Skip to content

GTi advice?

Featured Replies

have been thinking about getting a GTi and wondered if there is anything to keep an eye out for- whiny boxes, dodgy electrics etc...? have been without a Polo for about 4 years and thinking about coming back... :-D

thanks

  • Replies 17
  • Views 1.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

A Mk5 GTi?

The gearbox is the big one...prone to failure and requires replacing/rebuilding. Expensive + common fault. I'd have one of these cars if it weren't for the time bomb between the engine and wheels.

There's lots of threads on common problems on here and on Uk-Polos. I must stress though that despite a lot of owners on here complaning about gearbox problems, there are still a large amount of cars who have no problems. Mine is on 45k with no problems and Si_GTI has gone over 75k

A Mk5 GTi?

The gearbox is the big one...prone to failure and requires replacing/rebuilding. Expensive + common fault. I'd have one of these cars if it weren't for the time bomb between the engine and wheels.

You bloody drama queen!

The gearboxes can sometimes be a bit fragile yes, but mine has done 92,000 miles and is still just fine, touch wood. Quite simply, they just don't take abuse, so don't abuse it!

Re electrical faults, sometimes you can have fun and games with the electric windows when the motor, the regulator, or the switch(es) fail, but nothing major to look out for that I can remember. Make sure the cambelt is changed on schedule and the service history is good, check the standard wheels for corrosion if buying an original (non-modifed) example and factor in the cost of a refurb (£300-400 from a professional refurbishment company) if necessary. Obviously make sure the car is straight and ask about accident damage or anything like that, if you have to.

Good little cars, solid and reasonably reliable, handling is a bit sloppy as standard but coilovers are your friend and will sort you right out! :D

Cheers

There's lots of threads on common problems on here and on Uk-Polos. I must stress though that despite a lot of owners on here complaning about gearbox problems, there are still a large amount of cars who have no problems. Mine is on 45k with no problems and Si_GTI has gone over 75k

You replied as I was typing my first response :D I had a full gearbox oil change at 75k miles, a precaution more than anything :)

I'd hate to have a car where I have to mince around because I'm worried giving it a little stick will see the gearbox wilt.

I know four people locally with GTi's...Scott went through two gear boxes before moving onto a Ibiza, Dillion has had one refurb., Richard one refurb. and moved onto a Clio 172 when he thought it was going to happen again, and Mouse is still on his first....3 out of 4 with failures + all the incidences you hear about on here...that's not confidence inspiring.

I just don't worry about it. My car just takes the abuse when I give it some. I am definately aware it could happen, but the car is so good otherwise it doesn't bother me

We'll see how much it bothers you if it does happen then...

I've been thru 4 gearboxes on my mk4 16v and yeah it pissed me off when it happened but i felt it was worth the hassle to get it back....with my GTI now tho...i bought it knowing the gearbox was a possible big issue...but I'm happy enough to put up with it if/when it happens

the car more than makes up for its drawbacks

We'll see how much it bothers you if it does happen then...

I know. It will bother me IF it happens :lol:

Pedal boxes to.

The pedal box was only an issue on some cars, there is a website that you can go onto to check if your car was/is affected, mine wasn't.

The gearbox is a problem, but lets be honest, it's not the biggest worry in the world. I give mine a lot of stick and the clutch is on it's way out atm, but *touches wood* the gearbox is ok to date. It's not really any more of a problem for me than the fact that I know my G40 box isn't going to last very long at all, I just live with it.

The GTi, is a really nice little car to drive, it handles like an absolute dream, I can throw it round any corner at pretty much any speed and know that it won't let me down. It's got enough power there for when I need it, to get me out of trouble or for cruising down the motorway, and it's still a fairly sensible daily drive. I haven't modified mine much at all apart from the coilovers and BMC induction kit and I think that's the way I'll keep it, I can't see me ever getting rid of that car, I love it to bits 8-)

I forgotten who said it but take some negative reviews in some magazines with a pinch of salt about the handling. It is pretty good as standard, I noticed a vast improvement coming from a Mk5 Fiesta. Yes you may say only a normal Fiesta, but a supermini that was regarded as being the best handling of the bunch. It's obviously not as good as a 106 GTI as standard, but I did choose the Polo over one for a reason

i loved my mk5 gti to bits but they have so many faults i wouldnt buy another one for fear of something breaking

i loved my mk5 gti to bits but they have so many faults i wouldnt buy another one for fear of something breaking

i take it we are talking gearboxes...? what else? i had a Mk4 8v before and had no probs whatsoever with it- apart from general wear and tear and was thinking that the GTI might be a good version for me to get back into Polos? not so sure now. don't think my other half would be that impressed if he was forever working on my new motor.

ye pretty much gearbox only...but its quite a big thing realy

in the end you have to mak up your own mind.....i went through gearboxes whereas some guys are on there originals but as i said i absolutely loved my gti

photos022mp9.jpg

just make sure it has leathers!

Sally do you know the website you can check it out on!

My GTI gave me little problems. Gearbox was not one of them, but I drive for a living, so i never thrashed it, have the works van for that. The passenger window was a bit strange, sometimes worked, sometimes not!

I however would not buy another one. I brought a Mini, and its a class above the polo. I must admit i thought the handling in the polo was shocking if I'm honest. So unpredicable. It made back roads unfun. The Mini has given the fun back, shows what can be achived.

I think the Gti is lacking something, maybe lots of little things, not sure, but its someone, incomplete.

Cheers

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.