Skip to content

gear changing

Featured Replies

just a quick question need to know something about gear changing. its a 1.4cl

i like to be economical and tend to be in 5th gear at about 35mph and 4th about 27mph+. is this fine or is the speed to low for the gears. the car takes it fine but just wondering it wont cause any damage to the gearbox or anything will it :?

thanks

Edited by dhali

  • Replies 28
  • Views 4.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

If the car isn't juddering then its fine. :)

Being economical and being in 5th gear at 35 mph are two completely different things though. Unlikely to cause any damage, but for the extra throttle you need to accelarate in 5th, you'd be as well to stay in 4th. Or 3rd.

I borrowed a mates 1.4 Mk4 and thrashed the tits off it, changing gear about 6000 rpm and it somehow still managed 40 mpg. I need one of them :lol:

Edited by tobyk

i tend to change when it hits 2k revs. i only do it to save fuel, but if i rag it and it will still give me high mpg i may aswell do that :lol:

When I had my mk 4 I'd be in 4th at 35. Then rag it till it sounded like it was gonna fall to pieces before 5th, but it was a thirsty car.

I loved that car, I miss it :(

I'm sure I read somewhere that low speed in a high gear puts strain on the engine. How truthful that is, I don't know.

when i had my GT i used to be in 3rd @ 20mph, 4th @ 25 and if i was sat going along at 30 i'd have it in 5th but then drop a gear if i needed to accelerate any more than 1/4throttle. used to get on average 40-45mpg of mixed driving

just coast 8-) :-D

just coast 8-) :-D

And use more fuel than leaving it in gear and using engine braking?

just coast 8-) :-D

And use more fuel than leaving it in gear and using engine braking?

he's right you know. engine has to use fuel to stop itself stalling :thumbsup:

It depends on the road really, a flat road with just me or a light passenger I'll be in 5th at 30 (mk3 1.3spi), any hint of a hill and I'll go down to 4th. Even down hill I'll go into 4th if it's a 30mph zone that needs to be stuck to.

Definitely don't coast - engine uses zero fuel going down hill in gear :) Not to mention lack of control!

[edit]Fuel injected at least[/edit]

Edited by Ray2k

I'm sure I read somewhere that low speed in a high gear puts strain on the engine. How truthful that is, I don't know.

Yeah, that's right, but you have to quite mechanically unsympathetic to do damage. Wide/ full throttle from 1000rpm in 3rd/4th/5th would probably be a good recipe for knackered bearings. Low engine speed = lower oil pressure and then factor in maximum engine load and you can imagine the rest.

Generally though, as someone else said, as long as there's no vibration or juddering, you'll be ok. Just bear in mind this is more relevant when at a constant speed. Hills and acceleration will require a down change.

i tend to change when it hits 2k revs. i only do it to save fuel, but if i rag it and it will still give me high mpg i may aswell do that :lol:

Petrol engines tend to be most economical between 2-3000rpm. By driving lower in the RPM range you are labouring the engine. If you look at the RPM you sit at when cruising in 5th at 60mph you'll see it is probably somewhere between 2-3000rpm. Less rev's do not mean more miles per gallon. The full rev range is there to be used as required. If accelerating up a hill you need to use the engines power that is available higher up the RPM range.

Key to good economy is using small throttle openings, being smooth and accelerating gently. Make use of the gears and the rev's...that's why they are there.

1st is for pulling away. Gears 2-4 are for accelerating and 5th is for cruising at a constant speed. I would never accelerate in 5th...even when going from 50 up to 70. Slide it back to 4th...bring up the speed and then back to 5th.

I personally won't use anything higher than 3rd in a 30, unless in the GT. You need to retain some acceleration and engine braking too...again only available slightly higher up the RPM range.

Edited by Tav

There is a whole website dedicated to fuel economy. Some of them believe using full throttle accelaration is the most economical way of accelerating, because sharp bursts of a lot of fuel are better than 30 seconds getting up to speed at half throttle.

