making out that your still ok. Things like brakes, yeah they're a bit poo on my polo but I like that, you learn to live with it.

I'd never buy a new polo not just because I think they look awful, well the facelift is 100 times better than the 9n, but just because of how bland they are. That's just my opinion, obviously people do like them as they sell, but for me it's the older car.

Is it the need for speed then that gives you the thrills from the classic models, or you just love them because there are 'maybe fewer' on the road and therefore exclusive?

Not necessarily it's more to do with the raw driving of an older car.

If I wanted exclusivity I wouldn't have been driving a 16 year old Polo... It's nothing to do with that.

It's not a need for speed either - it was slow!

If you are somebody who enjoys driving, and by driving I don't mean pootling along at 50 in top gear, I mean properly driving, then the older cars are better because of the feel they offer. As simple as that! You have to go to fairly lengthy methods to get a good amount of feel from power steering. Some pull it off, most don't.

I like to know I'm on the limit when the steering wheel has gone light, or I need to get in a bit of opposite lock, not because a light starts flashing on the dashboard.

It's all to do with being comfortable about driving a car YOU like rather than what mates, family and collegues might think is crap or based on the size of your wallet.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.