Skip to content

Should I be put off?

Featured Replies

Hi people,

New here and this is my first post :-p hope I've put this in the right section.

Basically I need some advice, I am looking at buying a Polo GTI, but I'm worried about these tales of gearbox trouble.

Should I be put off buying one? I really like the car, it has everything I want, and I was sure I was going to get one until I found the gearbox thing, so is it a big enough deal (and cost) to make me look elsewhere?

Thanks alot for any help

Andy

  • Replies 7
  • Views 1.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

dint put me of, i had a gearbox prob on my old mk4 think its a lil issue with polos bud

Started on a positive, now that I didn't expect!

Should have said, its 2000-2002 GTI's I'm looking at.

didnt put me off and i went thru 4 gearboxes on my mk4, every car has their probs, just happens to be the gearbox with the gti's

its a risk u take

Mmm, its a difficult one.

All makes of car have their faults and niggles, but I do think the gearbox issues they have would put me off buying one.

If it was a cheap and or simple to repair problem I wouldn't mind, but the gearboxes are very expensive to buy and have fitted. The gearbox is afterall probably the second most expensive single part of the car barr the engine and if it were to fail on a car as new as that I'd be very pissed off. It doesn't seem to be mileage or use related either, it either happens or it don't. Unfortunately it happens far too often for my liking.

OGMDX wasn't put off by 4, yes FOUR :shock: gearbox failures (must be VERY VERY keen on his Polo!) and Jason11 seems to think its just a "lil issue" with Polo's. Personally I think its totally unacceptable and if we were talking about a Saxo or Corsa everyone would be slagging them off and saying how shit they were.

My friend didn't see it in quite the same light when her immaculate low mileage MK4 Golf SE destroyed its diff/gearbox. VW wanted nearly 2k to replace it! :shock:

Are the more modern VW's still a quality product? IMO, no I don't think so, yet their resale values are still high? Badge snobbery still plays a big part in the consumer world.

All I can say is if you do buy one, get one from a reputable (if there is such a thing!) dealer. Insist on a decent 12 month minimum warrantee - parts and labour. The initial extra outlay could be well worth spending.

Hope this insight helps, sorry if you think its all negative!

Edited by breadman

I've had mine rebuilt twice, what a downer when i cant drive it, but i rung up my local vw dealership like 10 mins ago, and they are going to replace the pedal box as it is a fault and have a good look at it for free! so I'm happy

at the time i was very very keen on my mk4 (the 4 box car :lol:)

it was also cheaper/easier to sort n replace gearbox than find a new car when i was firstly a bit low on funding, and secondly refusing to do what i would call a downgrade in cars

first time gearbox went it cost nearly £550 including replacing clutch too while garbox was off for recon, time after that i had it done on warranty as the recon box didnt last 3 month's :shock:

the last time tho cost a lil over £100 altho i think i was given a 1.0L gearbox instead as the car was a lot higher in the revs than it shoulda been, was all good tho, increased the accelleration brilliantly :D

overall i loved my valvers ability to just stick to the road allowing me to chuck it round corners, and i personally thought it was bloody quick for what it was, for me it was worth it and didnt cost as much as it could have, its all about looking in the right places and having patience in finding the right solution at a decent price

my 2p

Buy mine, it's got 18 months warrenty on it. ;)

PM me for more info.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.