At the end of the day, you'll find what works for you.

when i had my GT i used to be in 3rd @ 20mph, 4th @ 25 and if i was sat going along at 30 i'd have it in 5th but then drop a gear if i needed to accelerate any more than 1/4throttle. used to get on average 40-45mpg of mixed driving

you are my driving twin, i drive exactly the same and have no probs, its economical and makes sense

5th gear in my car at 30mph and it wants to stall...

3rd 22mph, 4th 30mph, 5th 38mph. Anything less and it wont pull with your foot tapping the accelerator.

And being a Sport 5th gear @ 60mph = 3,000rpm :? So if you ever see a Lupo Sport on the motorway doing 60mph or 120mph instead of 70 that's me :biggrin:

Need 6th gear !

Edited by nick0323

i tend to change when it hits 2k revs. i only do it to save fuel, but if i rag it and it will still give me high mpg i may aswell do that :lol:

Petrol engines tend to be most economical between 2-3000rpm. By driving lower in the RPM range you are labouring the engine. If you look at the RPM you sit at when cruising in 5th at 60mph you'll see it is probably somewhere between 2-3000rpm. Less rev's do not mean more miles per gallon. The full rev range is there to be used as required. If accelerating up a hill you need to use the engines power that is available higher up the RPM range.

Key to good economy is using small throttle openings, being smooth and accelerating gently. Make use of the gears and the rev's...that's why they are there.

1st is for pulling away. Gears 2-4 are for accelerating and 5th is for cruising at a constant speed. I would never accelerate in 5th...even when going from 50 up to 70. Slide it back to 4th...bring up the speed and then back to 5th.

I personally won't use anything higher than 3rd in a 30, unless in the GT. You need to retain some acceleration and engine braking too...again only available slightly higher up the RPM range.

Braking as little as you can is also good as well. As well as not just stamping on the brakes. Gradually slowing down basically.

Doing 30 in 3rd is good actually. Because when you start to go over 30 the engine starts to get a bit noisey. Good way to keep yourself at 30. Thats what I do anyway. Stop you speeding, does in my car anyway, lol.

Nick - I have a Polo GTI box on my Lupo and on the motorway its much better than the sport box. The sport box used to rev its tits out!

But the upside to the sport box was that you could put your foot down in 5th at pretty much any speed above 55 and it would wind itself up and just go where as the Polo GTI one prefers to be dropped into 4th. Ain't no biggy tho, I prefer it. Means better MPG on long runs!

Nick - I have a Polo GTI box on my Lupo and on the motorway its much better than the sport box. The sport box used to rev its tits out!

But the upside to the sport box was that you could put your foot down in 5th at pretty much any speed above 55 and it would wind itself up and just go where as the Polo GTI one prefers to be dropped into 4th. Ain't no biggy tho, I prefer it. Means better MPG on long runs!

Yes I must admit that 5th gear is awesome, even if you just tap the throttle at 60mph you fly up to 100mph easy before having to push the throttle harder.

My car is going into VW this Saturday to have the pedal box looked at (free of charge) and replaced (free of charge) if need be. Its also getting a free visual check LOL :unibrow::finger:

I might as well ask VW to quote me on a GTI gearbox whilst I'm there this Saturday, my gearbox is kind of stiff sometimes although its a common symptom of a collapsing pedal box aparantly.

EDIT: May as well make it a refurbished gearbox otherwise I'm going to see my hard-earned monies go down the drain.

Sick idea. -N-

Edited by nick0323

I'm in third in 30mph zones and 4th in 40mph zones. 4th in 50mph zones if I need to change speed alot or 5th if its a like road with no roundabouts etc.

I'm in 3rd at 20, 4th at 30 and 5th if I'm over 40..

I heard it's better for your car to be revving slightly high than struggling..

Nick - I have a Polo GTI box on my Lupo and on the motorway its much better than the sport box. The sport box used to rev its tits out!

