Skip to content

possible dodgy mechanic ....advice needed!

Featured Replies

Right on saturday was driving along not fast started to go up a hill and the driveshaft popped out, had a tow home (70 pound down). since then the car has been sitting outside my house, today my dad passed me the number of a mobile mechanic, he came round today at half 5, didn't even jack the car up just looked under the bonnet, eventually telling me that i had sheered my driveshaft ect... basically telling me what i already know charges me 20 quid for this and requires a further 30 ish pound for a second hand drive shaft/c.v joint/new bolts and 50 pound to fit it, tells me i will get charged extra for geabox oil. I get the feeling that he's going to find a way to bump the price up even more tho, as when he came to view the car he seemed very unprofessional as he didn't get a very good look at it, just always presuming and that he could match the parts from another volkswagen is that possible??

just wondering what you guys think, should i cut my loss's and look somewhere else for help or take my chances with this guy,

oh yeh and he said my gearbox (polo 1.4 16v 75bhp) was used in loads of other cars like mk2 golfs every other old polo an so on is this true??

thanks

Edited by leescreen123

  • Replies 10
  • Views 1.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

use somebody else would be my advice

charging you £20 in the first place? i dont get it

hello, my car is broke, i think it might be the driveshaft

yeah, its broke mate.... £20 please :lol:

not all VW gearboxes are the same either

there shouldnt be any hidden costs, labour should be 1 hour which we charge £40 for.. s/h driveshaft £20, oil no more than £10

and actually why does it need oil? the driveshaft bolts to the flange on the gearbox, so no need to drain any oil

The only thing I will say is that its not uncommon for a mobile mechanic (or any engineer/electrician/plumber) to have a call out charge. £20 is about normal I reckon.

I would say if your not happy with the service find someone else. If your not happy with him it'll always be in the back of your mind as to whether he did the job properly or not.

Take it to a proper garage so if it goes wrong you can follow it up and you have a warranty

thats a joke, tell him to ram it and get a garage to do the job as said, at least that way you have comeback

  • Author

thanks for the replies, and to adeg40 he did literally just that, 20 pound just for a minute of work seems kinda hard to get to grips with. he could of jacked the car up and got a close look just to see there was nothing wrong and it has just come undone, as for the gearbox oil he justified it by sayin that the c.v joints are all connected to the gearbox and when its all removed the gearbox oil will come p**sing out? it would be brilliant if some1 who has there driveshaft go could commet plz ,and i'm wary about him using old parts off another car! the hole thing is a nightmare at the moment!!!

thanks

Edited by leescreen123

If he unbolts the inner cv from the gearbox, no fluid will be lost.

I'd say no just for him wanting £100 to supply and fit a second hand drive shaft.

Go to a garage mate and get a brand new one fitted will last longer and as said you will have come back on the work that has been done.

I know lots of good mechanics, and they all have garages. The only good mobile bloke I know is the one that goes from garage to garage round here doing electrics, the rest of them are crap at it.

give GSF a ring, find out how much it is for a new driveshaft, usually on an exchange basis, then by a new one, comes with new inner and outer cv joints on it and will cost about £55. jack the car up, get an M8 spline bit, undo the 8 (iirc) bolts where it attaches to the gearbox flangew, then undo the hubnut, 28mm socket??, think you have to split the bottom ball joint aswell, not sure on mark 4/5's, remove the driveshaft from the hub and replace and refit with the new one. gearbox oil shouldnt be asffected.

thats a rough guide of what i think i did about 18months back when i popped a driveshaft on my GT..........

if I'm wrong, someone correct me........

£100 to supply and fit a driveshaft of unknown history ent worth it mate, get him to fit a new one if your gonna get him to do it!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.