Skip to content

How reliable?

Featured Replies

I currently drive a 51 plate standard fiesta zetec S and to be honest its a great car, reliable, good mpg, comftable Etc.

But,

I have always like VWs ever since i was a kid, my brother drives a bread van and my mate has an old very nice beetle. I wouldn't mind selling my fiesta and buying an oldish polo- maybe a G40 or a newer GTi(not newest) maybe a 16v. My question is are they reliable enough? I know modern VWs (or german cars in general) are all round very reliable, but is this the same case with the older ones? As i do a lot of travelling to London from Yorkshire so reliability and OK MPG is a must.

Thanks in advance,

C

Edited by curly

  • Replies 13
  • Views 1.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I'd say the older VWs are more reliable than the newer stuff. You'd be hard pushed to go wrong with a Mk3 Polo GT. G40s are all very well, but they do need more maintenance. Good economy and good performance when standard though. Easily tuneable.

As toby said. 16v's and alike tend to eat gearboxes. Earlier polos can be bullet proof if looked after properly. G40 wise, treat it with respect and dont abuse it and it will be your faithful friend (like a tame husky) but abuse it and the wolf will quickly come out!

As long as you dont push the modifications too far on it and keep the services etc regular then a g40 will be perfectly reliable. its only if you go mental like a few of us on here then youre looking at chucking endless amounts of money at it in a never ending pit of things to do.

I wouldnt change it for the world though! (well slight exaggeration but i love it!) Get taken out in a g and you will see why the common phrase g smiles is so frequently heard!

Chris

The older VW's all in all are more reliable than the newer ones .

Iff you want a car that is similar in speed to your Zetec-S or slightly quicker go for a Mk3 GT

A Mk3 GT with some mods to bring it close to 100Bhp will easily be at a similar standard to a Zetec-S

The thing about Mk3's they have such a fun driving experience being small and light.

G40's are a whole new kettle of fish and as said by Sooped up g are ridiculous . You wont stop having fun in a G40 the sound the speed the shear thrill . They can become expensive on the servicing as you are talking about a supercharger. Iff you can afford it this would be the car you should go for in my eyes .

You also have to think that in a G40/GT you wont have all the Mod Cons you have gotten used to in your Zetec-S .

mk3 GT's are a hell of alot of fun....not a long distance commuting car but good fun in the bends.

mines been on and off for reliability....but thats what you get with a car thats done 100k+ and over 14 years old....parts need replaceing due to age, just something you have to expect.

few mods will see 100bhp close to a standard G40 for pace....

Although if your planning to jump into a mk3 Polo just remember that its very basic inside. No power steering, no central locking, not electric windows, no air bags, no abs, no air con etc.

Get yourself a mk3 mate spi/GT/G40 I've had a spi an I'm now on a G40, my first car loved long distances regardless of what people say she was reliable with it i used to do 100 mile+ journeys every week an as long as u sit at a resonable speed youll be fine an i got 400 miles to my tank aswell so bonus.

G40 on the other hand i use mine daily an once a week long distance, its happy with it but it is soon time to do oil an filter change (every 3k i do mine), lube charger (if you have boost return mod) etc. an thats fine if you have the money, mine gets everything it needs regardless of price, so my advice would be just make sure you can afford general maintence get friendly with GSF an VW an get a good/cheap mechanic. :grin:

Edited by wozzapolo1.3

Although if your planning to jump into a mk3 Polo just remember that its very basic inside. No power steering, no central locking, not electric windows, no air bags, no abs, no air con etc.

Yeah I would second that. If you are looking for a long distance cruiser then there are better cars out there than the GT or the G40 (your Fiesta being one of them) I'm saying they are not up to the job the early polos will run for ever with no problems but you might miss the refinements and comforts of a modern car.

Some of the newer polos like the GTI and the 16v might be better but I think (esp if you are looking at the Mk5's) but there is that issue with eating gearbox's and such which could be off putting.

You ever thought about having 2 car's? you can buy a Mk3 GT for a few hundred quid tune it up over time and have a cheap little weekend fun thing... and have a more refined weekday car.

I can kinda see the Zetec S being a modern day GT. Not overly quick but nippy and fun to drive. I have always fancied one for some reason!! :)

On the handling front, there isn't a standard Polo in existance that will be a better handling car than your ZS, so as long as you accept that :p

Thanks for the great replys guys, all very helpful.

2 cars would be good, but i just have not got the space for them both really. I dont really think the G40 would be such a great car for me yet then, maybe when i can have a second car.

I was just browsing through the car's for sale section on here and came accross a Golf Gti 1.8 8v. what are these like? dont know enough on the older Gti' s really although i'm guessing it's like any other car, look after it and it will repay you by being strong and reliable.

The Mk2 1.8 8vs are a great car, light, quick enough, good on insurance, not amazing on fuel economy though. The handling is very good for their age. There are plenty on 200,000 miles and above.

Perfect daily driver if you can live with 30-35 mpg average.

All 3 of my bro's Mk2 GTi 8v have been brilliant for any sort of driving, they aren't to bad on mpg, great cornering, you get pretty good acceration and they are brilliant for motorway journeys, overall a nice car for the money.

My mate swears by his 8V GTI's.

Mk2 Gols piss all over Mk3 polo's in almost all respects

The only problem is there a little bit of a larger car .

They handle like a dream and can be tuned to be pretty quick :nod:

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.