Skip to content

Can we clean up the forum

Featured Replies

Guys,Gals,

I have watched with a saddened heart the forum deteriorating for some time now and its time that something was done. Biting my tongue on what i would really like to put in this post.

Random thread picked at random - strangely the top of the pile as i write this

http://www.clubpolo.co.uk/forum/index.php?showtopic=340386

This is a typical example of the unecessary and unacceptable language used in posts.Why on earth has this forum become such an unmoderated free for all? So before all the mods come on here and tell me "try doing it yourself" or "we are busy doing other things" or some other reason for doing nothing about it - here is a quick list i have compiled of rot that has set in.

Here are a few quick search facts and figures to back up the point i am making

tw a t = 146 results

sh i t = 157 results

fu c k = 147 results

cu n t = 21 results

wan k er = 118 results

I'm sure i must be in there somewhere - always the way when someone actually speaks up about something.

Pretty sure the previous regime had filters that stopped this sort of thing - why has this not been adopted in the new website format?

I have written this post as a call for action rather than a whinge, I'm using the forum less and less and i am in no doubt that others are using it less and less with one of the main contributing factors being the tag the forum has as being for kids.

The forum used to be so much more than this - and still can be.

  • Replies 43
  • Views 2.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Tell the jeff who sold you the software that it's faulty

  • Speaking as one of the younger users, I think - as George Carlin once put it - the use of more 'colourful' language depends entirely on context. I certainly don't approve of verbal abuse towards any i

  • I'm with Kiz on this one. Id rather read people thoughts and accounts without swearing involved. It puts me and others off the forum as it really feels a less solubrious place to be when its on ther

I am pretty sure I have used bad language in posts before, but as long as it is not aimed at anyone then is it a problem? There is a lot worse floating about the internet.

Having said that a lot is just not needed and probably just used due to poor knowledge of the english language.

If you are unhappy with the language someone has used there is a report button as we can't go through and read every single post put up on here. I'll edit the example you gave, but any more why not just report them?

Also from now on I'll try and be more vigilant about it myself.

  • Author

Its not about the reporting, its more about appealing to everyone who uses the forum to refrain from doing it in the first place.

I kind of agree, but can appreciate that it would be hard to keep on top of it.

Personally, when writing on a public forum I tend to try and keep it clean. For example, I probably wouldn't say 'pig of a job' out loud, but I would on here as an alternative to my usual sweary demeanor. :lol:

There's no tmuch that can be done to stop people's language, but it would be nice if people kept it cleaner.

I'm probably guilty of this too, but I try not to be.

Edited by mbusby993

Understand what your saying Kiz, I do agree with Stephen as to if it's not aimed at anyone etc but it does need sorting and is been just takes a little time.

Can everyone please use the report button on posts like this, it helps MOD's to get it sorted and a lot faster than trawling page after page.

Speaking as one of the younger users, I think - as George Carlin once put it - the use of more 'colourful' language depends entirely on context. I certainly don't approve of verbal abuse towards any individual, but if someone wants to use the word 'shit' to describe for example the cup holders in the mk2f (which they are), I think that's perfectly acceptable. I'm against any sort of global censor, and think taking offense to a word without regard for context is conservative and archaic.

Club polo is one of the kindest forums on the internet to be honest. Very rarely do you see a thread of people arguing and swearing at each other. You also very very rarely see some one offending someone's car in the build section.

The main part of the forum for arguments is the technical forums when people disagree on how something should be done.

I bet the f ones are people saying ' I can't undo this fing bolt'. A banned word list on the forum's not needed though. Have you tried posting on carthrottle? Everything's bloody banned!

I do see where you're coming from though. But the majority of swearing and arguing comes from new members (sorry if your a new member) who come and post on a few threads or put some threads up and then leave after upsetting people. But that happens everywhere on the internet.

Edited by vdoubleu

I'm with Kiz on this one.

Id rather read people thoughts and accounts without swearing involved. It puts me and others off the forum as it really feels a less solubrious place to be when its on there.

I dont think the "it doesnt hurt anyone" holds any water. Too many bad things come from the first little acceptance.

I just think we are better than that and for some reason polo enthusiasts mostly seem to be a decent bunch. Especially compared to many other car forums.

Now if you were in the vicinity of my polo when I'm working on it, you would think that swear words are all I knew.

However, thats in the moment, and I'm often frustrated as I dont really know what I'm doing with cars, and it seems there is no activity you can do in the world of car maintenance or modification that doesnt involve at least a skinned knuckle. If a bolt could possibly fall down the inaccesible hole not matter how unlikely, the laws of physics will bend to ruin my day!

Generally, when you write stuff on here, you have time to work out what you want to say. Why not come accross as at least a little inteligent?

I dont think this is for the mods, (it would be if it was abusive) more of a ask for people to keep it clean and make us look like the decent bunch of car folk we are.

Edited by Retrotub

it seems there is no activity you can do in the world of car maintenance or modification that doesnt involve at least a skinned knuckle. If a bolt could possibly fall down the inaccesible hole not matter how unlikely, the laws of physics will bend to ruin my day!

