Skip to content

Polo Mk4..Which is better...1.4 16v or 1.6 8v...

Featured Replies

Guys, I'm migrating from my Mk3 GT to a mk4...just trying to work out which is better to get...the 1.6glx which is 8v I believe or the 1.4 16v...

is there a difference in power between the two and is there a massive difference on fuel?

Thanks! 8-)

  • Replies 12
  • Views 3.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

16v everytime, it has 100bhp whereas the 1.6 has around 15-20 less (someone will quote the exact bhp I'm sure). 1.6 is meant to be quite torquey

the 1.6 8v is 75 bhp and the 1.4 16v is 100bhp.

To be honest i haven't been in either so i cant comment on the fuel question

power figures is as above

i had a 16v n i loved it...really revvy engine, pretty damn nippy for what they are

1.6's as far as I'm aware are more motorway cruisers than anything else

1.4 16v everytime

For power anyway

Edited by Dub James

i hav a 1.6 8v cl nice tourqe engine, but the 16v is alot quicker, the fuel consumption isnt that brilliant but i guarentee that its alot better than the 16v on fuel.....hope that helps

Dan

Edited by higgo

16v fuel consumption isnt bad at all. i haven't noticed much of a difference between mine and my old corsa 1.2. there a lot quicker than 1.6 cl and look a lot better (imo!)

and i would say, MUST be more fun to drive, the engines LOVE IT!

last few weeks i have been calculating my mpg in my 1.4 16v

40 litres gets me 320miles which works out at 36.8mpg thats me driving normal on a mix of roads including b roads and motorways @ 80ish and in town stoping and starting. i recon i could nudge 40mpg if i dove it conservatively

I love my valver, its a good strong engine and loves the rev's but 2bh i drive it like an old man mainly but they go when they want to !

Erm the fuel consumption realy does vary on your driving style, i do quite alot of town driving and its shit with fuel (imo) but when you take it steady and don't do to much stopping and starting then it does pick up to be a respectable figure (30 - 35 mpg)

Also very nippy little cars and with decent tyres and suspension can be very very good in the twistys, can keep up with my friends mk2 16v ibiza in the corners, dare i say its faster in the corners :ninja: and the straights it keeps up with him to about 50 mph !

Valver wins every time imo, best mk4 you can get although there aint much to compare it to between it and the rest of the range ! Lol :nod:

I've had both....

both good cars my 1.6 was definatly a more reliable engine and you could rag the crap into it and never actualy argued with me lol.... fuel consuption is the same tbo not really any difference....

all the power on the 1.6 is low down were as the 1.4 is all high up so depends what sort of driving you prefer....

I'd have thought fuel would be about the same, i get about 36ish on mine thats having some fun and motorways everyday.

Again depends what you want the car for, if you want quick, good looking, fun, and the same fuel economy as the 1.6 id say get teh valver

if you want torque and the same economy as a valver with out as much power or fun then go for the 1.6

INSURANCE will be the biggest difference with the 16v being gr10 not sure wt the 1.6 is

16v all day longggg, besides all your gona do if you buy a 8v is spend weeks searching for 16v bumpers to paint and fit to it!!!

save the hassle and buy a 16vto begin with!! fuel consumption isnt too bad, depends how you drive it...

I've just bought a 1.4 16v and I love it. Very strong pulling little engine and pretty good on the fuel too. Even my terrible driving got me 38mpg which makes it the most economical car iv had next to my 1.0 Mk3 coupe haha.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.