Skip to content

Polo or Golf ?

Featured Replies

Polos are great cars to own and drive, however are Golfs better, or just bigger? what do you think!

  • Replies 35
  • Views 2.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

imo I prefer my golf alot more than my old mk3.

bigger, faster, more comfortable, feels safer

But some newer golfs, like the mk4 I don't particularly like

EDIT: sorry, I mean faster than my old polo which was a 1.3 as my golf is the 1.8 driver

Edited by goose

imo I prefer my golf alot more than my old mk3.

bigger, faster, more comfortable, feels safer

But some newer golfs, like the mk4 I don't particularly like

but there are some pretty fast polos around, besides cabin noise levels, aren't Golfs just bigger?

Get into a standard Mk2/3 Polo and try going quickly along a country lane. Then get into a Mk2 Golf, and notice how where you were struggling with the Polo, the Golf just does it's thing. You can feel a rear wheel lifting and then dumping itself back down again :lol: whenever I got to that stage in the Polo I had to be on my toes lol

wow! but there are some Polos around with great handling! Isn't it just the big feeling of the Golf that gives you confidence to do things you may not normally do in a Polo, mainly cos you have a sense of security in a Golf?

tbh i think the naturall progression is polo to golf. well it will be for me when i have a few ncb under my belt. ill be getting a mk2/3 16v

i think after golf... ill get the daddy of dubs......corrado vr6 and put a charger in it. *go's into day dream*

wow! but there are some Polos around with great handling! Isn't it just the big feeling of the Golf that gives you confidence to do things you may not normally do in a Polo, mainly cos you have a sense of security in a Golf?

No, it's because the Golf has proper front suspension lol

My Mk1 Golf (not much if any bigger than a polo) felt 10x better built than my polo, handled 10x better (might have been something to do with the 14x8's and coilovers though) and got 10x the respect. But my Polo is quicker in a straight line and much more economical.

^^^ Agree with Tobyk on the suspension.

Edited by XRP

tobyk; just out of courosity (spelling :S) why do u knock so many posts up on cp. when u dont like polos? ? lol

Because I had a Mk3 Polo for a while... Was OK up to a point.

I have lots of posts because I'm sad lol

o right. fair play.

what golf do youhave.. obvisly its mk2 in you are pic, but what isit?

My Mk1 Golf (not much if any bigger than a polo) felt 10x better built than my polo, handled 10x better (might have been something to do with the 14x8's and coilovers though) and got 10x the respect. But my Polo is quicker in a straight line and much more economical.

^^^ Agree with Tobyk on the suspension.

the suspension aspect might be because its a sports suspension, it wouldn't be standard feature on all Golf, would it?

No, it's not - although Mk2/3 Polos don't handle that badly for their era - there is a reason why Mk1 and Mk2 Golfs are considered to be among the best handling front drive cars ever - not just the 70s/80s...

Stock vs Stock - the Golf wins hands down. But, there are a few select mods you can apply to early Polo suspension which can help. Ultimately though, you are looking at a wishbone conversion, which brings the front suspension setup to near enough Golf spec...

Put it this way.

Polo was the lower version of the Golf. The Golf would have been designed as the bigger better car so everything about it would have been better, that includes handling. (feel free to shoot me down if this is wrong btw)

I had a Mk3 polo for about 5-6 months and the handling was shit to be quite honest. was fun but it was shit!

Another thing - when VW released the Mk4 Polo, it shared a surprising number of suspension components with the Mk2 Golf. 1984 (I think) was the first year of production for the Mk2 Golf, yet 11 years later, VW released the Mk4 Polo with mostly the same bits!

Personally I think my mk3 handles well. Especially roundabouts instead of braking I just drop it into 3rd and accelerate and it sticks. Lowered on alloys with good tyres in a lightweight car. Obviously not the same if it was standard.

In my previous car a long time ago 1.4 mk2 fiesta I used to slide out on roundabouts all the time.

Put it this way.

Polo was the lower version of the Golf. The Golf would have been designed as the bigger better car so everything about it would have been better, that includes handling. (feel free to shoot me down if this is wrong btw)

I had a Mk3 polo for about 5-6 months and the handling was shit to be quite honest. was fun but it was shit!

I would like to differ, sometimes I think its like the Bora and Golf, Bora is bigger but no better really, except for a few sporty ones. The same applies to the Polos and Golfs, there are some really better Polos and really sh***y Golfs out there!

The Bora isn't a bigger Golf - it's just a Golf with a boot! Same goes for the Vento and Jetta...

The Golf's only weakness is the non-VR6 Mk3s... How VW could badge the 2.0s GTIs I don't know. Same goes for the 2.0 Mk4s actually...

If we stick to the early cars, IE Mk1/2/3 Polos and Mk1/2 Golfs - then the Polos do not have anything on the Golfs...

I will say I enjoyed driving my Mk3 Polo though. Shit it may have been, but it still brought a smile to my face. It was a 1.0, and more than capable of going to quickly for it's suspension design :lol:

The Bora isn't a bigger Golf - it's just a Golf with a boot! Same goes for the Vento and Jetta...

The Golf's only weakness is the non-VR6 Mk3s... How VW could badge the 2.0s GTIs I don't know. Same goes for the 2.0 Mk4s actually...

If we stick to the early cars, IE Mk1/2/3 Polos and Mk1/2 Golfs - then the Polos do not have anything on the Golfs...

I will say I enjoyed driving my Mk3 Polo though. Shit it may have been, but it still brought a smile to my face. It was a 1.0, and more than capable of going to quickly for it's suspension design :lol:

Take earlier Golf GTis and the G40s etc , what do you think?

If we match the era, we've got early 90s Golf GTI vs Polo G40.

The ideal comparison would be Golf G60 vs Polo G40 - in which case the performance of the two is similar, although the G40 will probably hit 60 faster. Not a hope in hell of catching up after that. Whether it be up to 130+ mph or round a twisty road - no chance.

Golf GTI 16v would also woop a G40 at everything, std vs std. An 8v GTI would have a pretty good go as well.

It is safe to say that the G40 is the better handling Mk3 Polo - due to rose jointed suspension parts and slightly stiffer springs - but these just serve to take up slack, rather than make it better.

But, a fucked Mk2 1.3 Golf would probably have a G40 round a track*

* maybe not strictly true :lol:

just dont buy a mk2 golf, they look horible :)

If we match the era, we've got early 90s Golf GTI vs Polo G40.

The ideal comparison would be Golf G60 vs Polo G40 - in which case the performance of the two is similar, although the G40 will probably hit 60 faster. Not a hope in hell of catching up after that. Whether it be up to 130+ mph or round a twisty road - no chance.

Golf GTI 16v would also woop a G40 at everything, std vs std. An 8v GTI would have a pretty good go as well.

It is safe to say that the G40 is the better handling Mk3 Polo - due to rose jointed suspension parts and slightly stiffer springs - but these just serve to take up slack, rather than make it better.

But, a fucked Mk2 1.3 Golf would probably have a G40 round a track*

hey "tobyk" where do you get your facts from, just wondering? 8-)

* maybe not strictly true :lol:

From speaking to people who have owned G60 Golfs and G40 Polos.

And from driving both Mk3 Polos and Mk2 Golfs.

hey "tobyk" where do you get your facts from, just wondering?

oh i see, as long as there's some personal experiences lol!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.