That is exactly what happens to me every time I work on one of my cars.

But I agree when you do come to posting that experience up on here usually you have calmed down enough to at least pass for a sane person.

Exactly, don't really see the need for swearing in posts.

I got frequently told off when the car was still on my girlfriend's parents drive for my foul language (they're quite old fashioned) and I think they genuine thought it was all I knew. But when you're typing up a post it's just not necessary. It takes the same amount of time to just have a bit of civility.

:D

oh fiddlesticks.....

Swearing - a mark of humour, passion and motherf....g emotion.

  • Author

Swearing is statistically linked to a person being uneducated, so you come across stupid and an idiot.

Which is why i created this topic - to appeal to people to refrain from doing it rather than a ban of free speech, so that as a club we dont look like childish fools.

'There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics.' said

Mark Twain - and I swear he is the telling the truth.

I used to trawl through the posts often removing anything i didnt see fit to be published on the forum. Not having a dig at the mods but sometimes trawlings needed and part of the responsibility. Sometimes you have to go to the work instead of waiting for it to come to you.

Ok i think we all use afew choice words when fixing cars. I burnt my hand 3 times on the turbo housing fiddling with my radiator the other day. Needless to say i swore like a methorfcuk but on the forum shit can very easily be replaced with rubbish very easily. Saying it originates from being stupid though i dont agree with. I've seen very smart people swear :/

Hi Kiz,

I support what you are saying. There is also some non-swearing English that needs improving as well. Some of the language is unreadable. Also I would like to see more accuracy when advice is given in the technical forums. Some of what is written is clearly wrong. It is the responsibility of everyone to inform those who need to know especially younger members who need to expand their knowledge. For instance, from my engineering background, I will only give advice on subjects I know about and not what I think I know. Thanks for your comments.

Regards

Phil

we have to remeber that people who buy a polo come looking for the forum, it's not a good look to have excessive swearing and text speak. This might be their first contact with the VW comunity, it needs to be a good impression

I must say, the unrestrained practice of language inferior to her majesy's english is quite ghastly, i really must empathize with the honourable gentleman raising this most valid of subject.

I should say quite the levels we've seen of late are, of such fibre we have today, all conspiring to bring our beautiful language into disrepute. And work to shrink it's reaches! I believe too that with such practice, other unsavoury habits violate us also!

It is lazy. Swearing could so often be replaced with comprehensive pin-pointing of inteligence but instead an identification of subject matter is all too often closed down into a universal rounding of gutter-level understanding. And people are getting addicted to it! We must fight this like any addiction!

This must be practiced by the individual. The alternative is enforcement, most contrary to what is desirable. We must use our freedoms to practice what is right!

Swearing shouldn't be appearing anywhere on the forum as we have a swear filter. But I'm guessing that if it is appearing then it's not working. It was set up to to pick up text speak too. Will look into it today and report back....

Notwithstanding the fact that careful use of specialist phrasing makes lawyers lots of dosh while being incomprehensible to the layperson, I'm exercising my freedom to point out to the honourable gentleman that practise is the acceptable verb form spelling.

Here are a few quick search facts and figures to back up the point i am making

tw a t = 146 results

sh i t = 157 results

fu c k = 147 results

cu n t = 21 results

wan k er = 118 results

I'm sure i must be in there somewhere - always the way when someone actually speaks up about something.

Pretty sure the previous regime had filters that stopped this sort of thing - why has this not been adopted in the new website format?

I've tested it and it still works. The word is still stored in its original uncensored format in the database tables and the conversion seems to be done on the 'front end'. So when you do a search for 'bad' words it will still return every post that its been used in but clicking into the thread you won't(shouldn't) see it. The post you link to has been updated now so I'm not sure what word was used.

The swear/bad word filter is exactly the same one as was on the old forum. Nothing changed and no swear words have been removed or added. However out of that list the only word that's on it is the C one which converts it to 'nice person'. But I just added Tw*t and wa*ker.

The team are happy to have this discussion regarding adding new ones but there is a very fine line between allowing members to express themselves and over moderating and treating people like children, which is something that has been experienced in the pass. However aggression and swearing aim at other members is never tolerated!

As for text speak I hate it!!! :) No, I really do. This is not a Club Polo issue but a nationwide issue. You should see some of the applications forms I get! The bad word filter does convert a lot of this already but i'm sure it could do with an update as language evolves and new words come into existence.

Swearing shouldn't be appearing anywhere on the forum as we have a swear filter. But I'm guessing that if it is appearing then it's not working. It was set up to to pick up text speak too. Will look into it today and report back....

Tell the jeff who sold you the software that it's faulty

Edited by matt01

  • Author

That Mikey made me howl with laughter!

Going to stress the point I was trying to make again - we shouldn't have to ban free speech and language should be used in moderation or limited to areas. People should be made aware of the problem and should refrain from using such language where it is not necessary. Any new visitors to the site are just confronted with obscenities and this is likely to end up in a damaged reputation or people not willing to sign up and become a member.

nice person

nice person iere ehre erw

sdfsadsa nice person sadasdasda

Edited by testDog

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.