Skip to content

Is a classic polo better in any way than recent model?

Featured Replies

.....a car should be entertaining, fun and have character. It should feel special to drive and engage you....

I dont think they 'should' be. People want cars for different things.

For instance, my mum wouldnt want a car for the fun or entertaining aspect. She'd be more bothered about safety and just

making sure it was reliable, comfy and got her to the supermarket and to Leeds shopping :-D

I'm 22 and female, I've always loved cars and they must have character, which is why I've had a lot of 'old' ones.

Now I'm getting to the point where I'm more bothered about comfort, safety and mod cons. And not bombing about in

a car that looks like i drove it straight out of a scrap yard. :lol:

  • Replies 44
  • Views 2.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Whats better? McDonalds or Burger King?

Ford or VW?

Xbox or Playstation?

PC or Mac?

etc etc..

The list goes pn and on.. Its all personal opinion.

I would have an old car over a new car anyday. Not that I think they are better, I just prefer them. It may not be as comfy or as safe and smooth but my GT still takes the piss out of mondern-day equivlants on looks, handling and speed.

I'd like both, for different reasons. I love my GT.

McDonalds or Burger King? Burger King

Ford or VW? VW

Xbox or Playstation? Playstation

PC or Mac? PC

What do I get for filling out your survey?

After reading through the replies, I have to say that supercharged spaniel has hit the nail on the head.

If you are interested in driving feel and enjoyment, then the older ones are far better IMO.

Yes, of course the newer ones are safer in every respect and have more creature comforts. But they don't add in anyway to the driving involvement and character which is for me at least, is the most important thing.

Of course to the majority of Joe Public, owning a new or newer VW is more about badge snobbery, comfort and safety.

Polo's (just like all small cars of there type) have always appealed in the main to women. 'Nothing wrong with that.

For me, the newer Polo's have lost there appeal mainly due to loosing the original strong points that VW had. Reliabilty and build quality are piss poor IMO on mk4/6n and onwards.

All of the people that I know who own more modern Polo's/Golf's have had issues with reliablity and build quality. Gearbox failures, rust, poor electrics - particularly windows and central locking, interior trims falling off etc.

Why they are so relatively expensive new and retain high second hand values is beyond me.

So "better" in one person's eyes is different to another person's.

It all depends on what you're after.

.....a car should be entertaining, fun and have character. It should feel special to drive and engage you....

I dont think they 'should' be. People want cars for different things.

For instance, my mum wouldnt want a car for the fun or entertaining aspect. She'd be more bothered about safety and just

making sure it was reliable, comfy and got her to the supermarket and to Leeds shopping :-D

I'm 22 and female, I've always loved cars and they must have character, which is why I've had a lot of 'old' ones.

Now I'm getting to the point where I'm more bothered about comfort, safety and mod cons. And not bombing about in

a car that looks like i drove it straight out of a scrap yard. :lol:

I'm not really interested in comuting, I don't see this as the main use for a car. For me a car is a tool to enjoy roads with...the more enjoyment you get from driving the better the car. This extends to the point where I'm not overly bothered about what badge it comes with or even how it looks.

The key is to get a car that's both entertaining and gives you the performance perks...Panda 100HP is one example of a modern car which does this.

...but then I always end up taking 35miles to get home from uni...when it's only 6 miles to my house...

Edited by Tav

its down to personal opinion, personally i like mk1 2 & 3 polo's. more character (and rattles) and easy to fix cheaply. mine is very reliable and the are a bit rarer on the roads now.

Always had older cars (early 90s cars mostly) and gave into peer pressure and bought a modern car. Its great, handles better, quicker, more comfortable, more toys, better interior but its just not the same as an older car. Older cars just have a certain charm.

yeah I'd go for more character on an older car too, after driving my mk2 for the last few years somehow I just dont think a "nice" new car would be the same. My mk2 is basic and down to the essentials to get you from A to B, what more do you want :lol: :lol:

Edited by optima21

McDonalds or Burger King? Burger King

Ford or VW? VW

Xbox or Playstation? Playstation

PC or Mac? PC

What do I get for filling out your survey?

excellent choices sir!

for me its older cars and their quirky bits that i like, when i travel in a mates 6n its just isnt the same as when we go out in mine, theres a certain something that VW got just right about the 86c and then managed to ruin with the 6n. the 6n feels just like any other car to passenger in, everything works, seats are tidy, clocks correct, its got a cd player with all the speakers working. boring is a harsh word but its gettin on for that.

but then again, i am heavily biased by owning a Mk2, as are most of the other replies.

yeah I'd go for more character on an older car too, after driving my mk2 for the last few years somehow I just dont think a "nice" new car would be the same. My mk2 is basic and down to the essentials to get you from A to B, what more do you want :lol: :lol:

Take you from B back to A :lol:

Not necessarily it's more to do with the raw driving of an older car.

:nod:

Less means more...

To some of us maybe :paranoid:

I like my Mk5. It's not too big like newer superminis, still has character imo, good mix of old and new (could argue it looks like a Mk3 breadvan lol)

I've had a mk3 and a mk4.. i like them both and never really had any problems with either. my mk3 needed and oil pressure sensor in the whole time i had it. my mk4 is misfiring so i have sparks ready to go in.. i would say i prefer the classics but the mk4 is nice aswell.

It looks to me as this is a never ending arguement. Each side is protecting their choice! I had to ask this question because I was not convienced that classic models are better. This is a win-win situation for both models, people who own classic models have put forward great points that support their choices and the same applies to owners of recent model. People who own both models seem to suggest that both models are good! Well where do we go from here, I guess it'll be "Polo or Golf?"

Definately a Golf :lol:

There's headroom, it goes round corners, and my engine choice is practically anything from the VW range!

Definately a Golf :lol:

There's headroom, it goes round corners, and my engine choice is practically anything from the VW range!

Is it because you own a golf? Check out new topic and send your reply in there. Cheers!

my old mk4 was alright

loved the interior everything bar the leccy window switches (the elec windows were broke btw) was where it should be

had shitty tyres on and i ragged it, went on 3 wheels and scrubbed off all its speed before it would lose control lol

my mk3 is ok aswell, seats are comfy, everything inside works as its all basic and good, handles better due to good tyres/strut brace/suspension and is fookin well faster

people always look at it aswell which nobody took a blind bit of notice to the mk4

tough choice between the two, i prefer my gt to my 1.4 cl but having tried a mk3 would probably get a mk4 16v if i was to get another

although my next car will either be a g40 or a e30 318is lol

my old mk4 was alright

loved the interior everything bar the leccy window switches (the elec windows were broke btw) was where it should be

had shitty tyres on and i ragged it, went on 3 wheels and scrubbed off all its speed before it would lose control lol

my mk3 is ok aswell, seats are comfy, everything inside works as its all basic and good, handles better due to good tyres/strut brace/suspension and is fookin well faster

people always look at it aswell which nobody took a blind bit of notice to the mk4

tough choice between the two, i prefer my gt to my 1.4 cl but having tried a mk3 would probably get a mk4 16v if i was to get another

so in other words, classic polo will do you alright?

although my next car will either be a g40 or a e30 318is lol

IMHO ye maybe a newer polo is better........But the older ones are just soo much more cool! 8-) :cool:

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.