But the upside to the sport box was that you could put your foot down in 5th at pretty much any speed above 55 and it would wind itself up and just go where as the Polo GTI one prefers to be dropped into 4th. Ain't no biggy tho, I prefer it. Means better MPG on long runs!

Yes I must admit that 5th gear is awesome, even if you just tap the throttle at 60mph you fly up to 100mph easy before having to push the throttle harder.

My car is going into VW this Saturday to have the pedal box looked at (free of charge) and replaced (free of charge) if need be. Its also getting a free visual check LOL :unibrow::finger:

I might as well ask VW to quote me on a GTI gearbox whilst I'm there this Saturday, my gearbox is kind of stiff sometimes although its a common symptom of a collapsing pedal box aparantly.

EDIT: May as well make it a refurbished gearbox otherwise I'm going to see my hard-earned monies go down the drain.

Sick idea. -N-

You ready for the price..... £1,200 on exchange + VAT :lol: Labour is around £450-500 on it to.

when i had my GT i used to be in 3rd @ 20mph, 4th @ 25 and if i was sat going along at 30 i'd have it in 5th but then drop a gear if i needed to accelerate any more than 1/4throttle. used to get on average 40-45mpg of mixed driving

you are my driving twin, i drive exactly the same and have no probs, its economical and makes sense

never found my GT to feel like it was struggling at 30 in 5th so never bothered altering my style, plus on my first GT anything above 2k was pure ASBO noise so obviously going through towns etc didnt really want the revs to high because of the exhaust lol

I never go below 40 in 5th, and 30 in 4th in my GTI (both just around 2000 rpm)

Nick - I have a Polo GTI box on my Lupo and on the motorway its much better than the sport box. The sport box used to rev its tits out!

But the upside to the sport box was that you could put your foot down in 5th at pretty much any speed above 55 and it would wind itself up and just go where as the Polo GTI one prefers to be dropped into 4th. Ain't no biggy tho, I prefer it. Means better MPG on long runs!

Yes I must admit that 5th gear is awesome, even if you just tap the throttle at 60mph you fly up to 100mph easy before having to push the throttle harder.

My car is going into VW this Saturday to have the pedal box looked at (free of charge) and replaced (free of charge) if need be. Its also getting a free visual check LOL :unibrow::finger:

I might as well ask VW to quote me on a GTI gearbox whilst I'm there this Saturday, my gearbox is kind of stiff sometimes although its a common symptom of a collapsing pedal box aparantly.

EDIT: May as well make it a refurbished gearbox otherwise I'm going to see my hard-earned monies go down the drain.

Sick idea. -N-

You ready for the price..... £1,200 on exchange + VAT :lol: Labour is around £450-500 on it to.

:crybaby:

Did you win the lotto? Fancy sharing out some of that money? :unibrow:

May as well turn my head and focus on getting a 40mm drop with some descent tyres.

Edited by nick0323

i tend to change when it hits 2k revs. i only do it to save fuel, but if i rag it and it will still give me high mpg i may aswell do that :lol:

Petrol engines tend to be most economical between 2-3000rpm. By driving lower in the RPM range you are labouring the engine. If you look at the RPM you sit at when cruising in 5th at 60mph you'll see it is probably somewhere between 2-3000rpm. Less rev's do not mean more miles per gallon. The full rev range is there to be used as required. If accelerating up a hill you need to use the engines power that is available higher up the RPM range.

Key to good economy is using small throttle openings, being smooth and accelerating gently. Make use of the gears and the rev's...that's why they are there.

1st is for pulling away. Gears 2-4 are for accelerating and 5th is for cruising at a constant speed. I would never accelerate in 5th...even when going from 50 up to 70. Slide it back to 4th...bring up the speed and then back to 5th.

I personally won't use anything higher than 3rd in a 30, unless in the GT. You need to retain some acceleration and engine braking too...again only available slightly higher up the RPM range.

Right on all counts. Anything less than 2k in a petrol and it's having to produce more torque than it naturally would, so will waste fuel.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.