Skip to content

stock or standard

Featured Replies

Hi , i am thinking of changing a few things on my mk 4 polo such as grill alloys coilovers exct. But the other day i stumbled accross a GTI polo i really liked the look of it i just need to work out weater to carry on with my mk 4 or buy a GTI . any other peoples views on this would be good. thanks

Epictrail.

Edited by Epictrail

  • Replies 25
  • Views 1.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

same boat mate.... but i really dont like the Facelift model for some reason to me its just ugly id have the GTi engine in a mk4 anyday but hey if i had the money n people to help thats what id do but i dont and cant lol, i prob just get a Vavler

Depends on your budget. A GTI is better than any Mk4 so go for it if the car is straight

If I had a very nearly stock mk4 I'd probably forget the numberplate on the way to pick up the GTI

i would rather have the gti engine in the mk4 aswell, i like the mk4 shape

Mk5 is same shape though really, with a much better dashboard, nicer headlamps/exterior and a fully galvanised shell :p

The Mk5 definately, having driven, been a passenger in both 4 & 5, and owned the mk5 prefer the 5 anyday. Gti's standard still I find make my head turn to look back.

I miss mine!!!

hmmm i'd rather have the gti but due to the extra money you'd have to spend on buying and insuring the car i'd probly stick with the mk4!

the dash is cheap and tacky like most new VWs lately ( step dad worked for VW ) got all the latests polos/golf n i hate the interior nice car but still i like the old mk4

the dash is cheap and tacky like most new VWs lately ( step dad worked for VW ) got all the latests polos/golf n i hate the interior nice car but still i like the old mk4

I have owned both a mk4 and now have a GTI, the dash on a mk4 is plain and ugly!

The 6N2 dash is a hell of an improvent on the mk4's!

Mk4 dash, its ergonomic and well built but just looks horrid and dated. Mk5 still looks modern inside although ergonomics are pretty crap

Which mk4 is it?

If its 16V then its a harder dission to make than say a 1.0L.

If its not a 16V mk4 you have. Just remember the GTI's love there petrol. My mate had one and he was just always putting petrol in it and with the current prices of petrol its something to think about. Also if the pedal box and gearbox haven't be done you need to factor in that they might break and you will need to take the car somewhere to get them done. Or take time off yourself to do them. Both are fiddley pain in the arse jobs.

Depending on how old you are, you should look at insurance as well.

Mine aint to bad on juice, mostly motorway driving and i see between 270 - 310 miles to a tank!

Well its subjective to how you drive it. As with any car.

^^^

True and i tend to drive ergonomically on the motorway sticking to 70, but then like to open it up on the country lanes!

Considering some 1.6GLX owners were getting around under 35 MPG the GTI is very good on fuel

mk5 hands down. better looking and faster!

mk5 hands down. better looking and faster!

i like mk4's :) ..the mk5 is nicer on the inside thats about it i think

wow i didnt expect this many replies i have looked into both routs more and like a lot of you said a modded mk 4 does turn more heads and no one likes a super thirsty car lol. how would i cheak to see if the gear box is ok or dodgy in the GTI just incase i got one in the future. thanks for all the help and replies.Does any one no any good places where i could get bit to modd me mk 4 ?? thanks .Epictrail.

www.mk4.com/alltheway!

mk4 for me if its a valver or a decent clean car if not GTI

Has to be Mk5 GTI for me, i think they're very good looking, the interior is lovely and dash is wicked.

mk4 16v.

This debate never ends, it all comes down to what look you prefer. If you like the 90s styling of the mk4 go for that, if you prefer a more modern cut with more refinery, then choose the GTi.

The GTI with ease.

As long as the pedal box and gearbox recal work has been completed then I can't see any reason as to why the 6N Polo 16v is better than the 6N2 Polo GTI.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.